Posts: 19,497
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
11-02-2025, 08:53 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-02-2025, 08:54 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(11-02-2025, 08:39 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (11-02-2025, 08:25 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think there is a tendency to over think football.
It's a simple sport really.
The ex Wolves manager Ian Greaves summed it up when he said -'when confidence in the team us high good players become great and average players become good, and when confidence is low good players become average and average players become bad'
Confidence is low at the moment and we have a lot of average players.
It's Mason's job to sort this out and provide an environment where the players can produce their best football. And as someone pointed out further up the thread, at our best we can be reasonably good for this league, the games against Leicester and Preston aren't that long ago.
If Mason can't sort it, he will lose his job, if he can he will be a far better manager for having gone through this experience.
Yep.
We were shite yesterday. He's got time for all the reasons we know, young, promising (a few poor performances don't change that), the Board have put their long term weight behind him.
The only way he'd be gone by Christmas is Bruce like results.
Remember that our best players have been sold, to Ipswich and Southampton. It's hardly surprising that the replacements aren't as good.
Frustrating though it is, we have to think long term.
I think we all know our current place in the food chain and we know the issues we have as a club off the field that we are working through, and if this season is to be a season of transition most will accept it provided we see progress on the pitch (an identity of play, player improvement, a young coach steadily coming to grips with being a number one) however we are not seeing any of this.
The reason for the swing in opinion this weekend is just how badly in reverse we are travelling on the above metrics. Yesterday wasn’t a case of Wednesday being great, it wasn’t a case of there being two teams in a game chasing points, we were absolutely clueless, and turned in the worst performance since Bruce. It was alarmingly bad and Mason seemed to think it was OK at FT.
Posts: 341
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
In Mason’s defence the squad has some real limitations, especially in the wide areas, but he hasn’t done much to try and address those challenges since the end of the window and it’s become more of an issue week by week. 4231 was fine in the early weeks, especially with Fellows and Furlong here who both suited that shape, but now it just feels a bit awkward. We are reaching the point where something needs to change. It won’t be the players, so it needs to be the approach. It’s something CC was good at when he felt the side was lacking. He’d find a way to set us up to get more from what was available.
With the lack of wide options, especially on the right, I’d be tempted to go with a back 3 to try and change things up if I was Mason. I’m not always a fan of that shape, but I think it would suit the likes of Phillips, Mepham and Bielik. Can’t forget that Campbell was playing well for Montreal as part of a 3 as well. Would give us the option to play 2 strikers and then tighten up the midfield with a 3, or get two ‘10s’ behind a striker but without them needing to be out and out wide players.
Posts: 7,975
Threads: 255
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-02-2025, 02:27 PM)ABBaggie Wrote: In Mason’s defence the squad has some real limitations, especially in the wide areas, but he hasn’t done much to try and address those challenges since the end of the window and it’s become more of an issue week by week. 4231 was fine in the early weeks, especially with Fellows and Furlong here who both suited that shape, but now it just feels a bit awkward. We are reaching the point where something needs to change. It won’t be the players, so it needs to be the approach. It’s something CC was good at when he felt the side was lacking. He’d find a way to set us up to get more from what was available.
With the lack of wide options, especially on the right, I’d be tempted to go with a back 3 to try and change things up if I was Mason. I’m not always a fan of that shape, but I think it would suit the likes of Phillips, Mepham and Bielik. Can’t forget that Campbell was playing well for Montreal as part of a 3 as well. Would give us the option to play 2 strikers and then tighten up the midfield with a 3, or get two ‘10s’ behind a striker but without them needing to be out and out wide players.
Agreed. Surprised this hasn’t been tried yet. It’s just where we play Mikey
Posts: 7,727
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
I just don't think we've got anyone capable of playing wingback on either side, to play a 3. That said, I don't think we've got any fullbacks decent going forward on either side to play a back 4.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Funny how despite moving on the spacegoats we're in a position where a manager who increasingly looks out of his depth is getting diminishing returns from the squad. Surely this can't be the case, or does it indicate that a competent manager is in fact the most important thing rather than players picking and choosing when they perform?
Posts: 19,497
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Have to say, I’ve just listened to the Albion Analysis podcast, and whilst they continue to move further and further into opinion territory, the few stats they did mention just showed even more so what a bad job Mason is doing. I really want to be patient and give him time, but yesterday was just so bad, so filled with errors and just such a sheer dereliction of duty, I can’t see how I can.
It’s clear he won’t be sacked this week, but Wednesday have the worst defence in the league, have had the most chances created against them, one of the worst xA for goals against, and they didn’t have to break a sweat to get a point. Our play was so, so incoherent and the subs so, so poor that it was arguably our worst managerial display in years, and we’ve had fugging Bruce and Mowbray!
Posts: 341
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(11-02-2025, 05:33 PM)Jacko Wrote: I just don't think we've got anyone capable of playing wingback on either side, to play a 3. That said, I don't think we've got any fullbacks decent going forward on either side to play a back 4. 
Right side is a bit of a struggle but Gilchrist could do a job there I think in the short term. Styles and Iling-Junior both reasonable options on the other side.
To be honest changing to a back 3 isn’t a massive shift away from how we actually play in game with our current shape, but the subtle shift might help us get a few more bodies forward.
Posts: 3,108
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
I share the concerns in the OP.
Confidence is probably a huge part of it.
A team in transition another.
The loss of our right side, which for years has been the basis of all our attacking moves, another factor.
RM needs to show he can address these issues. At the start of the season we looked very much like the squad had bought into the plan, now not at all. The chief concerns for me are:
Subs. Always too late and normally the wrong ones.
Attacking threat. Almost non existent.
Lethargy. I said elsewhere that half the side didn't even bother to come over when the coaches were explaining something during Mowatts treatment break.
Also, I have no idea of the medical advice but Dike and Maja are in their last season here, just get them on the pitch anyway.
Bany is slightly different but what was the point of naming him as sub if not to give him 10 minutes?
Posts: 7,975
Threads: 255
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-03-2025, 01:01 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I share the concerns in the OP.
Confidence is probably a huge part of it.
A team in transition another.
The loss of our right side, which for years has been the basis of all our attacking moves, another factor.
RM needs to show he can address these issues. At the start of the season we looked very much like the squad had bought into the plan, now not at all. The chief concerns for me are:
Subs. Always too late and normally the wrong ones.
Attacking threat. Almost non existent.
Lethargy. I said elsewhere that half the side didn't even bother to come over when the coaches were explaining something during Mowatts treatment break.
Also, I have no idea of the medical advice but Dike and Maja are in their last season here, just get them on the pitch anyway.
Bany is slightly different but what was the point of naming him as sub if not to give him 10 minutes?
Noticed that - very telling
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
Have been wondering for the last few games if there is a bit of question mark over the new fitness geezer - are they getting worked too hard in training?
|