11-09-2025, 02:26 PM
(11-09-2025, 12:35 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:(11-09-2025, 10:08 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote:(11-09-2025, 10:00 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:(11-09-2025, 02:33 AM)Jacko Wrote:(11-09-2025, 12:48 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: It's difficult to see how Edwards can turn that team around. He carried on Nathan Jones' good work at Luton but was unable to carry that on after relegation back to the Champ.
He might turn Wolves into a bunch of honest triers but I can't see him organising them enough for them to start grinding out wins on a semi-regular basis.
He won't come close to keeping The Shit up, but surely you're not giving Nathan Jones credit for Luton's promotion to the Premier League?
Why not? He’d built Luton up to that point, sure it was only November but he continued what was already there. Do you not remember Brian Talbot taking Fat Ron’s Mk2 team on? Had we not drawn Everton in the cup we’d have had every chance that season. Edward’s failed at Watford and initially kept Luton going with the momentum, they ran out of steam. I don’t blame him for their PL failure, that was a step too far for Luton, but it was a disastrous Chalpionship campaign the following season.
Nathan Jones is a nobber and he failed at Stoke (so have several others - that club was rotten) and he was bonkers to take the Southampton job. He’s doing what he did at Luton with Charlton though. They’re currently doing the best of the 3 promoted teams.
Jones definitely deserves huge credit for Luton getting up. Got them promoted to the Champ, got them into the play offs the season before and had them up near the top of the table when he left in November. He absolutely deserves his share of the credit .
So yes, Jacko, I am giving credit to Jones for providing the base on which Edwards succeeded.
Remember as well Luton were doing well under Jones when he left to go to Stoke. They then went to shit under the inspired leadership of Graham Jones. Nathan Jones came back in, halted that and had them looking like a decent team again.
Charlton are a similar level of club to Luton and it looks like Jones' is best suited to that type of club.
I think Nathan Jones is a very good manager, and someone I’d have bitten your hands off for in the summer as he’s a manager that makes the most out of what he has and can build a very functioning unit that is better than the sum of its parts. His teams aren’t pretty but they stay in games and he has a knack for finding a way to upset, unsettle and beat teams. I tipped Charlton as outsiders this season for a top half finish and I’ve seen very little to suggest otherwise.
He was mental to take the Stoke and Saints jobs, but can’t blame him for wanting to make a step up. I think he could absolutely do it at a bigger club, but needs to be a bit more discerning. He’d have been a very good appointment for us this summer.


