This season tells me one thing…
#71
I do wonder whether the mix of people in charge - Mason, Morrison, Abella etc has an aura of lacking a clear imprint of who is the head honcho. The Megson/Burrows type combo had the ideal mix of players knowing who was in charge but with some very different experience and style of communication in the wings
Raw Sausage
Reply
#72
(11-10-2025, 08:49 AM)richbaggie Wrote: There's a really good comparison that could be made between Mason and Kieran McKenna at Ipswich. Both retired young due to injury and went down the coaching route and achieved the highest coaching badges available. Both picked up first jobs at relatively big clubs albeit Ipswich a division below but both rebooting with new owners.

I took a look at his start earlier. After a flying start in his first few games, they then struggled and tailed off in 2021. They had an awful start the season after and they wanted him out but they stuck with and they finished 11th. They then went on an incredible run as we know.

Now, I'm not saying Mason is as good as him. I genuinely don't know yet. I would imagine that he's had so many ideas flowing through his head these past few years of how he wants teams to play and how he would manage people. Hes now finding out which ideas work and what don't. He has and will continue to make mistakes because of his inexperience. At the moment, I am more relaxed than most in letting it play out, seeing if he can develop. Who knows, he may go the same way as Kieran McKenna or he might not have it in him to be a no.1. Give him time to find out....within reason.

Not sure this is entirely true Rich.... McKenna came in during the 21/22 season when Ipswich were struggling in League One - they went on a fantastic run almost immediately after he arrived but it wasn't enough for them to get close to the playoffs, and their form petered out in the final month or so when they were 10+ points adrift of the top 6. The following season they won promotion to the Championship and then to the PL the year after.

The difference here is that McKenna had an immediate impact at Ipswich - he turned round a struggling team and improved individuals to the point where many of the squad that was in the bottom half of League One were playing in the PL less than 3 years later. 

I'm not sure he's ever been under any pressure from their fans other than a couple of weeks ago when they were struggling to find their feet in the Championship. 

Whilst it's fair to compare McKenna and Mason from a playing career cut short and coaching perspective, I think they're poles apart in how they have adapted to management.
Reply
#73
(11-10-2025, 11:05 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 08:49 AM)richbaggie Wrote: There's a really good comparison that could be made between Mason and Kieran McKenna at Ipswich. Both retired young due to injury and went down the coaching route and achieved the highest coaching badges available. Both picked up first jobs at relatively big clubs albeit Ipswich a division below but both rebooting with new owners.

I took a look at his start earlier. After a flying start in his first few games, they then struggled and tailed off in 2021. They had an awful start the season after and they wanted him out but they stuck with and they finished 11th. They then went on an incredible run as we know.

Now, I'm not saying Mason is as good as him. I genuinely don't know yet. I would imagine that he's had so many ideas flowing through his head these past few years of how he wants teams to play and how he would manage people. Hes now finding out which ideas work and what don't. He has and will continue to make mistakes because of his inexperience. At the moment, I am more relaxed than most in letting it play out, seeing if he can develop. Who knows, he may go the same way as Kieran McKenna or he might not have it in him to be a no.1. Give him time to find out....within reason.

Not sure this is entirely true Rich.... McKenna came in during the 21/22 season when Ipswich were struggling in League One - they went on a fantastic run almost immediately after he arrived but it wasn't enough for them to get close to the playoffs, and their form petered out in the final month or so when they were 10+ points adrift of the top 6. The following season they won promotion to the Championship and then to the PL the year after.

The difference here is that McKenna had an immediate impact at Ipswich - he turned round a struggling team and improved individuals to the point where many of the squad that was in the bottom half of League One were playing in the PL less than 3 years later. 

I'm not sure he's ever been under any pressure from their fans other than a couple of weeks ago when they were struggling to find their feet in the Championship. 

Whilst it's fair to compare McKenna and Mason from a playing career cut short and coaching perspective, I think they're poles apart in how they have adapted to management.

I got the follow up season wrong having looked again but his first season was mixed. He won 6 of his first 8 but then only 5 of the last 15 which saw them fall away badly. So I think the point still stands. Early impact followed by a drop off. They stuck with him despite that and reaped the rewards the following year as he grew into the role.
Reply
#74
It would be interesting if Squid could do an historical view from the Ipswich fans, deep dive in that period of time under McKenna.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#75
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.
Yeah, tens of thousands of them, who've been doing the same thing for decades, even spreading it to their offspring. Idiots. Good job we have beacons of wisdom like you on this dump to tell us how it really is.

The truth is that the highlighted bit is extreme nonsense and nobody expects all of that, because we're actually not idiots and understand fully the game and team we have supported for decades, along with it's current struggles. Some of us, however are not scared to wear our hearts on our sleeves, when it comes to the club we love, even if that means we over-react sometimes and our opinions fluctuate with our emotions. I can want Mason out at 14:55 and a statue built by 5 o'clock, so what? Football is an emotive game. Thank god we have forums like this to vent, moan, celebrate.

What is unreasonable is going all in to defend a player, coach, owner who's time with this great club will be fleeting at best, and, in the process, belittling fans who will follow until their dying breath. Who's more important, an emotive fan who gets a bit hot under the collar now and again, but supports the club through thick and thin, or someone who is here for 1 or 2 season max and in 5 years will be no more than a decent quiz question.
Stop the fan bashing man.
Reply
#76
(11-10-2025, 12:05 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.
Yeah, tens of thousands of them, who've been doing the same thing for decades, even spreading it to their offspring. Idiots. Good job we have beacons of wisdom like you on this dump to tell us how it really is.

The truth is that the highlighted bit is extreme nonsense and nobody expects all of that, because we're actually not idiots and understand fully the game and team we have supported for decades, along with it's current struggles. Some of us, however are not scared to wear our hearts on our sleeves, when it comes to the club we love, even if that means we over-react sometimes and our opinions fluctuate with our emotions. I can want Mason out at 14:55 and a statue built by 5 o'clock, so what? Football is an emotive game. Thank god we have forums like this to vent, moan, celebrate.

What is unreasonable is going all in to defend a player, coach, owner who's time with this great club will be fleeting at best, and, in the process, belittling fans who will follow until their dying breath. Who's more important, an emotive fan who gets a bit hot under the collar now and again, but supports the club through thick and thin, or someone who is here for 1 or 2 season max and in 5 years will be no more than a decent quiz question.
Stop the fan bashing man.

So what you're saying is just let the place be a hissy fit of people talking utter shite? 

If you want that in abundance go onto Twitter or Facebook. There's plenty of morons spouting monosyllabic crap on there.
Reply
#77
(11-10-2025, 12:05 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.
Yeah, tens of thousands of them, who've been doing the same thing for decades, even spreading it to their offspring. Idiots. Good job we have beacons of wisdom like you on this dump to tell us how it really is.

The truth is that the highlighted bit is extreme nonsense and nobody expects all of that, because we're actually not idiots and understand fully the game and team we have supported for decades, along with it's current struggles. Some of us, however are not scared to wear our hearts on our sleeves, when it comes to the club we love, even if that means we over-react sometimes and our opinions fluctuate with our emotions. I can want Mason out at 14:55 and a statue built by 5 o'clock, so what? Football is an emotive game. Thank god we have forums like this to vent, moan, celebrate.

What is unreasonable is going all in to defend a player, coach, owner who's time with this great club will be fleeting at best, and, in the process, belittling fans who will follow until their dying breath. Who's more important, an emotive fan who gets a bit hot under the collar now and again, but supports the club through thick and thin, or someone who is here for 1 or 2 season max and in 5 years will be no more than a decent quiz question.
Stop the fan bashing man.

Don't fall into Dekka's net.  He uses hyperbolic language to call out people who he believes are using hyperbolic language.  He's only holding up a mirror of his own behaviour.

The bit in bold hasn't been said by anyone.  I think most want to be able to decipher a plan, see that something is taking shape and players looking like they're executing patterns of play or inventive set piece moves etc.

I think everyone hopes every manager we ever appoint is going to succeed.  It's interesting that Dekka had no leeway or intention of allowing ToMo time to get back into the saddle from his health treatment.  Why no leeway?  Because he didn't want him in the first place.  He's merely accusing others now of his own behaviour from the end of last season.  

As for Mason?  I can't make my mind up.  He's shown nothing yet, most the metrics are going in a downward direction and yet the valid response is "it's only been 14 games".  I think if you give him the season you've then got to give him 10 games into the following season to see what's been learnt.  I've been disappointed in how cautious he's been and when almost the entire ground don't understand team selections and mid-game substitutions then he's clearly not getting it right.  He doesn't give the impression that he's experimenting, learning  or trying to do anything innovative, that's where I think the lack of patience is born from.

It feels like he's only ever 3 games away from a crisis and getting sacked, he needs a bit of support from above.  If the club acknowledged we're in transition with the squad, that Mason is doing as expected and yes he's (to an extent) learning his role along the way but this was/is how it's going to be this season and he's "our Man", that would help elevate pressure.  Instead it feels like they've put the expectation of a play-off place out there and, consequently, 14 games or 14 years experience is irrelevant as results are demanded.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#78
(11-10-2025, 01:02 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 12:05 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.
Yeah, tens of thousands of them, who've been doing the same thing for decades, even spreading it to their offspring. Idiots. Good job we have beacons of wisdom like you on this dump to tell us how it really is.

The truth is that the highlighted bit is extreme nonsense and nobody expects all of that, because we're actually not idiots and understand fully the game and team we have supported for decades, along with it's current struggles. Some of us, however are not scared to wear our hearts on our sleeves, when it comes to the club we love, even if that means we over-react sometimes and our opinions fluctuate with our emotions. I can want Mason out at 14:55 and a statue built by 5 o'clock, so what? Football is an emotive game. Thank god we have forums like this to vent, moan, celebrate.

What is unreasonable is going all in to defend a player, coach, owner who's time with this great club will be fleeting at best, and, in the process, belittling fans who will follow until their dying breath. Who's more important, an emotive fan who gets a bit hot under the collar now and again, but supports the club through thick and thin, or someone who is here for 1 or 2 season max and in 5 years will be no more than a decent quiz question.
Stop the fan bashing man.

Don't fall into Dekka's net.  He uses hyperbolic language to call out people who he believes are using hyperbolic language.  He's only holding up a mirror of his own behaviour.

The bit in bold hasn't been said by anyone.  I think most want to be able to decipher a plan, see that something is taking shape and players looking like they're executing patterns of play or inventive set piece moves etc.

I think everyone hopes every manager we ever appoint is going to succeed.  It's interesting that Dekka had no leeway or intention of allowing ToMo time to get back into the saddle from his health treatment.  Why no leeway?  Because he didn't want him in the first place.  He's merely accusing others now of his own behaviour from the end of last season.  

As for Mason?  I can't make my mind up.  He's shown nothing yet, most the metrics are going in a downward direction and yet the valid response is "it's only been 14 games".  I think if you give him the season you've then got to give him 10 games into the following season to see what's been learnt.  I've been disappointed in how cautious he's been and when almost the entire ground don't understand team selections and mid-game substitutions then he's clearly not getting it right.  He doesn't give the impression that he's experimenting, learning  or trying to do anything innovative, that's where I think the lack of patience is born from.

It feels like he's only ever 3 games away from a crisis and getting sacked, he needs a bit of support from above.  If the club acknowledged we're in transition with the squad, that Mason is doing as expected and yes he's (to an extent) learning his role along the way but this was/is how it's going to be this season and he's "our Man", that would help elevate pressure.  Instead it feels like they've put the expectation of a play-off place out there and, consequently, 14 games or 14 years experience is irrelevant as results are demanded.

CA, I always completely honest with regards to TM, I don’t rate him as a manager and I found him to be incredibly condescending towards fans who disagreed with his ‘philosophy’ and towards teams that beat us playing football the ‘wrong way’. My opinion was based on his record as a manager both at WBA and the subsequent 15 or so years afterwards. 

The difference is Mason has managed 14 or so games as a manager and yet people are putting up threads asking if he should be sacked, who the next manager is, whilst currently we are 4 points adrift of the playoffs. I have no idea if he’s, good, bad or indifferent but the ott posts after a short run of poor results is not really something I’d call justified. 

Trying to justify knee jerk reactions that we’ve seen on here over the last few weeks is your prerogative, but given Mason is baggage free, I’d rather he was given more than a handful of games and a unbalanced squad to judge him by.
Reply
#79
In a consumerist world where customers demand to be satisfied, strong views are routinely polarised by the observer whilst counterpoints and hyperbole both celebrated, it’s a rich environment for petty oneupmanship.

God Bless this dump.
Reply
#80
Dekka, you allowed the fact you don’t like/rate him to want rid at the first opportunity. No leeway at all, you just wanted to be right.

And in this very thread you’re accusing people of not wanting this manager because he wasn’t their choice and not giving anyway just so they can be proven right.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: