Posts: 9,618
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
It is no secret I think Mason is really struggling with game management, especially when we are not winning/playing well, so I thought I would have a look through the subs to make sure its not confirmation bias on my behalf.
I have, below, listed all the subs he's made, in brackets is the minute the sub was made and whether i felt the sub was positive, neutral or negative using the following key; Positive - ^, Negative - v, neutral - /.
Blackburn:
Wallace > Fellows (72 - /)
Diakite > Price (80 - v)
Cambell > Grant (89 - v)
Wrexham:
Johnston > Grant (73 - /)
Wallace > Fellows (74 - /)
Diakite > Mowatt (74 - v)
Collyer > Price (79 - v)
Pompey:
Grant > Johnston (60 - /)
Maja > Price (82 - /)
Wallace > Fellows (87 - /)
Collyer > Molumby (87 - /)
Stoke:
Collyer > Wallace (79 - v)
Diakite > Johnston (88 - v)
Williams > Mowatt (88 - v)
Maja > Molumby (95 - ^)
Derby:
SIJ > Wallace (73 - /)
Collyer > Mowatt (74 - /)
Maja > Johnston (83 - /)
Middlesborough:
Johnston > Wallace (62 - /)
Collyer > Mowatt (62 - v)
Maja > Diakite (76 - ^)
Leicester:
Styles > SIJ (72 - v)
Maja > Heggebo (72 - /)
Wallace > Johnston (86 - /)
Collyer > Mowatt (89 - /)
Norwich:
Wallace > Johnston (60 - /)
Heggebo > Maja (60 - /)
Bielik > Taylor (75 - v)
Collyer > Mowatt (75 - /)
Gilchrist > SIJ (85 - v)
Millwall:
Maja > Wallace (62 - /)
SIJ > Price (62 - /)
Mowatt > Collyer (79 - /)
Diakite > Molumby (79 - v)
Bostock > Johnston (89- /)
So in 6/9 games we have made subs that on average have been negative and defensively minded. On the other three occasions I would deem the subs to be neutral at most. We have (IMO), only made 2 subs that switched teh balance towards more attacking threat, that was Maja for Diakite against Boro and Maja for Molumby v Stoke. The Boro' swap was after that had already gone 2 up and the one v Stoke was in the 95th minute. So neither were well timed, rather reactive and desperate.
Mason needs to be braver with his subs, because by and large his starting XIs are too neutral/defensive already for my liking of course.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
I admire the effort here Lurker but I do think you need to take into account the result at the time too - in 5 of those games we’d have been winning at the time of the majority of those subs so it would make sense that he didn’t open us up.
Portsmouth and Derby were very poor, we left it far too late to push for something… yesterday he left things far too late and should have made changes at HT, but we were that bad im not sure subbing all XI would have made a difference.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
It’s almost as if we have a limited squad and the attacking options we do have seem semi-permanently injured.
Posts: 9,618
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-05-2025, 05:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I admire the effort here Lurker but I do think you need to take into account the result at the time too - in 5 of those games we’d have been winning at the time of the majority of those subs so it would make sense that he didn’t open us up.
Portsmouth and Derby were very poor, we left it far too late to push for something… yesterday he left things far too late and should have made changes at HT, but we were that bad im not sure subbing all XI would have made a difference.
If we were consistently playing well and comfortably seeing games out I would agree, pal. But we have been struggling to keep hold of control in games and have on a couple of occasions got lucky when inviting pressure on.
There's more than one way to defend a lead, as I mentioned in my thread about Newcastle. And whilst Dekka is right to an extent. There have been different decision he could have made when making subs and he has punted for the 'text book' cloggy, negative choices. I just hope it's exactly what Dekka says and not his natural tendency. I guess we will only find out when that excuse is taken away from him when we get a Grant/Bany back fit.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
Who gets to decide if they're positive, negative or neutral? You? How are you avoiding your hiasvthrte then??
Posts: 9,618
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
10-05-2025, 06:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-05-2025, 06:12 PM by Lurker#3.)
(10-05-2025, 05:53 PM)MrBater Wrote: Who gets to decide if they're positive, negative or neutral? You? How are you avoiding your hiasvthrte then??
Well it's my post
I think my calls on the subs are pretty fair? In fact I would say kind in some senses.
Feel free to give your opinions, MB!
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Wallace coming on and scoring at Wrexham isn't a positive sub then? Yeah ok.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(10-05-2025, 06:05 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (10-05-2025, 05:53 PM)MrBater Wrote: Who gets to decide if they're positive, negative or neutral? You? How are you avoiding your hiasvthrte then??
Well it's my post
I think my calls on the subs are pretty fair? In fact I would say kind in some senses.
Feel free to give your opinions, MB!
My point was you even mentioned avoiding confirmation bias.
I don't think it's been the subs, I think it's been a rookie manager trying to force things to happen that haven't worked out, mainly because we have no real options.
Unless he finds a super kid then nothing is going to change either.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I think maybe you don’t realise how biased this is. The Milwall game was awful but the majority of those are positive changes. How can Maja coming on for Wallace not be a positive sub?
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(10-05-2025, 05:21 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (10-05-2025, 05:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I admire the effort here Lurker but I do think you need to take into account the result at the time too - in 5 of those games we’d have been winning at the time of the majority of those subs so it would make sense that he didn’t open us up.
Portsmouth and Derby were very poor, we left it far too late to push for something… yesterday he left things far too late and should have made changes at HT, but we were that bad im not sure subbing all XI would have made a difference.
If we were consistently playing well and comfortably seeing games out I would agree, pal. But we have been struggling to keep hold of control in games and have on a couple of occasions got lucky when inviting pressure on.
There's more than one way to defend a lead, as I mentioned in my thread about Newcastle. And whilst Dekka is right to an extent. There have been different decision he could have made when making subs and he has punted for the 'text book' cloggy, negative choices. I just hope it's exactly what Dekka says and not his natural tendency. I guess we will only find out when that excuse is taken away from him when we get a Grant/Bany back fit.
I get what you’re saying, and I respect your opinion on the analysis of games, you’re well in advance of most on here!
In fairness to Mason, his squad is not on that’s exactly stocked with counter attacking talent, and much like under CC, if he has confidence in his team to see out a lead, it makes sense that he would shore it up and seek to retain possession or at least push teams into areas they can’t threaten, and for the most part I think we do this well.
Where I have an issue with Mason is the lack of reactivity when we go behind. We haven’t taken a point from a losing position yet this season, and it’s something we’ve struggled with as a squad for a while. I understand he’s not had a wealth of options in an already depleted attack, but if we get Bany, Grant and possibly Dike back in the next 2 weeks, we need to start seeing improvement here!
|