Housing asylum seekers
#1
I thought this was a decent report from the BBC regarding the issues of housing asylum seekers. Personally I think if the Labour government persists with HMOs as a replacement for hotels, they are signing their own political death warrant, sooner rather than later. Communities do not want them, they will cause huge resentment (already are) and they are incentivising private landlords to kick families out of accommodation in favour of people who may or may not have justified reason to seek asylum.

HMOs
Reply
#2
Explain the 'no legal right' bit to me Dekka - could they be arrested for being placed in accommodation? And are you now falling for the 'Illegal' immigrant lines? Where would you like them to be placed, maybe camps where they could be concentrated into one area away from the general public - maybe even a train ride away?
Reply
#3
(09-09-2025, 10:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Explain the 'no legal right' bit to me Dekka - could they be arrested for being placed in accommodation? And are you now falling for the 'Illegal' immigrant lines? Where would you like them to  be placed, maybe camps where they could be concentrated into one area away from the general public - maybe even a train ride away?

B1 they may or may not have legal status to stay in the UK, they haven’t been assessed before they are housed in a HMO. So their legal right to stay in the country is an unknown at such time. Where did I use the term ‘illegal immigrant’ in my post? I didn’t you did in some tedious ‘gotcha’ comment. There will be genuine asylum seekers and there will be some without a reason to be in the country via unofficial routes. 

If you think it’s ok for Serco to rock up in areas earning millions replacing family accommodation with HMOs, with almost zero responsibility for them once they are there, and at the same time there are thousands of families waiting for accommodation for years then that’s up to you. It does tell me one thing, you’re a gift for Farage and Reform, if you think that HMOs are the answer to the problem.
Reply
#4
Their legal right to be in the country pre-assessment is not unknown. 'No legal Right' is relatively obvious in it's meaning, it's simply another way of saying illegal.

And no, I don't think it's right but as ever in your world there appears to be no solution but the contract was put in place years ago under one of the iterations of the last government. So unless you want an expensive court battle and legal dispute costing as much as housing the asylum seekers that is a reality.

https://asylummatters.org/app/uploads/20...-Guide.pdf
Reply
#5
Their legal right to be in the country is assumed at the point of entry and asylum is claimed. It is only after they have been processed and found not to qualify for asylum that they become "illegal".
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#6
(09-09-2025, 11:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Their legal right to be in the country pre-assessment is not unknown. 'No legal Right' is relatively obvious in it's meaning, it's simply another way of saying illegal.

And no, I don't think it's right but as ever in your world there appears to be no solution but the contract was put in place years ago under one of the iterations of the last government. So unless you want an expensive court battle and legal dispute costing as much as housing the asylum seekers that is a reality.

https://asylummatters.org/app/uploads/20...-Guide.pdf

It’ll cost the Labour Party the next election if it continues to swap hotels for HMOs. Labour either face the reality of the situation or they just open the door to Reform. It may not have been their fault but it’s now their problem.
Reply
#7
Here are your options:
1. Tear up a contract that will cost you best part of £2Bn in costs and still have to find housing for thousands of asylum seekers; or
2. Continue until there is an alternative solution - taking into account we are approaching the winter and the numbers will start to drop naturally.

Labours failure on this issue so far has been to implement a better processing system and places for asylum seekers to go outside of the UK to be processed. Dealing with those already here with a contract already in place is not their failure.
Reply
#8
I did watch the report & thought it was decent & balanced
Im sure it said it was in Burney ??

Now imagine if Serco decided to buy up lots of large victorian properties in the London borough Islington rather than cheap poor Burnley
Would the Guardian readers be happy with groups of men hanging around outside schools or intimidating young women?

Where are the economic migrants held in France Greece & others whilst waiting to hear their case?
Reply
#9
There is no popular, cost-effective place to house asylum seekers where the locals won't complain.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bibby_Stockholm
Reply
#10
(09-09-2025, 07:40 PM)Pipkins Wrote: I did watch the report & thought it was decent & balanced
Im sure it said it was in Burney ??

Now imagine if Serco decided to buy up lots of large victorian properties in the London borough Islington rather than cheap poor Burnley
Would the Guardian readers be happy with groups of men hanging around outside schools or intimidating young women?

Where are the economic migrants held in France Greece & others whilst waiting to hear their case?

Burnley had 476 as at the end of June compared with Islington having 616.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: