Preston’s none penalty
#11
(10-19-2025, 07:58 AM)Atomic Wrote: The tiny touch isn't enough for me. A definite penalty. I'd be livid if we didn't get a pen for that had it been at the other end.

We didn't get a penalty for a similar tackle on Heggebø earlier in the season so it pretty much evens that out.

This.

I've watched it 4 times now and I still think it's a penalty.
I haven't slowed it down, I haven't watched it from different angles, so maybe I'm wrong.

But remember the ref can't slow it down and has only one angle.

We will get decisions go for us and go against us. I don't think it does anyone any good to over analyse them.
Reply
#12
Quote:We will get decisions go for us and go against us. I don't think it does anyone any good to over analyse them.


That's how I like it. Human fallibility is OK with me. Yes, it can be frustrating (Portsmouth), but it's far better than having VAR ruining the flow and spontaneous nature of football. Even if we're on the receiving end of the decision. 

Ultimately, a bad decision is a matter of seconds in a game of 90+ mins. There's enough time to overcome any poor decisions.
Reply
#13
(10-19-2025, 08:11 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
Quote:We will get decisions go for us and go against us. I don't think it does anyone any good to over analyse them.


That's how I like it. Human fallibility is OK with me. Yes, it can be frustrating (Portsmouth), but it's far better than having VAR ruining the flow and spontaneous nature of football. Even if we're on the receiving end of the decision. 

Ultimately, a bad decision is a matter of seconds in a game of 90+ mins. There's enough time to overcome any poor decisions.

Agree.

We’ve had more than enough go against us this season, it’s a nice to finally see one go for us. 

Same as Atomic, I’ve watched it several times and I don’t see how it’s not.
Reply
#14
Watched it a few times and I thought it was a penalty. Just shows how hard a ref's job is sometimes.
Reply
#15
Thought it was a penalty when watching it in real time from the Brummie. Having seen it back on the Sky highlights last night I'm still not convinced that it wasn't a penalty.
Reply
#16
Thought it was a peno at the time (as did Hawks Jr), but we were sitting in the opposite corner. It’s also very hard to tell whether or not there was contact with the ball from the few replays I’ve seen.

Whether Collyer has played it or not, he was going nowhere with it (it was intercepted straight away), so either way I think it’s a fair decision. As said above not gonna complain about luck when it comes our way, and even if we have got lucky I think it balances out against the red card Storey should have received in the second, which would have put the game to bed a lot earlier than was the case.
Reply
#17
(10-19-2025, 07:58 AM)Atomic Wrote: The tiny touch isn't enough for me. A definite penalty. I'd be livid if we didn't get a pen for that had it been at the other end.

We didn't get a penalty for a similar tackle on Heggebø earlier in the season so it pretty much evens that out.

Like wba13 says, have a look at the Express and Star replay. He cleanly takes the ball. Not sure what all the fuss is about after seeing that. The ref on this occasion was spot on.
Reply
#18
(10-19-2025, 09:20 AM)Rowie60 Wrote:
(10-19-2025, 07:58 AM)Atomic Wrote: The tiny touch isn't enough for me. A definite penalty. I'd be livid if we didn't get a pen for that had it been at the other end.

We didn't get a penalty for a similar tackle on Heggebø earlier in the season so it pretty much evens that out.

Like wba13 says, have a look at the Express and Star replay. He cleanly takes the ball. Not sure what all the fuss is about after seeing that. The ref on this occasion was spot on.

I've seen it. It's not enough. If that's in the centre circle the free kick is given virtually every time. For me it's a pen.
Reply
#19
Pelanty
Raw Sausage
Reply
#20
(10-19-2025, 09:31 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(10-19-2025, 09:20 AM)Rowie60 Wrote:
(10-19-2025, 07:58 AM)Atomic Wrote: The tiny touch isn't enough for me. A definite penalty. I'd be livid if we didn't get a pen for that had it been at the other end.

We didn't get a penalty for a similar tackle on Heggebø earlier in the season so it pretty much evens that out.

Like wba13 says, have a look at the Express and Star replay. He cleanly takes the ball. Not sure what all the fuss is about after seeing that. The ref on this occasion was spot on.

I've seen it. It's not enough. If that's in the centre circle the free kick is given virtually every time. For me it's a pen.

The key thing is Mowatt was there to collect the ball after the ball changed direction due to the challenge. If he wasn't it would have been a pen.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)