Poll: Tin Tack
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes
50.43%
59 50.43%
No
17.09%
20 17.09%
Undecided
32.48%
38 32.48%
Total 117 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Mason
#41
(11-02-2025, 12:04 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Still has till Blues go 3 up before halftime...

No need to thank...
Reply
#42
(11-02-2025, 06:30 AM)aj21 Wrote: Too soon to sack him. Crazy appointment but we don’t have a clue about appointing managers and at least he wasn’t a dinosaur like Mowbray, Bruce, Big Sam, Pardew.

If Carlos gets sacked by Valencia then Mason should be removed and Carlos bought back. Like when a better players becomes available, if you have money and can buy, you should. The same should apply here.

He is behaving like a dinosaur with an even tinier brain.  Appalling.
Reply
#43
(11-02-2025, 06:30 AM)aj21 Wrote: Too soon to sack him. Crazy appointment but we don’t have a clue about appointing managers and at least he wasn’t a dinosaur like Mowbray, Bruce, Big Sam, Pardew.

If Carlos gets sacked by Valencia then Mason should be removed and Carlos bought back. Like when a better players becomes available, if you have money and can buy, you should. The same should apply here.

But nestors spreadsheet didn’t rate him.
Reply
#44
I was talking to a Makem last week and he said that it all changed for them when they brought in a new Sporting Director in 2020, since then he says their recruitment and selling “have been fantastic” apparently this summer they brought in a DoF from Roma who focuses on Europe, which contributed to “great summer signings”. I suspect if you talk to fans of Brentford and Bournemouth, even Villa they’ll have a similar story to tell. If you look at the players we’ve brought in they’re not better than the ones we’ve let go and I think the ones we’ve let go have been done so too early and too cheaply. I’m still struggling to know how much of this shit show is on Nestor and how much on Mason, but I’m tending towards Nestor.
Reply
#45
(11-02-2025, 12:35 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: I was talking to a Makem last week and he said that it all changed for them when they brought in a new Sporting Director in 2020, since then he says their recruitment and selling “have been fantastic” apparently this summer they brought in a DoF from Roma who focuses on Europe, which contributed to “great summer signings”.  I suspect if you talk to fans of Brentford and Bournemouth, even Villa they’ll have a similar story to tell.  If you look at the players we’ve brought in they’re not better than the ones we’ve let go and I think the ones we’ve let go have been done so too early and too cheaply.  I’m still struggling to know how much of this shit show is on Nestor and how much on Mason, but I’m tending towards Nestor.

It's a fair criticism of Nestor who I thought may have used more of his Euro connections from his time with Bologna.

There are however things Nestor doesn't control. In three months I can't remember Mason making a substitution that's changed a game, tried a different approach, shown that he's improving any of the players that he does have. All that does lie at the door of the coach.

If Nestor thinks our 'assets' are stagnating under Mason then I reckon that'll see him sacked quicker than a continued run of poor results.
Reply
#46
(11-02-2025, 01:18 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Undecided at present. He was clearly the club's number one choice so I don't see him being sacked in the short term. I do think though that a poor November, as was discussed in a thread earlier this week, will put huge pressure on him and could see the crowd really turn on him.

Whilst I don't want him gone at the moment, I do have considerable concerns and deep down I don't think he'll still be at the club at Christmas.

(11-01-2025, 10:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Nestor coming across as another Garlick… probably excellent at many areas of administration, data and operations but completely blank when it comes to football.

I would say that Nestor is currently as culpable as Mason for our failings in terms of players bought and sold and managerial selections. There are serious question marks about him.

I agree that there are question marks around Nestor for sure, but he is clearly Shilen’s man here and his recent promotion and increased remit suggests he’s going nowhere fast. His remit will be a 2-3 year timescale, and so far we’ve had an improvement in our general transfer hit rate, we’ve brought down the cost and age of the squad and we are seeing steady progress in our women’s and youth teams. He won’t be sacked just because Mason isn’t a success, but I’d expect there will be much more scrutiny of any future appointment. The big what if I suppose will always be how good would Wicky have been?
Reply
#47
Was going to give him the Oxford game before deciding but the last two winnable games and zero goals have made up my decision I want him out though I fear we are stuck with him and the players and manager will have a deserved toxic atmosphere now.
Reply
#48
(11-02-2025, 12:35 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: I was talking to a Makem last week and he said that it all changed for them when they brought in a new Sporting Director in 2020, since then he says their recruitment and selling “have been fantastic” apparently this summer they brought in a DoF from Roma who focuses on Europe, which contributed to “great summer signings”. I suspect if you talk to fans of Brentford and Bournemouth, even Villa they’ll have a similar story to tell. If you look at the players we’ve brought in they’re not better than the ones we’ve let go and I think the ones we’ve let go have been done so too early and too cheaply. I’m still struggling to know how much of this shit show is on Nestor and how much on Mason, but I’m tending towards Nestor.

Sunderland also grew and sold their own talent to fund things... All in all, a model we should follow. Only we don't try the.kids now either...
Reply
#49
(11-02-2025, 12:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-02-2025, 01:18 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Undecided at present. He was clearly the club's number one choice so I don't see him being sacked in the short term. I do think though that a poor November, as was discussed in a thread earlier this week, will put huge pressure on him and could see the crowd really turn on him.

Whilst I don't want him gone at the moment, I do have considerable concerns and deep down I don't think he'll still be at the club at Christmas.

(11-01-2025, 10:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Nestor coming across as another Garlick… probably excellent at many areas of administration, data and operations but completely blank when it comes to football.

I would say that Nestor is currently as culpable as Mason for our failings in terms of players bought and sold and managerial selections. There are serious question marks about him.

I agree that there are question marks around Nestor for sure, but he is clearly Shilen’s man here and his recent promotion and increased remit suggests he’s going nowhere fast. His remit will be a 2-3 year timescale, and so far we’ve had an improvement in our general transfer hit rate, we’ve brought down the cost and age of the squad and we are seeing steady progress in our women’s and youth teams. He won’t be sacked just because Mason isn’t a success, but I’d expect there will be much more scrutiny of any future appointment. The big what if I suppose will always be how good would Wicky have been?

What general improvement in transfer hit rate? 

Price, nowhere near as useful as Fellows 
Bany, if he walked past me in the street I wouldn’t recognise him 
Phillips, Mepham, Campbell…(too many other bloody defenders to mention) all the back four are no better than the players we lost 

Mowbray, ffs! 
Mason, complete gamble 

His performance has been worse than GM’s Dad.
Reply
#50
Tonight was his big chance to redeem himself
To be fair he took step one by changing the system to 3
At the back but he really bottled it in the 2nd half
The 3 subs at 60 minutes should have been
Dike Johnston & Bany

Go for the win instead of trying to hang on for a 0-0
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: