In support of Mason
#41
Fans pays their money and are entitled to voice their opinions. You shouldn't boo your team and chant Mason out during a game, it's embarassing and has the opposite effect one would think - thing is it didn't did it? They all woke the fuck up. I do wonder if they'll be awake next Saturday?
Reply
#42
Without doubt for me, there has been a helluva lot of over the top Mason bashing across the various social media channels. All summer, most supporters were saying that their expectations were a lot lower and mid table and flirting with play offs was acceptable in their eyes as we continued to battle finance issues. Throw in a big squad turnaround, losing 2 of the better players and appointing a novice, I would have expected to see us mid table at this stage of the season.

That's not to say Mason can't get criticism, but there's very rarely any nuance and balance, especially after fans have made their minds up on someone. I very much see this bias on here and on social media. Not that people will recognise that bias in themselves, no doubt they will absolutely refute it.

He's done some good work, he's made plenty of mistakes. That's pretty much what I would have expected a novice to make. We expected a difficult season, with difficult spells, that's exactly what we are seeing.

I still don't know if he's going to be a good manager or not, not after just 18 games. He's a good coach, the players have enjoyed the sessions and they are very much united behind him. That's a good foundation to build upon. I think he's an intelligent bloke who will improve his in game management which has been his downfall. For me, unless we look in danger of slipping into relegation, I think Bilkul will stick with him, certainly whilst the squad are right behind him.
Reply
#43
(12-01-2025, 11:10 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I'm actually a bit fed up with some of our fan base's attitude at the minute. The massive issue which seems completely overlooked by many is the big overhaul of playing staff due to FFP meaning we have to get rid of big earners. This is added to by a new young manager, after an old experienced one failed miserably, who has clearly been very highly thought of still finding his feet, after just 18 games. We've had a fair wobble, but some seem to think once we dip below top 10 it's time to pull the trigger. It's bonkers.

Mason only deserves the bullet if we get bottom 4-5 and we go off the rails, like it did under Bruce. He's not even had half a season yet.Now we sit right in the middle of the table. It's not unexpected is it really considering what we've had to contend with?

Many on here seem to think anything other than being around the playoffs is the only acceptable level. Honestly, if we finish mid table, but start seeing something more positive coming then I'll take it. We are back to the kind of club we were 25 years ago for the time being, whilst we navigate the mess left behind. I also can forgive the club if our squad is a bit unbalanced. It's a season of more transition than most.

Too many fans expect too much, too soon in a spoilt child way.

I hope Mason proves those know it all types wrong as I'm fed up of the unrealistic expectations and entitlement some feel in a division littered with clubs of a similar history and support base as us, and the highlighted disaster Lai and his cronies left us with.

We actually have to have patience now.

Love a sanctimonious fan bashing post me. Who are all these spoilt, Ill educated, entitled supporters. Name names. If there’s so many of them it should be easy.

Me think you protesteth too much!

Look everywhere on social media. Whining unreasonable people AOTS.

It's fair enough to say this- sorry if it's upset you, you poor sensitive soul.

If it’s on Twitter post on Twitter. You posted it on here so fair to assume it was targeted on here.

Truth is very few posters expect top 6. I believe the pre-season poll and all subsequent polls back this up, with the vast majority predicting us being outside of the play offs.

Regarding the PSR issue, surely if every penny counts it is crucial to question signings? Remember, we are not a squad full of free transfers, we have spent considerable money. It is therefore valid to analyse the quality of those making the decisions.
Same goes for appointing a first time coach? Was it the correct decision.

The truth is these are the points being raised but people on the extremes choose to exaggerate in order to try and make a point. Whereas if the point is truly valid no exaggeration is necessary.

Of all the problems the club has at present, the fans are way down the list. You are basically targeting the  group who have the least effect on what happens in the boardroom or on the pitch. And are the only ones that pay for the privilege.
Reply
#44
(12-01-2025, 11:23 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 11:10 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I'm actually a bit fed up with some of our fan base's attitude at the minute. The massive issue which seems completely overlooked by many is the big overhaul of playing staff due to FFP meaning we have to get rid of big earners. This is added to by a new young manager, after an old experienced one failed miserably, who has clearly been very highly thought of still finding his feet, after just 18 games. We've had a fair wobble, but some seem to think once we dip below top 10 it's time to pull the trigger. It's bonkers.

Mason only deserves the bullet if we get bottom 4-5 and we go off the rails, like it did under Bruce. He's not even had half a season yet.Now we sit right in the middle of the table. It's not unexpected is it really considering what we've had to contend with?

Many on here seem to think anything other than being around the playoffs is the only acceptable level. Honestly, if we finish mid table, but start seeing something more positive coming then I'll take it. We are back to the kind of club we were 25 years ago for the time being, whilst we navigate the mess left behind. I also can forgive the club if our squad is a bit unbalanced. It's a season of more transition than most.

Too many fans expect too much, too soon in a spoilt child way.

I hope Mason proves those know it all types wrong as I'm fed up of the unrealistic expectations and entitlement some feel in a division littered with clubs of a similar history and support base as us, and the highlighted disaster Lai and his cronies left us with.

We actually have to have patience now.

Love a sanctimonious fan bashing post me. Who are all these spoilt, Ill educated, entitled supporters. Name names. If there’s so many of them it should be easy.

Me think you protesteth too much!

Look everywhere on social media. Whining unreasonable people AOTS.

It's fair enough to say this- sorry if it's upset you, you poor sensitive soul.

If it’s on Twitter post on Twitter. You posted it on here so fair to assume it was targeted on here.

Truth is very few posters expect top 6. I believe the pre-season poll and all subsequent polls back this up, with the vast majority predicting us being outside of the play offs.

Regarding the PSR issue, surely if every penny counts it is crucial to question signings? Remember, we are not a squad full of free transfers, we have spent considerable money. It is therefore valid to analyse the quality of those making the decisions.
Same goes for appointing a first time coach? Was it the correct decision.

The truth is these are the points being raised but people on the extremes choose to exaggerate in order to try and make a point. Whereas if the point is truly valid no exaggeration is necessary.

Of all the problems the club has at present, the fans are way down the list. You are basically targeting the  group who have the least effect on what happens in the boardroom or on the pitch. And are the only ones that pay for the privilege.

I think you're being far too over sensitive and I don't want online finger pointing at specific posters. I'm just advocating patience and supporting a new manager. Of course it's a two way street where he has to be shown to be learning on the job, but as disappointing as some performances and the recent run of form has been we really aren't in a bad place at all.

I hope Mason has learnt a lot from Saturday and he proves the doubters wrong. As I said, considering the circumstances, Saturday seemed bigger than just 3 points, but that's only if we push on.

I really think we are somewhere between 6th and 12th in the big scheme.
Reply
#45
The problem for any manager bouncing around mid table is that he is only as good as his last result. If we'd lost on Saturday people would have been shouting for him to get the sack, some on X were calling for him to be sacked at half time. We win against a poor Swansea team and people are "in support of Mason". It could all change again on Saturday. The second half against Swansea and the first half against Cov proves that there is enough quality in the team to be competing for a top 6 position. That the players clearly like and support Mason is good, but it doesn't mean anything unless we get results. IMO the jury is still out on Mason, but I really want him to succeed and as others have said we have to get behind him while he's still in the job.
Reply
#46
(12-01-2025, 11:44 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 11:23 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 11:10 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I'm actually a bit fed up with some of our fan base's attitude at the minute. The massive issue which seems completely overlooked by many is the big overhaul of playing staff due to FFP meaning we have to get rid of big earners. This is added to by a new young manager, after an old experienced one failed miserably, who has clearly been very highly thought of still finding his feet, after just 18 games. We've had a fair wobble, but some seem to think once we dip below top 10 it's time to pull the trigger. It's bonkers.

Mason only deserves the bullet if we get bottom 4-5 and we go off the rails, like it did under Bruce. He's not even had half a season yet.Now we sit right in the middle of the table. It's not unexpected is it really considering what we've had to contend with?

Many on here seem to think anything other than being around the playoffs is the only acceptable level. Honestly, if we finish mid table, but start seeing something more positive coming then I'll take it. We are back to the kind of club we were 25 years ago for the time being, whilst we navigate the mess left behind. I also can forgive the club if our squad is a bit unbalanced. It's a season of more transition than most.

Too many fans expect too much, too soon in a spoilt child way.

I hope Mason proves those know it all types wrong as I'm fed up of the unrealistic expectations and entitlement some feel in a division littered with clubs of a similar history and support base as us, and the highlighted disaster Lai and his cronies left us with.

We actually have to have patience now.

Love a sanctimonious fan bashing post me. Who are all these spoilt, Ill educated, entitled supporters. Name names. If there’s so many of them it should be easy.

Me think you protesteth too much!

Look everywhere on social media. Whining unreasonable people AOTS.

It's fair enough to say this- sorry if it's upset you, you poor sensitive soul.

If it’s on Twitter post on Twitter. You posted it on here so fair to assume it was targeted on here.

Truth is very few posters expect top 6. I believe the pre-season poll and all subsequent polls back this up, with the vast majority predicting us being outside of the play offs.

Regarding the PSR issue, surely if every penny counts it is crucial to question signings? Remember, we are not a squad full of free transfers, we have spent considerable money. It is therefore valid to analyse the quality of those making the decisions.
Same goes for appointing a first time coach? Was it the correct decision.

The truth is these are the points being raised but people on the extremes choose to exaggerate in order to try and make a point. Whereas if the point is truly valid no exaggeration is necessary.

Of all the problems the club has at present, the fans are way down the list. You are basically targeting the  group who have the least effect on what happens in the boardroom or on the pitch. And are the only ones that pay for the privilege.

I think you're being far too over sensitive and I don't want online finger pointing at specific posters. I'm just advocating patience and supporting a new manager. Of course it's a two way street where he has to be shown to be learning on the job, but as disappointing as some performances and the recent run of form has been we really aren't in a bad place at all.

I hope Mason has learnt a lot from Saturday and he proves the doubters wrong. As I said, considering the circumstances, Saturday seemed bigger than just 3 points, but that's only if we push on.

I really think we are somewhere between 6th and 12th in the big scheme.
Maybe I am being over-sensitive and that's fine to say, but by slating fans for being over-critical, you yourself are being over-critical of the fans. Surely you can see that?

Ok, Big Bob from Bearwood may throw his toys out the pram and scream for Mason out or Phillips to be dropped or Nestor to be sacked, but that's what being a football fan is all about. Big Bob will be the only one, from that list, still here in 10 or 20 years is my guess and that's irrespective of whether we are in the Champions League or the Conference.
It's a game played over 90 minutes and that's 90 individual minutes with each one capable of triggering a multitude of emotions from elation to despair and everything in between. If you take these emotions out then the game disappears or becomes bowls or something. Saturday was a perfect example of that range of emotions and a lot of the fans you are criticising were still there in the 46th minute despite all seeming lost. Many of them probably posted their frustrations at half time, but they didn't go anywhere. That's passion, faith, commitment, and without them / us there is no club, there is no game.

That's why I hate, generalised, fan-bashing. 

P.S Pretty much every fan I know, and I know a few, agree with your prediction, so not even sure where these entitled fans with ridiculous expectations come from but It's not Tipton!
Reply
#47
Mason is like all managers. He lives or dies by the results.
If we lose as long as we play attacking football I for one will still back Mason.
Mason job is to win games and play entertaining football.
Reply
#48
(12-01-2025, 10:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-01-2025, 10:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I'm actually a bit fed up with some of our fan base's attitude at the minute. The massive issue which seems completely overlooked by many is the big overhaul of playing staff due to FFP meaning we have to get rid of big earners. This is added to by a new young manager, after an old experienced one failed miserably, who has clearly been very highly thought of still finding his feet, after just 18 games. We've had a fair wobble, but some seem to think once we dip below top 10 it's time to pull the trigger. It's bonkers.

Mason only deserves the bullet if we get bottom 4-5 and we go off the rails, like it did under Bruce. He's not even had half a season yet.Now we sit right in the middle of the table. It's not unexpected is it really considering what we've had to contend with?

Many on here seem to think anything other than being around the playoffs is the only acceptable level. Honestly, if we finish mid table, but start seeing something more positive coming then I'll take it. We are back to the kind of club we were 25 years ago for the time being, whilst we navigate the mess left behind. I also can forgive the club if our squad is a bit unbalanced. It's a season of more transition than most.

Too many fans expect too much, too soon in a spoilt child way.

I hope Mason proves those know it all types wrong as I'm fed up of the unrealistic expectations and entitlement some feel in a division littered with clubs of a similar history and support base as us, and the highlighted disaster Lai and his cronies left us with.

We actually have to have patience now.

Love a sanctimonious fan bashing post me. Who are all these spoilt, Ill educated, entitled supporters. Name names. If there’s so many of them it should be easy.

C'mon Bob you were there Saturday.  Some anger was to be expected, fair enough, but e.g. the guy 2 seats down from me was apoplectic. Booing and bellowing. I've actually never heard him be positive and there was no vocal support from him after we turned it around. What's that if not a 'spoilt child' reaction? I've always defended our fans, having been many times to All of our neighbours I've always thought we were a bit more patient. 
Turning on your own team rarely works well, Saturday was more a reaction to the realisation at half time the coach was ordering a pint in the last chance saloon. Most of the complaints on here refer to the in game stuff. This is understandable, I've got a list of questions myself on that. Ultimately the manager will sink or swim based on how he deals with it. I maintain the position if you appoint a rookie you need to give him a chance. I sincerely hope that in this data driven age the senior club management are hopefully querying the approach and what the manager plans to do about the obvious issues, and more importantly helping him where they can.
Reply
#49
(12-01-2025, 12:07 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Mason is like all managers. He lives or dies by the results.
If we lose as long as we play attacking football I for one will still back Mason.
Mason job is to win games and play entertaining football.

Well it's not, is it? If there is evidence of a plan to break teams down and get into scoring positions then that's fine because if the players do their job we'd get goals and that's ultimately what is required to get anywhere. This has been in short supply until now and hence why he's had the criticism. The word "patience" has been used but it wears thin when there are no patterns to suggest we are improving or even treading water as a team. One half has got a lot of people saying "told you so" already. Let's hope they are right.
Reply
#50
Our fan base does have an air of arrogance about it this season 'how dare teams actually stop us playing', 'how dare we only be a couple of wins away from a play-off place. We should be comfortably in the play-offs'. 'How dare we see a poorer quality squad and see poorer results due to cost cutting'. 'How dare we see a rookie manager make mistakes'. Wah, wah, wah.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)