Poll: Would you have dropped Griffiths yesterday?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes. Mason knows what he's doing.
3.81%
4 3.81%
No. Mason is putting names in the tombola.
96.19%
101 96.19%
Total 105 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Would you have dropped Griffiths yesterday?
#11
Not against taking Griffiths out to protect him as he's so young for a first choice keeper. But frankly he didn't seem to be lacking confidence. He was just part of an absolute brain fart 15 mins.

Back in v Sheffield.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#12
No, he’s salvaged enough of our meagre points tally this season and was perhaps overdue an off day. Even with a better backup I’d have persisted, especially with a change at CH also; and I’d have instead perhaps looked to have rested him after a second stinker.

But I don’t think it changed much yesterday, which is very fortunate for Mason. Although he was beaten too easily for the second all three were because of cock-ups in front of JW and I doubt JG could have done anything about the first or third goals.

So although for me it was a dumb and unnecessary decision, it wasn’t the bigger problem. He made the required changes and their replacements came in looking very average indeed. Yesterday was the type of performance you’d expect after a three day break - not before one. That’s worrying.
Reply
#13
(12-07-2025, 01:18 PM)BasingBaggie Wrote:
(12-07-2025, 01:13 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: No way.
One bad game. Even the best keepers have a bad game from time to time.

Charlton goal? Are the defence confident of him (reverse could also be said). I am no fan of Wildsmith but Griffiths has made mistakes and ultimately it’s on the Manager to make those calls

He’d kept us in that game remember and the deflection went under him but the blame was no one closing down the shot
Reply
#14
Griffiths has been at fault or partly at fault for certain goals recently (Ipswich, Charlton, Swansea) but even despite this there are several games where he has played a huge part in winning games. He's a young player who will make mistakes. He is still hugely in credit as far as I'm concerned and definitely has the potential to be better than Palmer.

I don't see any sense in dropping Josh at the moment particularly given the complete lack of a reasonable alternative. We've generally been very fortunate to have real quality keepers at the club over the last 15 years or so but Wildsmith certainly falls into the category of exceptions to this along with Button and Fulop. He inspires no confidence whatsoever in his defenders or the crowd. Physically he just isn't big enough for a modern day goalkeeper.

By virtue of selecting this clown it really adds further questions against Mason's judgement.
Reply
#15
(12-07-2025, 12:49 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Wildsmith as backup? Absolutely not.

If we had a competent backup, yes.

+1
Reply
#16
He came over and apologised to the away end. He is a good young keeper and he wasn’t great against Swansea. I have no idea what they see in training, the option to rest him/change him wasn’t the worst call by Mason. The fact that we all think Wildsmith is shit and people in the away end were on his back immediately hardly helps. I would bring Griffiths back in on Tuesday night because the away end will be toxic enough as it is. However dropping Mepham is far more important than changing the keeper
Reply
#17
It doesn't say much for our goalkeeping coach if neither of our senior keepers are currently worthy of selection...
Reply
#18
No. Absolutely not. Griffiths has saved us more points than his odd mistake has cost and for the most part has played behind a defence I'm not convinced by. Also Griffiths should be the future, Wildsmith is out of contract in June. Plus where does this lead us to next when Wildsmith does the inevitable and chucks one in? OK Josh, you're fine again now.
A completely stupid decision.
Reply
#19
No chance. The only person on the planet who thought that was a good idea was the clown picking the team. Is it in his contract that he has to do at least one mental thing per game?
Reply
#20
Mason now has a man management problem.
If he drops Wildsmith now, it will just tell JG that it was a mistake and he can get away with his mistakes. So the pressure is off him.
It tells Wildsmith he doesn't have confidence in him.
So when JG gets injured....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: