Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(10-31-2025, 11:27 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:20 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:18 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 09:16 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: That's just someone's opinion.
Greatest can only be judged by sales.
Some obvious ones missing.
Most popular does not equal best.
Totally agree. More sales often just equals more exposure, tv/radio plays. It certainly is no barometer on quality or originality.
If we went purely on sales we’d be hailing the likes of Adele and Westlife as the greatest ever.
Anything else except sales is individuals opinions.
And an individual's opinion matters far more than sales data. Not once has the number of copies sold by a record influenced my enjoyment of it. We all judge subjectively, sales figures mean precisely fuck all.
According to this list List of best-selling albums - Wikipedia (yeah Wikipedia I know) Whitney Houston's Bodyguard soundtrack is the third biggest selling album of all time, and Shania Twain's Come On Over is 7th.
Do you seriously mean to tell me that they are the third and seventh greatest albums of all time?
Posts: 4,732
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
(10-31-2025, 11:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 11:27 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:20 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:18 AM)Duffers Wrote: Most popular does not equal best.
Totally agree. More sales often just equals more exposure, tv/radio plays. It certainly is no barometer on quality or originality.
If we went purely on sales we’d be hailing the likes of Adele and Westlife as the greatest ever.
Anything else except sales is individuals opinions.
And an individual's opinion matters far more than sales data. Not once has the number of copies sold by a record influenced my enjoyment of it. We all judge subjectively, sales figures mean precisely fuck all.
According to this list List of best-selling albums - Wikipedia (yeah Wikipedia I know) Whitney Houston's Bodyguard soundtrack is the third biggest selling album of all time, and Shania Twain's Come On Over is 7th.
Do you seriously mean to tell me that they are the third and seventh greatest albums of all time?
That don’t impress me much
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(10-31-2025, 12:09 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (10-31-2025, 11:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 11:27 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:20 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Totally agree. More sales often just equals more exposure, tv/radio plays. It certainly is no barometer on quality or originality.
If we went purely on sales we’d be hailing the likes of Adele and Westlife as the greatest ever.
Anything else except sales is individuals opinions.
And an individual's opinion matters far more than sales data. Not once has the number of copies sold by a record influenced my enjoyment of it. We all judge subjectively, sales figures mean precisely fuck all.
According to this list List of best-selling albums - Wikipedia (yeah Wikipedia I know) Whitney Houston's Bodyguard soundtrack is the third biggest selling album of all time, and Shania Twain's Come On Over is 7th.
Do you seriously mean to tell me that they are the third and seventh greatest albums of all time?
That don’t impress me much
I'm not telling anyone anything.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(10-31-2025, 12:45 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-31-2025, 12:09 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (10-31-2025, 11:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: (10-31-2025, 11:27 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (10-31-2025, 10:26 AM)Duffers Wrote: If we went purely on sales we’d be hailing the likes of Adele and Westlife as the greatest ever.
Anything else except sales is individuals opinions.
And an individual's opinion matters far more than sales data. Not once has the number of copies sold by a record influenced my enjoyment of it. We all judge subjectively, sales figures mean precisely fuck all.
According to this list List of best-selling albums - Wikipedia (yeah Wikipedia I know) Whitney Houston's Bodyguard soundtrack is the third biggest selling album of all time, and Shania Twain's Come On Over is 7th.
Do you seriously mean to tell me that they are the third and seventh greatest albums of all time?
That don’t impress me much
I'm not telling anyone anything.
Apart from the bit in bold.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
I'd say no top 50 albums can be complete without the stuff that influenced everything since. So I'd want at least one of the Motown Chartbusters Volumes 1 to 6, a Tighten Up collection, a Buddy Holly.or Chuck Berry album, Oddysey and Oracle, A Velver Underground, Ziggy, the MC5, The Clash- like em or not, their spirit inspired plenty. I should chuck in Hank Williams, Howling Wolf and Jimmy Rogers. If we went on sales alone we'd be stuck with Gary Bloody Barlow
As the quote said, only about 5000 people bought a Velvet Underground Album but every one of them formed a band.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-31-2025, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I'd say no top 50 albums can be complete without the stuff that influenced everything since. So I'd want at least one of the Motown Chartbusters Volumes 1 to 6, a Tighten Up collection, a Buddy Holly.or Chuck Berry album, Oddysey and Oracle, A Velver Underground, Ziggy, the MC5, The Clash- like em or not, their spirit inspired plenty. I should chuck in Hank Williams, Howling Wolf and Jimmy Rogers. If we went on sales alone we'd be stuck with Gary Bloody Barlow
As the quote said, only about 5000 people bought a Velvet Underground Album but every one of them formed a band.
Some proper, timeless stuff on those.
Posts: 2,797
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
17
(10-31-2025, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I'd say no top 50 albums can be complete without the stuff that influenced everything since. So I'd want at least one of the Motown Chartbusters Volumes 1 to 6, a Tighten Up collection, a Buddy Holly.or Chuck Berry album, Oddysey and Oracle, A Velver Underground, Ziggy, the MC5, The Clash- like em or not, their spirit inspired plenty. I should chuck in Hank Williams, Howling Wolf and Jimmy Rogers. If we went on sales alone we'd be stuck with Gary Bloody Barlow
As the quote said, only about 5000 people bought a Velvet Underground Album but every one of them formed a band.
Exactly this.
If the criteria for greatness were based on sales, that would make the Sun the greatness newspaper of all time.
Q.E.D.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(10-31-2025, 02:53 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: (10-31-2025, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I'd say no top 50 albums can be complete without the stuff that influenced everything since. So I'd want at least one of the Motown Chartbusters Volumes 1 to 6, a Tighten Up collection, a Buddy Holly.or Chuck Berry album, Oddysey and Oracle, A Velver Underground, Ziggy, the MC5, The Clash- like em or not, their spirit inspired plenty. I should chuck in Hank Williams, Howling Wolf and Jimmy Rogers. If we went on sales alone we'd be stuck with Gary Bloody Barlow
As the quote said, only about 5000 people bought a Velvet Underground Album but every one of them formed a band.
Exactly this.
If the criteria for greatness were based on sales, that would make the Sun the greatness newspaper of all time.
Q.E.D.
That may be true, but it's also a more objective method than a bloke on the internet picking 50 albums out of a hat.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 2,797
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
17
(10-31-2025, 03:12 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-31-2025, 02:53 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: (10-31-2025, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I'd say no top 50 albums can be complete without the stuff that influenced everything since. So I'd want at least one of the Motown Chartbusters Volumes 1 to 6, a Tighten Up collection, a Buddy Holly.or Chuck Berry album, Oddysey and Oracle, A Velver Underground, Ziggy, the MC5, The Clash- like em or not, their spirit inspired plenty. I should chuck in Hank Williams, Howling Wolf and Jimmy Rogers. If we went on sales alone we'd be stuck with Gary Bloody Barlow
As the quote said, only about 5000 people bought a Velvet Underground Album but every one of them formed a band.
Exactly this.
If the criteria for greatness were based on sales, that would make the Sun the greatness newspaper of all time.
Q.E.D.
That may be true, but it's also a more objective method than a bloke on the internet picking 50 albums out of a hat.
Essentially it all depends on what the definition of 'greatness' is. If you want to equate 'greatness' with 'number of sales', then there will be certain amounts of numerical data you can refer to. Though as pointed out in a post above, this method is far from objective - statistics are clearly influenced by all sorts of factors and agendas.
If 'greatness' is taken as 'influential' in terms of the ongoing development of popular music in its various forms then TJ25 has made a clear argument above, though there is no statistical way I know of to measure this. I don't believe in the concept of defining 'greatness' in terms of these types of lists plucked off the top of people's heads anyway, as they operate purely in the realms of the subjective, whether the person involved is an authority on music or not.
I'm with Frank Black on this one:
"Nobody owns the pleasure of tones,
That belong to the guy with no ear".
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(10-31-2025, 03:12 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-31-2025, 02:53 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: (10-31-2025, 01:05 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I'd say no top 50 albums can be complete without the stuff that influenced everything since. So I'd want at least one of the Motown Chartbusters Volumes 1 to 6, a Tighten Up collection, a Buddy Holly.or Chuck Berry album, Oddysey and Oracle, A Velver Underground, Ziggy, the MC5, The Clash- like em or not, their spirit inspired plenty. I should chuck in Hank Williams, Howling Wolf and Jimmy Rogers. If we went on sales alone we'd be stuck with Gary Bloody Barlow
As the quote said, only about 5000 people bought a Velvet Underground Album but every one of them formed a band.
Exactly this.
If the criteria for greatness were based on sales, that would make the Sun the greatness newspaper of all time.
Q.E.D.
That may be true, but it's also a more objective method than a bloke on the internet picking 50 albums out of a hat.
I don’t there needs to be an objective method.
As I said yesterday on this thread the fun of these lists are conversations they generate.
|