Grant
#11
(08-30-2025, 06:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:11 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Grant is and has been far better than Grady.

Grant isn’t half the player and Grady has hardly been a roaring success.  Are you going through your edgy stage again, being deliberately provocative?

If we could move Grant on and replace him in the time we have left (most unlikely) then I’d happily do so.  In reality I would imagine he’ll go at the end of the season.

I think Josh is right here. Grant's contribution has been better than Grady's was. He's a limited player but he works very hard, keep the left hand side solid defensively and can produce some good attacking play. I really don't get why so many fans dislike him?

That said, as with all our other transfer dealings, I wouldn't be averse to him going and being replaced. It's just even more overhaul to deal with this window.
Reply
#12
Grady is far more talented than Grant, but Grant has contributed more to Albion than Grady.

I am not on a wind up, I'm not trying to be edgy. Just accept I'm a lifelong Albion fan that really rates one of our current players.

Is that so fucking bad? I'm not sure I should be copping stick for actually believing Grant is a bloody good player.

If I was constantly posting about how shit Styles was, I'd probably be more popular.
Reply
#13
Grant couldn't get past a stick of butter. I'd start him in games we need to soak up pressure but needs replacing if we go a goal down.
Reply
#14
(08-30-2025, 06:32 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:11 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Grant is and has been far better than Grady.

Grant isn’t half the player and Grady has hardly been a roaring success.  Are you going through your edgy stage again, being deliberately provocative?

If we could move Grant on and replace him in the time we have left (most unlikely) then I’d happily do so.  In reality I would imagine he’ll go at the end of the season.

I think Josh is right here. Grant's contribution has been better than Grady's was. He's a limited player but he works very hard, keep the left hand side solid defensively and can produce some good attacking play. I really don't get why so many fans dislike him?

That said, as with all our other transfer dealings, I wouldn't be averse to him going and being replaced. It's just even more overhaul to deal with this window.

He's been roundly criticised for the vast majority of his time at the club. Only really turning up and putting in the hard work last season after his year at Cardiff.

Diangana contributed massively the year he was on loan, contributed more in the PL season, our first season back in the 2nd tier (Val/Bruce season) Grant got 18 goals as we failed to reach the play-offs, despite that tally he was regularly criticised for his overall contribution to the team. Subsequently, he was so bad the following season that Corberán gave the green light to sending him on a season long loan to a team in the same division in 23/24. Then last season,  Grant's 'redemption' year, Diangana still out performed him, he had more goal involvements per 90 than Grant. 7 in 1500 minutes as opposed to 9 in 3000 minutes. Yes he came back from the  wilderness of the Cardiff loan and finally put in some effort, but let's not rewrite history.
Reply
#15
My comment mentioning Diangana was purely that you can pick out a couple of seasons with both players where they have been very/pretty good and others where they really haven’t justified the outlay. This summer there wasn’t really any debate about whether to let Diangana go. I think we all knew it was the time to part ways. I think the same will happen with Grant next summer.
Reply
#16
(08-30-2025, 06:52 PM)HLS Wrote: Grant couldn't get past a stick of butter. I'd start him in games we need to soak up pressure but needs replacing if we go a goal down.

Grant literally went past defenders in his last game v Wrexham. Or are we ignoring that? 

What is this Vendetta against Grant. I don't get it. You've got to be a clueless idiot not to see and understand his contributions.
Reply
#17
I don't believe we'll replace Fellows - at least like for like.
We've got 3 wingers/ wide players, Grant, Jed, Johnson. We won't always play with 2 of the three, so not necessary IMO.
I wonder whether the £10m has already been spent (fees and wages), given our finances?
Always happy to see fresh blood, mind ,so I'll be happy to be wrong...
Reply
#18
Diangana just did loads of damage passing to the opposition, giving away free kicks generally just falling on his arse at really bad times, I’d have Grant in the team any day of the week above diangana
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)