(09-03-2025, 06:49 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Of the 8 players you list, a move to WBA was a step down or another club in a nomadic career. That is why I would not have signed Taylor. People go on about GMac but a move to us gave him his first chance of Premier league football and was a step up to a higher division.
I am slightly disappointed we have not signed a young winger with something to prove and who is on the way up. Iling Junior may well turn out to be another Frabotta or Dobbin, none of them seem to stay anywhere very long!
Heggebo - stepping up from the Norwegian league
Gilchrist - being offered first team football in a permanent home
Campbell - stepping up from the MLS and into Europe
Bielik - stepping up from Blues to a bigger club having had a year in League One last season
Collyer and Illing-Junior - young players being given an opportunity on loan, both with plenty to prove.
Taylor, Mepham and Phillips have made steps down having been in the PL last year, but from what we've seen of Phillips, he's hardly coming across as a billy big bollocks here for a payday. He's spent the last few years as a bit part player or out on loan, he's now got the opportunity to be a first team regular (and I imagine club captain soon) for the first time in his career. Mepham and Taylor it's too early to judge.
I would have liked to see us sign someone from the lower leagues - a pacy winger, or an attacking fullback that was making a step up instead of Taylor, but the window was closing and hes experienced backup.