EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule'
#21
How long before the first female manager? I'm assuming we're not counting Cherie Lunghi.
Reply
#22
(06-07-2019, 08:31 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: How long before the first female manager? I'm assuming we're not counting Cherie Lunghi.
Fit Wink
Flag shagging,misogynistic,covidiot,anitvax gammon.
Or just a normal white bloke.
Reply
#23
(06-07-2019, 08:31 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: How long before the first female manager? I'm assuming we're not counting Cherie Lunghi.

I’ve still got that series on dvd somewhere - well ahead of its time

(06-07-2019, 04:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 04:03 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 03:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.

Do you honestly believe that?

That's an oversimplification but yes, obviously salary etc. comes into it but if it's decided that you're the best candidate for the job then you'll get it. Also being a football manager is different from many other professions in the sense that there's a lot more head hunting going on and a lot of information is known about the potential candidates before a formal process has even taken place. Frequently a team will have an idea in mind of who they want to take over before the formal process has started. 

This won't change with the Rooney rule. The BAME managers that have shown themselves capable of managing at a high level either have jobs (Nuno) or will get another high level job (Hughton). The ones that have shown themselves not to be good enough (Paul Ince, John Barnes) will continue not to get high level jobs.
 
You’ve just captured the point right there. 

If you are good enough - you get employed/another opportunity to succeed.  

The difference is that the mediocre white managers keep getting opportunities - and we talk about them all the fugging time on here/see the next thread - whereas the Bame counterparts don’t get as many opportunities.  Whether it’s their first job or getting another chance.  

Whether the Rooney rule redresses that is of course another point of debate.
Reply
#24
Does the Rooney rule mean all players must be thick as shit,shag oaps,be shit for England, drive drunk and then go and do it all again in America?
Reply
#25
Funny thing, racism. I'm a manager of two people at the moment (one of them is me). I'm trying to "sell" my colleague to a company we've just merged with - they need a couple of people short term at short notice, which would solve my immediate problem with workload. So I had a long chat with an old mate over there (who is British Asian background) and walked away with a suspicion that he didn't want my buddy (whom he has never met) because he is Nigerian. Did I imagine this? Did my own innate racism influence the way I tried to sell the fellow to them? Do I raise the "R" word with management to try to resolve it?

Minefield.
Reply
#26
Unfortunately you have to take it as face value pulling out the race card is a terrible thing to say to do and more important to prove .
Reply
#27
(06-07-2019, 09:14 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 08:31 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: How long before the first female manager? I'm assuming we're not counting Cherie Lunghi.

I’ve still got that series on dvd somewhere - well ahead of its time

(06-07-2019, 04:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 04:03 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 03:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.

Do you honestly believe that?

That's an oversimplification but yes, obviously salary etc. comes into it but if it's decided that you're the best candidate for the job then you'll get it. Also being a football manager is different from many other professions in the sense that there's a lot more head hunting going on and a lot of information is known about the potential candidates before a formal process has even taken place. Frequently a team will have an idea in mind of who they want to take over before the formal process has started. 

This won't change with the Rooney rule. The BAME managers that have shown themselves capable of managing at a high level either have jobs (Nuno) or will get another high level job (Hughton). The ones that have shown themselves not to be good enough (Paul Ince, John Barnes) will continue not to get high level jobs.
 
You’ve just captured the point right there. 

If you are good enough - you get employed/another opportunity to succeed.  

The difference is that the mediocre white managers keep getting opportunities - and we talk about them all the fugging time on here/see the next thread - whereas the Bame counterparts don’t get as many opportunities.  Whether it’s their first job or getting another chance.  

Whether the Rooney rule redresses that is of course another point of debate.

Good post, Manc. The issue with football is that due to its structure decisions on managers are governed in 90%* of cases by fear rather than ambition.









*in a study conducted by myself
Reply
#28
(06-07-2019, 09:14 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: You’ve just captured the point right there. 

If you are good enough - you get employed/another opportunity to succeed.  

The difference is that the mediocre white managers keep getting opportunities - and we talk about them all the fugging time on here/see the next thread - whereas the Bame counterparts don’t get as many opportunities.  Whether it’s their first job or getting another chance.  

Whether the Rooney rule redresses that is of course another point of debate.

But what I'd say is that if we're talking about Barnes, he had multiple chances already and has absolutely no successes to show for it. The likes of Pardew, Hughes etc. at least showed something at Premier league level (e.g. taking Newcastle to 5th, in Hughes case taking (I think it was) Fulham to a top 8 finish and keeping Stoke in the top 10 for consecutive seasons. Generally the managers who show promise at Premier League level keep getting jobs.

Managers with comparable records to Barnes end up falling down the leagues or going back into coaching. Where is Steve Kean these days? Ricky Sbragia had two years searching for managerial posts after Sunderland before he gave up and went back to coaching the Under 17s for Scotland.

I certainly don't support the idea that Paul Ince didn't have a chance. 

He's had 6 managerial positions, did well at Macclesfield and then in his first stint at MK Dons at League Two Level. 

Based on this he got the Blackburn job in the Premier League, and won 3 in 17, and failed miserably; he went back to MK Dons and did an unspectacular job, then leaving because he thought he could do better. 

After that he broke the club record for number of losses at Notts County.

Then went to Blackpool before the chaos started and won 1 in 4, not only this but he was touting his son to Monaco despite still being Blackpool manager.

There's absolutely nothing in this story arc to suggest he's been affected by his race. He got a Prem job off the back of a League Two job and ultimately has a CV of a manager that can be a success at League Two level, but hasn't shown anything more than this. 


The problem with the Rooney Rule is that while it's well intentioned it's not addressing the real issue. It's not that BAME managers are being denied jobs in favour of white candidates, it's that not enough BAME individuals are going into coaching and management. That's something that can be encouraged during the coaching badge stages, but all the Rooney rule is going to do is lead to a large number of job rejections for those BAME candidates because there's not enough BAME candidates going into management.
Reply
#29
(06-08-2019, 08:53 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 09:14 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: You’ve just captured the point right there. 

If you are good enough - you get employed/another opportunity to succeed.  

The difference is that the mediocre white managers keep getting opportunities - and we talk about them all the fugging time on here/see the next thread - whereas the Bame counterparts don’t get as many opportunities.  Whether it’s their first job or getting another chance.  

Whether the Rooney rule redresses that is of course another point of debate.

But what I'd say is that if we're talking about Barnes, he had multiple chances already and has absolutely no successes to show for it. The likes of Pardew, Hughes etc. at least showed something at Premier league level (e.g. taking Newcastle to 5th, in Hughes case taking (I think it was) Fulham to a top 8 finish and keeping Stoke in the top 10 for consecutive seasons. Generally the managers who show promise at Premier League level keep getting jobs.

Managers with comparable records to Barnes end up falling down the leagues or going back into coaching. Where is Steve Kean these days? Ricky Sbragia had two years searching for managerial posts after Sunderland before he gave up and went back to coaching the Under 17s for Scotland.

I certainly don't support the idea that Paul Ince didn't have a chance. 

He's had 6 managerial positions, did well at Macclesfield and then in his first stint at MK Dons at League Two Level. 

Based on this he got the Blackburn job in the Premier League, and won 3 in 17, and failed miserably; he went back to MK Dons and did an unspectacular job, then leaving because he thought he could do better. 

After that he broke the club record for number of losses at Notts County.

Then went to Blackpool before the chaos started and won 1 in 4, not only this but he was touting his son to Monaco despite still being Blackpool manager.

There's absolutely nothing in this story arc to suggest he's been affected by his race. He got a Prem job off the back of a League Two job and ultimately has a CV of a manager that can be a success at League Two level, but hasn't shown anything more than this. 


The problem with the Rooney Rule is that while it's well intentioned it's not addressing the real issue. It's not that BAME managers are being denied jobs in favour of white candidates, it's that not enough BAME individuals are going into coaching and management. That's something that can be encouraged during the coaching badge stages, but all the Rooney rule is going to do is lead to a large number of job rejections for those BAME candidates because there's not enough BAME candidates going into management.

Thats a really well set out argument.  What the Rooney rule will do is create a pathway.  If you achieve these qualifications then you are guaranteed an interview, thus more BAME players going into coaching.
Reply
#30
Well it's about more than just badges. Coaching experience will do more towards landing you a job, it's not enough to get a badge and assume you'll get a job. That's not a realistic message to send out.

I just think there HAS to be a better way, if we're going to encourage more BAME individuals to get into coaching, than creating a system whereby you're actively searching for a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've interviewed them. It's tokenism, it's very patronising and I can't see how it's going to make any difference when teams generally have an idea of who they want to get the job not only prior to the interview itself, but prior to a formal process even taking place.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)