Charlie Kirk
(09-18-2025, 12:20 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-...ensorship/

So Trump the cunt says one thing does whatever fits his agenda.
Quelle surprise!

Fake news.  Big Grin

Talking of his lies - did anyone watch the C4 programme last night, Trump v The Truth?  They listed 100 lies he's told since being President for the second time.

The tattoo interview https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89JJcUHqC30 was hilarious.  Well it would be if it was satire and not actually true.  I gave up and went to sleep after this one.

Despite things like this, the utter stupidity and contempt for the truth, people still follow and believe in him.   Games gone Tom.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
The American descent into McCarthyism is picking up speed.

First Jimmy Kimmell gets cancelled and now prominent universities are naming names.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world...25985.html
Reply
I'm sorry but comparing modern day cancel culture with McCarthyism is as flawed as calling people on the right of centre, Nazis. It demonstrates either a lack of understanding as to the insidious nature and mechanisms of the HUAC, or is deliberately inflammatory hyperbole.

Cancel culture in a nutshell, these people are not serious people:

Charlie Kirk is shot (and killed), TV and movie star Chris Pratt offers his thoughts and prayers on social media, the left, "we must petition Disney to remove Pratt from his Marvel role and any other projects", Kimmel is fired, the left, "boycott Disney".
Reply
(09-18-2025, 10:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: I'm sorry but comparing modern day cancel culture with McCarthyism is as flawed as calling people on the right of centre, Nazis. It demonstrates either a lack of understanding as to the insidious nature and mechanisms of the HUAC, or is deliberately inflammatory hyperbole.

Cancel culture in a nutshell, these people are not serious people:

Charlie Kirk is shot (and killed), TV and movie star Chris Pratt offers his thoughts and prayers on social media, the left, "we must petition Disney to remove Pratt from his Marvel role and any other projects", Kimmel is fired, the left, "boycott Disney".

I was actually comparing the handing over 160 names by a university to the US government as McCarthy-esque, but let’s not stop the rest of your post eh?

Kimmell’s firing came, by all accounts, as a result of pressure from the government who didn’t take kindly to a little criticism.

You can bleat about the left and “cancel culture” all you want, but it’s becoming apparent that those with the means to silence dissenting voices are actually using that power now.

https://x.com/acyn/status/19688049688124...qkPwh6EZ-w

“They’re not allowed to criticise me” - this is how dictators speak.
Reply
(09-18-2025, 11:03 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-18-2025, 10:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: I'm sorry but comparing modern day cancel culture with McCarthyism is as flawed as calling people on the right of centre, Nazis. It demonstrates either a lack of understanding as to the insidious nature and mechanisms of the HUAC, or is deliberately inflammatory hyperbole.

Cancel culture in a nutshell, these people are not serious people:

Charlie Kirk is shot (and killed), TV and movie star Chris Pratt offers his thoughts and prayers on social media, the left, "we must petition Disney to remove Pratt from his Marvel role and any other projects", Kimmel is fired, the left, "boycott Disney".

I was actually comparing the handing over 160 names by a university to the US government as McCarthy-esque, but let’s not stop the rest of your post eh?

Kimmell’s firing came, by all accounts, as a result of pressure from the government who didn’t take kindly to a little criticism.

You can bleat about the left and “cancel culture” all you want, but it’s becoming apparent that those with the means to silence dissenting voices are actually using that power now.

https://x.com/acyn/status/19688049688124...qkPwh6EZ-w

“They’re not allowed to criticise me” - this is how dictators speak.

Cheers for the clarification.

So suspected anti-semitism shouldn't be investigated and, if found, rooted out? The university in question shouldn't fulfill its legal obligation to provide the information requested? Got it.

But let's not stop at the rest of your post eh?

Kimmell was suspended because major conservative affiliates like Sinclair threatened to preempt the show.

As I said earlier in the thread, the shoe is now on the other foot and people who revelled in getting people cancelled are now crying foul. This is the same company that fired Gina Carano from The Mandalorian for an insensitive deleted tweet (a deleted tweet, not a monologue on national television) about COVID mandates to rapturous support from the same people who now want to boycott them for Kimmell.

