So who would we want, and who is available?
#81
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.
Reply
#82
It's a bigger question the who do we want.
Can we afford to dismiss Mason. Even Simon Jordan said we were crazy to give Mason a 3 year contract when he was young and had never been a manager.
Reply
#83
(11-05-2025, 04:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.

There is a difference between a young manager and a completely inexperienced one.

I find it interesting to contrast Mason to Darren Moore. Moore had several clear flaws during his time with us and I can't argue with his sacking. Yet, he seemed streets ahead of where Mason is, for all Mason's supposed tutelage under top managers.
Reply
#84
(11-05-2025, 04:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.

OK, maybe I was looking back to a time that's gone. Truth is, if you have 2 experienced Championship goalscorers, you don't leave both on the bench to play a novice from another league if you want a result. And you don't change your defenders in the last 2 minutes of an away match unless there's an injury. Everyone behind the goal knew it and I'd guess all those on the pitch and bench.
Reply
#85
Back to the OP -
I've been rattling the old grey matter as to who I would pick to replace Mason.
Ian Evett would be my choice ATM.
Reply
#86
(11-05-2025, 04:51 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 04:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.

OK, maybe I was looking back to a time that's gone. Truth is, if you have 2 experienced Championship goalscorers, you don't leave both on the bench to play a novice from another league if you want a result. And you don't change your defenders in the last 2 minutes of an away match unless there's an injury. Everyone behind the goal knew it and I'd guess all those on the pitch and bench.

Yes but I’d argue Mason didn’t leave Dike and Maja on the bench until so late in the game, nor switch on Mepham due to a lack of experience, he did it because he’s a very poor manager.

(11-05-2025, 04:41 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 04:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.

There is a difference between a young manager and a completely inexperienced one.

I find it interesting to contrast Mason to Darren Moore. Moore had several clear flaws during his time with us and I can't argue with his sacking. Yet, he seemed streets ahead of where Mason is, for all Mason's supposed tutelage under top managers.

Absolutely agree with the Moore point… I’d also say there’s a difference between an inexperienced manager and an incompetent one.
Reply
#87
(11-05-2025, 04:41 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 04:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.

There is a difference between a young manager and a completely inexperienced one.

I find it interesting to contrast Mason to Darren Moore. Moore had several clear flaws during his time with us and I can't argue with his sacking. Yet, he seemed streets ahead of where Mason is, for all Mason's supposed tutelage under top managers.

True. Although Moore had a much better side to manage
Reply
#88
(11-05-2025, 05:52 PM)CIM Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 04:41 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 04:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2025, 03:47 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Neither Gibbs nor Mason have much managerial experience, nothing on a par with Burkinshaw, Burrows or Addison. His inexperience was evident when he was appointed, why they have not insisted on somebody with managerial experience alongside him is beyond me.

But when has this been successful in the last 10 or so years? Young managers are now being given the job due to embracing technology, data, and statistics in a way older managers traditionally do not, and this has been their main advantage. The purpose of appointing Mason was to bring a fresh set of ideas and to capitalise on what he’s learned from working with Conte, Mourinho, and even Big Ange.

There is a difference between a young manager and a completely inexperienced one.

I find it interesting to contrast Mason to Darren Moore. Moore had several clear flaws during his time with us and I can't argue with his sacking. Yet, he seemed streets ahead of where Mason is, for all Mason's supposed tutelage under top managers.

True. Although Moore had a much better side to manage

Also true, but then it was a much tougher league that year. Probably the toughest since our relegation.
Reply
#89
I really think this "data" angle is over-played. I've lived and worked in the USA for a couple of decades and all this is a group of Americans who believe they know better despite ultimately not knowing much. There's nothing wrong with this approach, at least you're doing something, which usually gets you ahead of most.

Unfortunately, they're trying to do it in a cut throat environment where the opposition isn't as backward as they naively believed. So it all it does is hasten your failure.

Let's face it re Mason, how much data could there possibly be?? One side of A4? I think what's more likely is they understood his presentation because it was delivered in a way that dressed up a particular approach in a way that made it feel scientific, mathematic and measurable. 

It's just a shame it's not that easy and most teams and clubs are already doing these 'innovations'
Reply
#90
(11-06-2025, 03:58 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I really think this "data" angle is over-played. I've lived and worked in the USA for a couple of decades and all this is a group of Americans who believe they know better despite ultimately not knowing much. There's nothing wrong with this approach, at least you're doing something, which usually gets you ahead of most.

Unfortunately, they're trying to do it in a cut throat environment where the opposition isn't as backward as they naively believed.

Let's face it re Mason, how much data could there possibly be?? One side of an A4. I think what's more likely is they understood his presentation because it was delivered in a way that dressed up a particular approach in a way that made it feel scientific, mathematic and measurable. 

It's just a shame it's not that easy and most teams and clubs are already doing these 'innovations'

I think you could be right there.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)