Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-22-2025, 09:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What did fans expect? We have sold our best players to balance the books. Without parachute payments our current business model and financial predicament means we are just another also ran Championship club like PNE.
Thank God. Some sense.
We’re 11 games into the season under a novice manager after a massive squad cull.
Horrible to see performances like that but most clubs will have them.
Some of the comments on here are just so irrational.
I’ll at least wait until Christmas before assessing if we’re gone off the rails.
This season is going to be about stabilising the club and that’s all.
Look at how we’ve dropped 6 places with one defeat. It shows most clubs have the same erratic form.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
10-23-2025, 07:49 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2025, 07:52 AM by TartanRug.)
(10-23-2025, 07:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (10-23-2025, 07:12 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (10-22-2025, 09:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (10-22-2025, 09:29 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Any hopes of top 6 were over the minute the transfer window shut. The squad is way off and we have a rookie manager trying his best with it. We don’t have the personnel to create anywhere near enough in open play to win games consistently.
I’m unconvinced by Mason so far but I struggle to get on his back too much when IMO Nestor made such a mess of the summer window.
The only natural fullback we have is Charlie Taylor, SIJ is our best and currently only choice at RW but also out of position, best part of 5m quid spent on Gilchrist, Campbell and Bielik and from what I’ve seen Heggebo is nowhere near worth what was spent on him
Good post.
The summer window was really poor, and it's starting to show.
Hindsight, no one was saying that at the time.
I think you'll find there were some of us, Shab.
We left ourselves really unbalanced, signed too many defenders, and didn't address the midfield.
I was worried at the time. We struggled enough for goals last season and were very reliant on Fellows now without him we unsurprisingly look even worse as an attacking side and seem very reliant on wonder goals to get us anything - how often do we put good moves together that end up with a good chance or goal?
(10-23-2025, 07:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (10-22-2025, 09:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What did fans expect? We have sold our best players to balance the books. Without parachute payments our current business model and financial predicament means we are just another also ran Championship club like PNE.
Thank God. Some sense.
We’re 11 games into the season under a novice manager after a massive squad cull.
Horrible to see performances like that but most clubs will have them.
Some of the comments on here are just so irrational.
I’ll at least wait until Christmas before assessing if we’re gone off the rails.
This season is going to be about stabilising the club and that’s all.
Look at how we’ve dropped 6 places with one defeat. It shows most clubs have the same erratic form.
I agree this season is stabilisation I'm not expecting anything beyond hopefully top half of the table. Next season we need to see if we're starting to turn the club on an upwards trajectory or are continuing the decline over the last several years.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
I agree with Spandau, but without all the quotes. Huge over reaction here to a not totally unexpected defeat (with 2 midfielders missing). Last night we were in it until ht. We need to address what happened in the 2nd half.
Posts: 1,130
Threads: 164
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(10-23-2025, 07:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (10-22-2025, 09:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What did fans expect? We have sold our best players to balance the books. Without parachute payments our current business model and financial predicament means we are just another also ran Championship club like PNE.
Thank God. Some sense.
We’re 11 games into the season under a novice manager after a massive squad cull.
Horrible to see performances like that but most clubs will have them.
Some of the comments on here are just so irrational.
I’ll at least wait until Christmas before assessing if we’re gone off the rails.
This season is going to be about stabilising the club and that’s all.
Look at how we’ve dropped 6 places with one defeat. It shows most clubs have the same erratic form. ?. There are about a dozen or so clubs on or around our level right now. We could well find ourselves 4th or 5th in a few weeks time, or we could be below where we are now. Mason was somewhat dealt a bad hand. Mowatt dictates our play, but we have no option to him. I do feel that Styles could do so, but that would mean Taylor at LB who looks way past his best. If we can get Bany fit, a big if I know, he could slot in at 10, and maybe drop Price a little deeper, but then we lose his goal threat somewhat. Mason has his hands tied right now.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(10-22-2025, 09:19 PM)MrBater Wrote: And yet the likes of Stoke, Coventry, Boro and even fucking Millwall are giving it a good go right now... Least they're getting a bit of excitement... Don't think any of them have had parachutes for a while? (Might be wrong).