This is just cancel culture being turned on it's exponents, not a descent into autocracy or (in the case of Berkeley fulfilling its legal obligations) a re-run of Salem or McCarthyism, no matter what Mia Farrow says on the nonce app.

Preston Mitchum yesterday: 'The right allegedly wants "free speech" yet are attempting to stop the voice of anyone who disagrees.'

Preston Mitchum on cancel culture in 2023: 'Unfortunately sometimes this must be done publicly to gain ongoing support and get the point across that what happened was unacceptable and for accountability to be achieved.'

Brilliant stuff.
Reply
(09-18-2025, 12:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-18-2025, 08:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-18-2025, 08:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-18-2025, 08:02 AM)HugeHons Wrote: Because we’re not under the EU umbrella anymore

Rolleyes Oh please...

The greatest irony is that, like him or not, Charlie Kirk invited disagreement and would actively debate it. The MAGA movement is already adopting the same methods as Joe McCarthy and Putin. In the 3 trips I've taken to the States since the election the discussions I'm having with Yanks about politics are ever more in hushed-tones. It's exceptionally unhealthy.

No he didn't. He targeted his debates against inexperienced university students and deployed numerous fallacies that they didn't know how to counter. He actively refused to debate people like Dean Withers and lied about having debated them.

I have as little clue who Dean Withers is as I had about Charlie Kirk last week tbh.

But if what you say about Charlie Kirk is true then he sounds like that Gary twat going round telling everyone that a wealth tax is the solution to all our problems.

Gary Davies or Gary Newbon?
Reply
Don’t even get me started on Gary Newbon
Reply
Jacko - there’s currently one huge big difference between the two sides though regarding this “cancel culture” or Freedom of speech debate.’ Both left and right have been guilty of overstepping in recent years and leftist pressure on this has come from think tanks, independent leftist bodies and political activists and yes that includes some in the media. That’s not acceptable.

Currently this attack on freedom of speech is coming right from the heart of the White House. Vance did his own McCarthy-esque speech (we have a list) and independent positions within State government are seeing people removed and replaced with Government puppets. I’m sure many governments have appointed people sympathetic to their views, but this is being blatantly flaunted as happening and any questioning of this suppressed.

I would hope, and I’m assuming your persona is not someone else on the wind-up, you could see why this attack from the right is so much different. It’s coming from a position of power.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
The only response I see from the right on the current attack on free speech is..well you started it. What next, "your mom"?
Reply
(09-19-2025, 07:25 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Jacko - there’s currently one huge big difference between the two sides though regarding this “cancel culture” or Freedom of speech debate.’  Both left and right have been guilty of overstepping in recent years and leftist pressure on this has come from think tanks, independent leftist bodies and political activists and yes that includes some in the media.  That’s not acceptable.

Currently this attack on freedom of speech is coming right from the heart of the White House.  Vance did his own McCarthy-esque speech (we have a list) and independent positions within State government are seeing people removed and replaced with Government puppets.  I’m sure many governments have appointed people sympathetic to their views, but this is being blatantly flaunted as happening and any questioning of this suppressed.

I would hope, and I’m assuming your persona is not someone else on the wind-up, you could see why this attack from the right is so much different.  It’s coming from a position of power.

You've saved me the trouble of replying.

Kimmell was cancelled as a result of pressure from the government after airing his opinion that they were making capital out of Kirk's assassination. Silencing dissenting voices in the media is a key trait of authoritarian regiemes.

UC Berkely handed over details of 160 individuals who were pro-Palestine and critical of Israel's actions. There's nothing "anti-Semitic" per se about criticising Israel, but it is a useful jumped up charge to shut down dissent.

The President last night effectively threatened that any TV network that runs critical pieces on him could have the licenses revoked. He is also attempting to sue the WSJ for their claims they had a note written by him to Epstein, a note that's now gone public.

None of this is in keeping with a secure, healthy democracy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)