Charlie Kirk
People trying to get people fired or deplatformed = cancel culture. This is something both the Left and Right engage in, btw.

The government actually getting you fired because they don't like what you are saying = state suppression of speech.

I don't agree with cancel culture, but it's very obvious that the government censoring speech is more serious than social media mobs.
Reply
(09-19-2025, 08:36 AM)Squid Wrote: People trying to get people fired or deplatformed = cancel culture. This is something both the Left and Right engage in, btw.

The government actually getting you fired because they don't like what you are saying = state suppression of speech.

I don't agree with cancel culture, but it's very obvious that the government censoring speech is more serious than social media mobs.

Spot on. What the Trump Administration is doing is much more dangerous than a few snowflakes bleating on Twitter.
Reply
Bill Maher nails it. Moronic debate about two opposite factions dragging all the sane ones into this. https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-enter...27117.html
Reply
(09-19-2025, 08:49 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2025, 08:36 AM)Squid Wrote: People trying to get people fired or deplatformed = cancel culture. This is something both the Left and Right engage in, btw.

The government actually getting you fired because they don't like what you are saying = state suppression of speech.

I don't agree with cancel culture, but it's very obvious that the government censoring speech is more serious than social media mobs.

Spot on. What the Trump Administration is doing is much more dangerous than a few snowflakes bleating on Twitter.

Brian Kilmeade suggests on Fox News that homeless people should be given involuntary lethal injections -"Just kill 'em!"

Jimmy Kimmel makes fun of the orange moron's truly nonsensical response when asked how Kirk's death was affecting him ("I'm having a new ballroom built").

Guess who's been banned.
Reply
(09-19-2025, 08:36 AM)Squid Wrote: People trying to get people fired or deplatformed = cancel culture. This is something both the Left and Right engage in, btw.

The government actually getting you fired because they don't like what you are saying = state suppression of speech.

I don't agree with cancel culture, but it's very obvious that the government censoring speech is more serious than social media mobs.

This is a very good post.

Individuals have the right to give a view that they feel someone should be sacked...this is primarily a football message board it happens all the time.

They can call for boycots against products, organisations, countries etc. 

This is the essence of free speech.

But just because they say it, we don't have to meekly go along with it. For example I might not agree with J K Rowling but I wouldn't boycott her output, I'll still watch the Cormoran Strike series on tv, even if others are advocating a boycott.

Completely different from Govts imposing censorship.
Reply
(09-19-2025, 08:36 AM)Squid Wrote: People trying to get people fired or deplatformed = cancel culture. This is something both the Left and Right engage in, btw.

The government actually getting you fired because they don't like what you are saying = state suppression of speech.

I don't agree with cancel culture, but it's very obvious that the government censoring speech is more serious than social media mobs.

Well put.
However, it's shocking that people need this explained to them.
Reply
(09-19-2025, 10:16 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-19-2025, 08:36 AM)Squid Wrote: People trying to get people fired or deplatformed = cancel culture. This is something both the Left and Right engage in, btw.

The government actually getting you fired because they don't like what you are saying = state suppression of speech.

I don't agree with cancel culture, but it's very obvious that the government censoring speech is more serious than social media mobs.

This is a very good post.

Individuals have the right to give a view that they feel someone should be sacked...this is primarily a football message board it happens all the time.

They can call for boycots against products, organisations, countries etc. 

This is the essence of free speech.

But just because they say it, we don't have to meekly go along with it. For example I might not agree with J K Rowling but I wouldn't boycott her output, I'll still watch the Cormoran Strike series on tv, even if others are advocating a boycott.

Completely different from Govts imposing censorship.

Rowling's an interesting example. 

I don't agree with her views at all (please let's not turn this into a debate on her views) and would not personally buy any products or do anything that financially benefits her in any way. The issue however is that I have young children and they're approaching the age where Harry Potter is pretty much inescapable. So eventually I'll almost certainly have to suck it up and buy the books, films, merch, etc.
Reply
(09-19-2025, 11:35 AM)Duffers Wrote: Rowling's an interesting example. 

I don't agree with her views at all (please let's not turn this into a debate on her views) and would not personally buy any products or do anything that financially benefits her in any way. The issue however is that I have young children and they're approaching the age where Harry Potter is pretty much inescapable. So eventually I'll almost certainly have to suck it up and buy the books, films, merch, etc.

Rowling is an absolute heroine for most girls my kids' ages, and for me too tbh.
Reply
People actually boycott products in real life based on someone’s views?

Christ, I always presumed that was just something people threatened on social media to make a point, but never actually did it.
Reply
(09-19-2025, 11:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-19-2025, 11:35 AM)Duffers Wrote: Rowling's an interesting example. 

I don't agree with her views at all (please let's not turn this into a debate on her views) and would not personally buy any products or do anything that financially benefits her in any way. The issue however is that I have young children and they're approaching the age where Harry Potter is pretty much inescapable. So eventually I'll almost certainly have to suck it up and buy the books, films, merch, etc.

Rowling is an absolute heroine for most girls my kids' ages, and for me too tbh.

Again, I've no interest in getting into any arguments about her or her views.

Just using her as an example of a divisive figure who it's actually very difficult to boycott.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: