This season tells me one thing…
#41
(11-09-2025, 10:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: TBH I’m not sure he’s a good, bad or average manager, I do think however that if you bring in a young unproven manager you give them time to prove themselves and 14 matches isn’t that, particularly when we are sitting in midtable which let’s be honest isn’t unreasonable to suggest maybe our level unless we bring in more players in January. 

If we were in the bottom three then yes, but we aren’t.

I actually agree with this 100% but change my mind for 90 minutes every time I watch us play.
Reply
#42
(11-09-2025, 10:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If we were in the bottom three then yes, but we aren’t.

And despite the recent bad run, poor performances, and the meltdowns on here, we're just 4 points outside the play-off places. 

Just think about that. After all the challenges in terms of player availability, an unbalanced squad, having the right hand side of the first XI decimated on deadline day, Mason has still got us within a good short run of results away from the play-offs. 

It's far from the disastrous position a lot of people are painting, is it? 

I'd say league position wise we're very much on par from what I'd expect, even with an experienced coach, let alone a rookie.
Reply
#43
I think the big challenge for Mason is our next 2 matches, Top of the league and flying Coventry and The team that have problems winning away and a local derby in Blues. If we can come out of these 2 matches with 4 pts unlikely yes but possible it will show Mason is learning.
A couple of things he should have learned from yesterday is Maja is nowhere near fit, Hegobo must start he did more in 25 mins than Maja has done this season. Taylor in my opinion was our best defender yesterday seemed to read the game better than Phillips who was very hit and miss.
The time has past for Grant, Dike,Wallace and Maja. For me bye bye and enjoy the rest of your career.
Reply
#44
On this bored and more generally on social media there’ll be a wide variety of opinions on Mason across the stick, twist and undecided spectrum. During the course of yesterday I went from stick to twist to undecided and I’m now back at stick. What people get up to on social media is all fine, no problem whatsoever. However the widespread and loud booing yesterday was a new low and IMO cuntish behaviour of the highest order. I can understand it at the end of the game, but booing your own team when the players are clearly trying their best is just crap. I don’t think I’m looking at the past with rose tinted glasses but our home support pre our premier league days even under Gould would never have done that. Don’t know what’s happened but it is v v disappointing.
Reply
#45
(11-09-2025, 11:36 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 10:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If we were in the bottom three then yes, but we aren’t.

And despite the recent bad run, poor performances, and the meltdowns on here, we're just 4 points outside the play-off places. 

Just think about that. After all the challenges in terms of player availability, an unbalanced squad, having the right hand side of the first XI decimated on deadline day, Mason has still got us within a good short run of results away from the play-offs. 

It's far from the disastrous position a lot of people are painting, is it? 

I'd say league position wise we're very much on par from what I'd expect, even with an experienced coach, let alone a rookie.

What book did you listen to yesterday?
Reply
#46
(11-09-2025, 11:36 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'd say league position wise we're very much on par from what I'd expect, even with an experienced coach, let alone a rookie.

This is the one thing Mason has going in his favour. I don't see any manager in the world getting this side into the POs over 40 games.

Cov, Boro, Leicester, Ipswich and Blues all have more quality than us and the ability to spend to improve in January. That's before you've considered sides who will punch above their weight by virtue of being well coached e.g Charlton, Millwall and Preston.
Reply
#47
I was wrong when I voted Mason out, that was emotion’s getting best of me after last minute defeat.
Mason for me deserves the chance to build this season, he’s a rookie yes but is he learning well yesterday he did.
Changed subs early enough to make a big impact Mollumby got everywhere and We all know what Heggebø did.
Reply
#48
Look at Sunderland now. Rebuilding a club takes time.
I think the only way Mason should be replaced is if we are in genuine danger of relegation. Otherwise it is a game of patience and using January’s window wisely.
Reply
#49
(11-09-2025, 11:54 AM)Old Fart Wrote: What book did you listen to yesterday?

None. I didn't have my earphones, unfortunately. Even if I did, I thought the atmosphere was quite good, so didn't need them. I wasn't bored, I genuinely enjoyed the game yesterday, particularly the second half.

(11-09-2025, 11:55 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 11:36 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'd say league position wise we're very much on par from what I'd expect, even with an experienced coach, let alone a rookie.

This is the one thing Mason has going in his favour. I don't see any manager in the world getting this side into the POs over 40 games.

Cov, Boro, Leicester, Ipswich and Blues all have more quality than us and the ability to spend to improve in January. That's before you've considered sides who will punch above their weight by virtue of being well coached e.g Charlton, Millwall and Preston.

We're a mid-table side. The sooner our fan base accepts that, the better.
Reply
#50
(11-09-2025, 12:06 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Look at Sunderland now. Rebuilding a club takes time.
I think the only way Mason should be replaced is if we are in genuine danger of relegation. Otherwise it is a game of patience and using January’s window wisely.

Does it?

Their new owners came in, installed an effective DoF, won promotion to the Champ in their first season, finished in the top 6, and then acted quickly when their disastrous appointment of Beale failed, before doing a thorough recruitment process that ended up with another promotion.

I’d argue that what Sunderland did well was had a very clear plan which meant they would realise and act to rectify their mistakes quickly and not find excuses for underperformance.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)