So then - this week’s poll
#31
Sack now.
Reply
#32
I declared my thoughts on Mason a few weeks ago and nothing has changed. His after match comments yesterday confirmed as to why things will not get better. The decision to sub MJ to help balance the side was the actions of a complete moron. We lost any forward movement we had, put us on the back foot. MJ must be thinking why he bothers. Sooner Mason is gone the better.
Reply
#33
(11-23-2025, 03:41 AM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 10:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 10:07 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:38 PM)CIM Wrote: If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.

…you take a massive gamble with the clubs future by employing a rookie manager and then fans blame the manager?

I've not seen anyone defending Nestor. There was even a thread on here called "Nestor clear your desk" and it wasn't a Marie Kondo-esque exhortation to do some tidying.

I do think if the relegated teams + the other well funded ones were storming up the table, then fans might consider that promotion is unlikely and be more patient. But the unexpected weakness of so many teams this season + plus a general lack of goals has made fans tetchy.

I don’t even think it’s that Squid, like I know I’ve been amongst the biggest detractors of Mason, but my desire for his sacking isn’t based on  the relative weakness of the division  or how other teams are dong, it’s based on the sheer fact he’s doing a really, really bad job. If we were seeing players improve, if we were seeing progress that suggested this season was a worthwhile year of transition, id be supportive, but we are not. I couldn’t give a damn about teams around us (other than ensuring we are above at least 3 in the league) as I didn’t really expect more than a top half finish this year, but with some visible plan taking shape. Unfortunately we are seeing absolutely nothing of any value other than Mason being paid to play at being a manager, and frankly as a club and a fan base we deserve much better.

I'm tempted to agree, but actually I think that is the sort of thing that fans say and don't really mean. Ultimately, there's a limit to how "good" or improving" a losing team can look if most of the teams around you are stronger. Whereas this season, the league is weak and therefore we should be beating far more teams then we are currently.

Which is exactly what other teams fans will be saying about their clubs. We aren’t even halfway through the season, by the end of it, I suspect the relegated clubs and those who invested will be filling most if not all of the top six places in the league. 

I also didn’t say fans were defending Nestor, but as the man who employs the head coach/manager is he really going to sack two managers in six months? I doubt it, and even if he does, would it solve the problem? Nearly two months searching the super computer database yielded TM and Mason so perhaps it’d be third time lucky!
Reply
#34
Two things can be true.

Mason hasn't been great.

Nestor has shown with the two managers he's picked thus far and his summer transfer activity that he shouldn't be given another chance to mess it up.
Reply
#35
(11-23-2025, 09:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 03:41 AM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 10:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 10:07 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: …you take a massive gamble with the clubs future by employing a rookie manager and then fans blame the manager?

I've not seen anyone defending Nestor. There was even a thread on here called "Nestor clear your desk" and it wasn't a Marie Kondo-esque exhortation to do some tidying.

I do think if the relegated teams + the other well funded ones were storming up the table, then fans might consider that promotion is unlikely and be more patient. But the unexpected weakness of so many teams this season + plus a general lack of goals has made fans tetchy.

I don’t even think it’s that Squid, like I know I’ve been amongst the biggest detractors of Mason, but my desire for his sacking isn’t based on  the relative weakness of the division  or how other teams are dong, it’s based on the sheer fact he’s doing a really, really bad job. If we were seeing players improve, if we were seeing progress that suggested this season was a worthwhile year of transition, id be supportive, but we are not. I couldn’t give a damn about teams around us (other than ensuring we are above at least 3 in the league) as I didn’t really expect more than a top half finish this year, but with some visible plan taking shape. Unfortunately we are seeing absolutely nothing of any value other than Mason being paid to play at being a manager, and frankly as a club and a fan base we deserve much better.

I'm tempted to agree, but actually I think that is the sort of thing that fans say and don't really mean. Ultimately, there's a limit to how "good" or improving" a losing team can look if most of the teams around you are stronger. Whereas this season, the league is weak and therefore we should be beating far more teams then we are currently.

Which is exactly what other teams fans will be saying about their clubs. We aren’t even halfway through the season, by the end of it, I suspect the relegated clubs and those who invested will be filling most if not all of the top six places in the league. 

I also didn’t say fans were defending Nestor, but as the man who employs the head coach/manager is he really going to sack two managers in six months? I doubt it, and even if he does, would it solve the problem? Nearly two months searching the super computer database yielded TM and Mason so perhaps it’d be third time lucky!

It depends what you mean by solve the problem. If it means we stay in the division the (probably) a change in manager will impact that, although I don't yet think we're at genuine risk of relegation.

Yet......
Reply
#36
(11-22-2025, 07:42 PM)1952 Wrote: I'd keep. Performances have improved, today we looked a threat. Can see why he would change MJ although didn't agree with it. IJ defends better. Easy for those to say he should have taken Molumby off in hindsight. Should have put Dike on for Heggebo though.

?.  We can't just keep on switching managers. We are definitely improving as a whole. Heggebo is at last getting into scoring positions. Mikey is becoming more consistent. This is obviously down to coaching. But we do have an imbalanced squad, a squad of players who are mainly nothing more than average. Let's see what happens in the January window. Hopefully address some of our needs.
Reply
#37
(11-23-2025, 09:34 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 07:42 PM)1952 Wrote: I'd keep. Performances have improved, today we looked a threat. Can see why he would change MJ although didn't agree with it. IJ defends better. Easy for those to say he should have taken Molumby off in hindsight. Should have put Dike on for Heggebo though.

?.  We can't just keep on switching managers. We are definitely improving as a whole. Heggebo is at last getting into scoring positions. Mikey is becoming more consistent. This is obviously down to coaching. But we do have an imbalanced squad, a squad of players who are mainly nothing more than average. Let's see what happens in the January window. Hopefully address some of our needs.

Worth remembering in the summer we move on from Maja, Dike, Wallace and Grant. Gives us a real chance to balance the squad. In a year where I don't think we have a squad capable of getting in the top six regardless of who is in charge, we may as well give him the season, then if we want to change at that point a new man can have a full pre-season with a much more balanced squad.
Reply
#38
(11-23-2025, 09:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 09:34 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 07:42 PM)1952 Wrote: I'd keep. Performances have improved, today we looked a threat. Can see why he would change MJ although didn't agree with it. IJ defends better. Easy for those to say he should have taken Molumby off in hindsight. Should have put Dike on for Heggebo though.

?.  We can't just keep on switching managers. We are definitely improving as a whole. Heggebo is at last getting into scoring positions. Mikey is becoming more consistent. This is obviously down to coaching. But we do have an imbalanced squad, a squad of players who are mainly nothing more than average. Let's see what happens in the January window. Hopefully address some of our needs.

Worth remembering in the summer we move on from Maja, Dike, Wallace and Grant. Gives us a real chance to balance the squad. In a year where I don't think we have a squad capable of getting in the top six regardless of who is in charge, we may as well give him the season, then if we want to change at that point a new man can have a full pre-season with a much more balanced squad.

We either embrace rebuilding the squad over several transfer windows or we don’t. Fans can’t have it both ways but many of Masons biggest detractors are the same fans that in previous years said building over the long term was the way forward. You either give managers and players time or you don’t, you can put a caveat 15 games into a season we should always be hovering around the play-offs.
Reply
#39
(11-23-2025, 09:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 09:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 09:34 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 07:42 PM)1952 Wrote: I'd keep. Performances have improved, today we looked a threat. Can see why he would change MJ although didn't agree with it. IJ defends better. Easy for those to say he should have taken Molumby off in hindsight. Should have put Dike on for Heggebo though.

?.  We can't just keep on switching managers. We are definitely improving as a whole. Heggebo is at last getting into scoring positions. Mikey is becoming more consistent. This is obviously down to coaching. But we do have an imbalanced squad, a squad of players who are mainly nothing more than average. Let's see what happens in the January window. Hopefully address some of our needs.

Worth remembering in the summer we move on from Maja, Dike, Wallace and Grant. Gives us a real chance to balance the squad. In a year where I don't think we have a squad capable of getting in the top six regardless of who is in charge, we may as well give him the season, then if we want to change at that point a new man can have a full pre-season with a much more balanced squad.

We either embrace rebuilding the squad over several transfer windows or we don’t. Fans can’t have it both ways but many of Masons biggest detractors are the same fans that in previous years said building over the long term was the way forward. You either give managers and players time or you don’t, you can put a caveat 15 games into a season we should always be hovering around the play-offs.

That changes if there becomes a realistic possibility of relegation. Unless you're Watford every club decides that they are "going to give the manager time" but if it's clearly not working then at some point you have to react. I'm not saying that we're at this point with Mason
Reply
#40
(11-23-2025, 10:05 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 09:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 09:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 09:34 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 07:42 PM)1952 Wrote: I'd keep. Performances have improved, today we looked a threat. Can see why he would change MJ although didn't agree with it. IJ defends better. Easy for those to say he should have taken Molumby off in hindsight. Should have put Dike on for Heggebo though.

?.  We can't just keep on switching managers. We are definitely improving as a whole. Heggebo is at last getting into scoring positions. Mikey is becoming more consistent. This is obviously down to coaching. But we do have an imbalanced squad, a squad of players who are mainly nothing more than average. Let's see what happens in the January window. Hopefully address some of our needs.

Worth remembering in the summer we move on from Maja, Dike, Wallace and Grant. Gives us a real chance to balance the squad. In a year where I don't think we have a squad capable of getting in the top six regardless of who is in charge, we may as well give him the season, then if we want to change at that point a new man can have a full pre-season with a much more balanced squad.

We either embrace rebuilding the squad over several transfer windows or we don’t. Fans can’t have it both ways but many of Masons biggest detractors are the same fans that in previous years said building over the long term was the way forward. You either give managers and players time or you don’t, you can put a caveat 15 games into a season we should always be hovering around the play-offs.

That changes if there becomes a realistic possibility of relegation. Unless you're Watford every club decides that they are "going to give the manager time" but if it's clearly not working then at some point you have to react. I'm not saying that we're at this point with Mason

I agree but with 15 games gone and 4 pts from the playoffs the clamour to sack him from some seems a tad premature. I am Switzerland with regards to Mason and indeed Nestor and our owners, my neutrality is born out of not having any real clue what they are looking to achieve.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: