A different way of looking at things
#1
I see Mason is getting most of the criticism for current form and results, which is exactly how DoF in football like. When it goes well it’s a brilliant team effort from the ‘football department’ when it goes badly it’s all the Head Coaches fault. 

This season was always going to be very difficult, we have sold our best players and replaced them with players who may come good but are currently looking no better if not worse than what we had. Why in such a transitional season would you choose to employ a rookie manager with no real day to day experience of being the boss, but for a handful of caretaker games? The managerial position should have been the most expensive and significant signing this summer and it feels like we’ve take a punt on potential. Yes every manager is a risk but you don’t have to go from Mowbray/Bruce to Mason in terms of experience and stages in careers. There were other options with better/attack record of success.

It’s too early to start getting too up or down about results but Mason is just a cog in this machine and I’m not sure it’s fair to be putting most of the blame at his door when it breaks down.
Reply
#2
1 header at goal in 90 mins is down to his negative approach.
Reply
#3
(10-25-2025, 02:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see Mason is getting most of the criticism for current form and results, which is exactly how DoF in football like. When it goes well it’s a brilliant team effort from the ‘football department’ when it goes badly it’s all the Head Coaches fault. 

This season was always going to be very difficult, we have sold our best players and replaced them with players who may come good but are currently looking no better if not worse than what we had. Why in such a transitional season would you choose to employ a rookie manager with no real day to day experience of being the boss, but for a handful of caretaker games? The managerial position should have been the most expensive and significant signing this summer and it feels like we’ve take a punt on potential. Yes every manager is a risk but you don’t have to go from Mowbray/Bruce to Mason in terms of experience and stages in careers. There were other options with better/attack record of success.

It’s too early to start getting too up or down about results but Mason is just a cog in this machine and I’m not sure it’s fair to be putting most of the blame at his door when it breaks down.

Sorry, I completely disagree with this. 

The only time anyone ever talks about 'the football department' is when there's something negative.  "What were they doing appointing Mowbray", "Gourlay the fat twat, appointing Bruce", "How can we sell Fellows/Pereira etc." without replacement. No one blames the manager for those things, although in the case of Mowbray and Bruce there's also despair at how bad they were.

However, when talking about Corberan, fans talk about how good he was as a manager, not how well 'the football department' did to get him.

I think it's actually the opposite to what you've said in bold
Reply
#4
Not about results.
Reply
#5
(10-25-2025, 02:14 PM)Middlemore rd Wrote: 1 header at goal in 90 mins is down to his negative approach.

Not good and he needs to turn it round soon.

Do you think we're a decent side though? To me we're no better than a lot of the other dross in the middle of the Chump. Capable of half decent performances now and then but in no way good enough to string together a run of wins.
Reply
#6
(10-25-2025, 02:20 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-25-2025, 02:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see Mason is getting most of the criticism for current form and results, which is exactly how DoF in football like. When it goes well it’s a brilliant team effort from the ‘football department’ when it goes badly it’s all the Head Coaches fault. 

This season was always going to be very difficult, we have sold our best players and replaced them with players who may come good but are currently looking no better if not worse than what we had. Why in such a transitional season would you choose to employ a rookie manager with no real day to day experience of being the boss, but for a handful of caretaker games? The managerial position should have been the most expensive and significant signing this summer and it feels like we’ve take a punt on potential. Yes every manager is a risk but you don’t have to go from Mowbray/Bruce to Mason in terms of experience and stages in careers. There were other options with better/attack record of success.

It’s too early to start getting too up or down about results but Mason is just a cog in this machine and I’m not sure it’s fair to be putting most of the blame at his door when it breaks down.

Sorry, I completely disagree with this. 

The only time anyone ever talks about 'the football department' is when there's something negative.  "What were they doing appointing Mowbray", "Gourlay the fat twat, appointing Bruce", "How can we sell Fellows/Pereira etc." without replacement. No one blames the manager for those things.

However, when talking about Corberan, fans talk about how good he was as a manager, not how well 'the football department' did to get him.

I think it's actually the opposite to what you've said in bold

Nestor has had two managerial decisions one was awful and easily avoided, the other he went out and got a rookie who is getting pelters from fans. He’s also assembled the current squad which looks completely disjointed to me. 

It’s easy to blame Mason for our current form  but I’m not at all sure that’s fair. If we sacked him now, we still have the same DoF making the most significant decisions for the clubs immediate future.
Reply
#7
The centre of midfield is the problem
Reply
#8
(10-25-2025, 02:25 PM)Middlemore rd Wrote: The centre of midfield is the problem

+1

I think Mowatt is decent but whatever Mason says about him I think he struggles so much with 3 game weeks. He needs someone a lot more creative and forward looking alongside him and we need an alternative to him which we don't have
Reply
#9
(10-25-2025, 02:24 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(10-25-2025, 02:14 PM)Middlemore rd Wrote: 1 header at goal in 90 mins is down to his negative approach.

Not good and he needs to turn it round soon.

Do you think we're a decent side though? To me we're no better than a lot of the other dross in the middle of the Chump. Capable of half decent performances now and then but in no way good enough to string together a run of wins.

The question should be “ are we a better side than we are seeing”
My answer is yes. So get rid.
If it’s no then stick.
I’ve seen nothing to suggest he can turn it around, so blind faith will hurt us. We are no longer looking up, but looking over our shoulder.
Reply
#10
Diakete wins balls in midfield but then loses it very easily. Mowett must be losing his shit in that midfield. He is 1 man. Wtf can he do.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: