(10-27-2025, 07:36 PM)Duffers Wrote: A good list and an interesting read.
One glaring exception I have to take is Daft Punk’s Random Access Memories at #9. It’s the Be Here Now of dance music and one of the most overrated records of all time.
It’s not even Daft Punk’s best album, yet alone the ninth best of all time.
Quite. That stood out to me, too. Homework was a defining album when it came out. It crossed genres with effortlessness. You could hear Rollin' and Scratchin' at a techno club, Da Funk at house clubs, and Around the World on daytime Radio 1. Random Access Memories was grand, but nowhere near as influential (or as good, but that's subjective).
IMVHO, In Utero is better album than Nevermind and the only Nirvana album I would listen to in full, but Nevermind was more influential, so I can see why it's there.
Interestingly (for me at least), as I was scrolling down and saw Revolver, I thought "meh, Abbey Road was much better, but I hope they haven't placed the white album higher". I was kind of pleased to see Abbey Road on top.
Maybe controversial, but I could never get into Patti Smith, despite numerous people raving to me how great Horses was.
I think a list like that (Top 50 eva!) might be better as an alphabetical list. The writer makes a good case for most of the choices being in a top 50, and I like the fact it is so unashamedly eclectic, with places for Bitches Brew and even Taylor Swift. However, the rankings are what make it questionable for me.