Ratings......
#1
This is getting ridiculous now, why we cannot see this system doesn’t work at home I just can’t understand. We look comfortable playing deep and countering away but when we have to build the play and attack the opposition we seem clueless.

Up top we are fast, but we are very lightweight, and whilst HRK is limited, he wins a lot of fouls that relieves the pressure. Defensively, we are solid enough doing the basics but when we have a midfield  as static as today, so little to aim for up top, and no one in the middle who can just put their foot on the ball and dictate the tempo we will struggle at home.

Yes we miss Barnes and Phillips, but we have enough in this squad to select a better XI than tonight. 

Johnstone - 7 - Not a lot of chance with either goal and an excellent save to keep us in it. 

Holgate - 6 - sorry but he doesn’t have it. In the side because he’s better than Mears and Tosin, but makes the wrong decision time and time again 
Adarabaiyo - 4 - Not sure where the Tosin from Brighton has gone. Looked a shadow of the player he was a couple weeks ago.
Dawson - 4 - needs Hegazi alongside him. Anyone who thinks Dawson is better than Hegazi needs his head looking at.
Gibbs - 6 - Poor game for him. 

Livermore - 3 - utter garbage. Someone take the tippex to his contract sharpish... cannot play the pivot role, too slow and heavy to play facing goal and distribute. Naive from the management to think he could play that role.
Harper 6 - energetic, shame that shot didn’t go in, but can’t do it all himself.
Johansen - 5 - Unbalanced midfield, couldn’t get on the ball. Need to use him better.

Murphy - 5 - Lightweight and lazy. Looked interested for 10 mins but otherwise anonymous
Rodriguez - 5 - thankfully he can take a decent pen. Too slow in the middle, takes too long on the ball, and too easily defended. 
Gayle - 6 - was never a pen but knew what he was doing... gave the ref a decision to make. Disgraceful how underused he is.

Barry - 7 - changed the game when he came on. Gets his foot on the ball  and finds space for our players to run into.
Hoolahan - 6 - Sadly his legs aren’t as fast as his brain. The best link man we have, but we need better. 

Moore - 4 -  deserve praise on Saturday and deserves criticism tonight. The midfield was obviously unbalanced from kick off and led to the opening goal which changed the game. Why he and Jones cannot see what is blatantly obvious To everyone I just don’t understand.
Reply
#2
Those ratings are generally fair although I would give Harper a 7, J Rod a 7 and Murphy 4.

Spot on re Dawson. A bit unfair on Holgate although he has got worse by the game.
Reply
#3
Tosin marked Grabban out of the game, ridiculous score for him
Reply
#4
(02-12-2019, 10:42 PM)Bruntsmagicwand Wrote: Tosin marked Grabban out of the game, ridiculous score for him

Except the two times where he Grabban turned him, first time he put the ball across the box, and second time Johnstone makes a class save.

Tosin was poor today, he just wasn’t punished.
Reply
#5
(02-12-2019, 10:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 10:42 PM)Bruntsmagicwand Wrote: Tosin marked Grabban out of the game, ridiculous score for him

Except the two times where he Grabban turned him, first time he put the ball across the box, and second time Johnstone makes a class save.

Tosin was poor today, he just wasn’t punished.
It's just 'Mad being 'Mad....
Reply
#6
(02-12-2019, 10:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 10:42 PM)Bruntsmagicwand Wrote: Tosin marked Grabban out of the game, ridiculous score for him

Except the two times where he Grabban turned him, first time he put the ball across the box, and second time Johnstone makes a class save.

Tosin was poor today, he just wasn’t punished.
Not to mention jumping under the ball for the second goal.
Reply
#7
Very generous on Gayle, despite winning the pen he was basically a waste of a position for 89 minutes. Also harsh on Tosin, was miles better than Dawson today. The rest seem relatively reasonable
Reply
#8
(02-12-2019, 10:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: This is getting ridiculous now, why we cannot see this system doesn’t work at home I just can’t understand. We look comfortable playing deep and countering away but when we have to build the play and attack the opposition we seem clueless.

Up top we are fast, but we are very lightweight, and whilst HRK is limited, he wins a lot of fouls that relieves the pressure. Defensively, we are solid enough doing the basics but when we have a midfield  as static as today, so little to aim for up top, and no one in the middle who can just put their foot on the ball and dictate the tempo we will struggle at home.

Yes we miss Barnes and Phillips, but we have enough in this squad to select a better XI than tonight. 

Johnstone - 7 - Not a lot of chance with either goal and an excellent save to keep us in it. 

Holgate - 6 - sorry but he doesn’t have it. In the side because he’s better than Mears and Tosin, but makes the wrong decision time and time again 
Adarabaiyo - 4 - Not sure where the Tosin from Brighton has gone. Looked a shadow of the player he was a couple weeks ago.
Dawson - 4 - needs Hegazi alongside him. Anyone who thinks Dawson is better than Hegazi needs his head looking at.
Gibbs - 6 - Poor game for him. 

Livermore - 3 - utter garbage. Someone take the tippex to his contract sharpish... cannot play the pivot role, too slow and heavy to play facing goal and distribute. Naive from the management to think he could play that role.
Harper 6 - energetic, shame that shot didn’t go in, but can’t do it all himself.
Johansen - 5 - Unbalanced midfield, couldn’t get on the ball. Need to use him better.

Murphy - 5 - Lightweight and lazy. Looked interested for 10 mins but otherwise anonymous
Rodriguez - 5 - thankfully he can take a decent pen. Too slow in the middle, takes too long on the ball, and too easily defended. 
Gayle - 6 - was never a pen but knew what he was doing... gave the ref a decision to make. Disgraceful how underused he is.

Barry - 7 - changed the game when he came on. Gets his foot on the ball  and finds space for our players to run into.
Hoolahan - 6 - Sadly his legs aren’t as fast as his brain. The best link man we have, but we need better. 

Moore - 4 -  deserve praise on Saturday and deserves criticism tonight. The midfield was obviously unbalanced from kick off and led to the opening goal which changed the game. Why he and Jones cannot see what is blatantly obvious To everyone I just don’t understand.

Agree midfield was wrong but was one most on here picked.
Reply
#9
Johnstone 7

Holgate 5
Dawson 4
Tosin 4
Gibbs 5

Harper 7
Livermore 4
Johansen 5

Gayle 6
Rodriguez 6
Murphy 5

Barry 7.5
Hoolahan 6

Moore 5

Fans 3
Reply
#10
Would give Johnstone more than a 7 personally. His world class save earns a point tonight.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)