Stoke spend a fortune every summer and have been shit for a decade - do you think they've gone through the last 8-9 seasons without many performances and results like we had last night? Do you think our fans would sit around politely for that length of time saying give it chance?
Coventry are a great example of what we're trying to do - they sold Hamer and Gyokeres and have, over a couple of summers built the best team in the league with the profit. Every time Dekka posts "you can't do anything when you just sell your best players" someone point him in the direction of what Coventry have done the last three seasons. That said, this is as good as they've been for 20 years.
Boro also spend a fortune every summer and have picked a manager in Rob Edwards who from memory was pretty unanimously shouted down on here. This is also as good as they've been for a number of years after a bit of a fallow period since they were last relegated from the PL.
Millwall are as good as they've pretty much ever been and have spent years and years in the bottom two divisions. I'm not sure we'd have put up with what they have to get to where they are now.
What this league should show us is that unless you have the parachute money, you can't build something over night - I can't think of a team that's done it. Yes Mason can do better but we have to be competitive and build where we can when, we can until we're able to spend more money under the accounting rules or we get a major windfall from a player sale (I'm looking at you Isaac Price). During this period, realistically we should judge the club on two things:
1) Is there a plan with recruitment, are we committed to signing a certain profile and type of player that fits in with the managers plans - I'll give a benefit of the doubt 'Yes' but huge blackmark for the lack of a Fellows replacement.
2) Is the manager working effectively with what he's got, are we giving ourselves the best chance of consistently picking up points with our approach and are players improving under him - too early to tell.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
10-23-2025, 09:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2025, 09:43 AM by Josh1873.)
Oh come on, Stoke lost Tuesday, and are only a point ahead of us. Milwall are only 3 points ahead of us. So let's not pretend they're both some superbly run clubs that are unbeatable that we should be emulating. We're on a par with them and we're having a very similar start to the season as them.
Coventry and Boro are just better than us, there's no shame in that. They're both (for now) clearly the best two sides in the division.
There's issues with us, and we deserve criticism, but let's not get ridiculous with it, eh?
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(10-23-2025, 09:40 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Oh come on, Stoke lost Tuesday, and are only a few points ahead of us, just like Millwall are. So let's not pretend they're some superbly run side that are unbeatable that we should be emulating.
Coventry and Boro are just better than us, there's no shame in that.
There's issues with us, and we deserve criticism, but let's not get ridiculous with it, eh?
That's kind of my point, Josh. These clubs are held up like they've discovered some magical potion for success. When in reality they've endured far more shit than we have in the last 10-20 years in order to get to where they are now, which by the way, is only just better than an Albion side we spend nearly all of our time hammering for being shite.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Sorry, I misinterpreted your post. Ignore me
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(10-23-2025, 09:40 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Oh come on, Stoke lost Tuesday, and are only a point ahead of us. Milwall are only 3 points ahead of us. So let's not pretend they're both some superbly run clubs that are unbeatable that we should be emulating. We're on a par with them and we're having a very similar start to the season as them.
Coventry and Boro are just better than us, there's no shame in that. They're both (for now) clearly the best two sides in the division.
There's issues with us, and we deserve criticism, but let's not get ridiculous with it, eh?
Fair point that Josh.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
I hate to point out the ignored obvious but with Collyer and Molumby out (and an ill Bielik -who can play mf), we were short of numbers. Grant simply wasn't up to the pace, Maja/Dike same. Where I can't disagree with everyone is the full back situation. It was Campbell skint for pace that cost the 2nd goal. Phillips got the ball stuck under him blocking the cross, he felt he need another touch when actually he should have been shouted by his partner.Im more concerned no one picked up the scorer.
What happened last night was a change in approach from Watford. Most of the 1st half we looked more dangerous. Even allowing for the period they pushed us into our own half, we looked most likely to score. They also had the advantage of a ref that gave them 6 arguable free kicks and booked Styles for their guy falling over. That isn't an excuse though. 2nd half we were blown away like we were at Millwall. Our players do seem to crumble under that sort of pressure and that is a huge concern.
|