Caleb Taylor
#41
(08-30-2025, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.

We throw him in for two or three games when there are injuries, we play him in scratch teams in the pointless league cup and then say… I don’t rate him. Other players we buy come into the team and fans say, they need time to settle in and gel with the team.
Reply
#42
(08-30-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.

We throw him in for two or three games when there are injuries, we play him in scratch teams in the pointless league cup and then say… I don’t rate him. Other players we buy come into the team and fans say, I think he’s not good enough.

No, I've not seen anything to think he's a top end championship player but my opinion isn’t important. The opinion of all the Albion managers that have seen him day in day out is more important.
Reply
#43
(08-30-2025, 10:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.

We throw him in for two or three games when there are injuries, we play him in scratch teams in the pointless league cup and then say… I don’t rate him. Other players we buy come into the team and fans say, I think he’s not good enough.

No, I've not seen anything to think he's a top end championship player but my opinion isn’t important. The opinion of all the Albion managers that have seen him day in day out is more important.

He’s had seasoned pros in front of him, his chances were always going to be limited until this season. Griffiths hasn’t exactly looked anything above average on many occasions but I accept that he needs time and the opportunity to play if he’s ever to be judged good enough. The same consistency of approach is lacking with Taylor.
Reply
#44
(08-30-2025, 10:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.

We throw him in for two or three games when there are injuries, we play him in scratch teams in the pointless league cup and then say… I don’t rate him. Other players we buy come into the team and fans say, I think he’s not good enough.

No, I've not seen anything to think he's a top end championship player but my opinion isn’t important. The opinion of all the Albion managers that have seen him day in day out is more important.

That's a bit disingenuous Rich, for most of the last 3 seasons Taylor hasn't been available for our managers to pick as he has been out on loan playing first team football .

He was then and remains now still a relatively young player, especially for that position. It's not surprising given his age that managers have come to the conclusion that he and we were better served by him going out on loan. 

I have no problem with the decision to sell him, it paved the way for us to bring in an experienced player like Mepham who has huge amounts of experience and very recent success at this level.

I just don't understand why some seem to go out of the way to be a bit critical of the player. When you could argue that he is another success story from our academy. He is going to a club in the league we are playing in, it's not a step down for him.
Reply
#45
(08-30-2025, 10:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.

We throw him in for two or three games when there are injuries, we play him in scratch teams in the pointless league cup and then say… I don’t rate him. Other players we buy come into the team and fans say, I think he’s not good enough.

No, I've not seen anything to think he's a top end championship player but my opinion isn’t important. The opinion of all the Albion managers that have seen him day in day out is more important.

On the flip side a side that finished above us last season do deem him good enough. Given we’ve gone down the route of more experienced players in Phillips and Mepham I think it’s the right call to sell him but I wouldn’t at all be surprised if he’s a success for Millwall
Reply
#46
(08-30-2025, 11:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.

We throw him in for two or three games when there are injuries, we play him in scratch teams in the pointless league cup and then say… I don’t rate him. Other players we buy come into the team and fans say, I think he’s not good enough.

No, I've not seen anything to think he's a top end championship player but my opinion isn’t important. The opinion of all the Albion managers that have seen him day in day out is more important.

That's a bit disingenuous Rich, for most of the last 3 seasons Taylor hasn't been available for our managers to pick as he has been out on loan playing first team football .

He was then and remains now still a relatively young player, especially for that position. It's not surprising given his age that managers have come to the conclusion that he and we were better served by him going out on loan. 

I have no problem with the decision to sell him, it paved the way for us to bring in an experienced player like Mepham who has huge amounts of experience and very recent success at this level.

I just don't understand why some seem to go out of the way to be a bit critical of the player. When you could argue that he is another success story from our academy. He is going to a club in the league we are playing in, it's not a step down for him.

They will have all seen him in training when at the club,  had him assessed and reported back on when on loan. I think it was pretty telling that he went back to Wycombe last January after originally being recalled to be part of the squad.

I am not being critical of the lad. I think he's a decent mid to lower championship player who may improve further with experience at this level. But we've gone and bought a player for less than we've sold him for who is already a top end championship defender. That's good business.
Reply
#47
I think the mentality with youngsters has changed. In the past if you had a 21/22 year old even close to first team level then you'd be excited to see how they develop in the coming years. Now I'm surprise how quickly our fans are willing to seem them shipped out. Central defenders probably peak around 27-28 years old and Taylor is already comfortably a top end league one player.

Ultimately, not having Taylor this season isn't going to have much of an impact on our season. Probably not as much as Mepham, so that's why they've gotten rid. In an ideal world I would have liked to see him develop here.
Reply
#48
The problem with Taylor is that he’s not a footballer. He’s in his twenties and can’t trap a ball hit at him. There is no place in a team that plays out from the back if you can’t control the ball with your feet no matter what other attributes he may have.
Reply
#49
(08-30-2025, 12:56 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think the mentality with youngsters has changed. In the past if you had a 21/22 year old even close to first team level then you'd be excited to see how they develop in the coming years. Now I'm surprise how quickly our fans are willing to seem them shipped out. Central defenders probably peak around 27-28 years old and Taylor is already comfortably a top end league one player.

Ultimately, not having Taylor this season isn't going to have much of an impact on our season. Probably not as much as Mepham, so that's why they've gotten rid. In an ideal world I would have liked to see him develop here.

Agree with all of this. If we had signed Taylor this summer from Wycombe I reckon we’d have all been excited by him - physically imposing, young, plenty of experience for his age and spent last year at the top end of League One. A player on his way up. Yet a lot of people seem really negative about him despite probably not ever really seeing him play properly aside from a few sub appearances and cup games where we put out a reserve side. I’d say only those few who regularly watch our stiffs can ever have seen enough to form a proper opinion of him.

I can understand why we’ve sold him. As Sliced says, letting him go won’t adversely impact on this season. We do look to have really improved defensively as well so can’t criticise the club at all. I did hope this would be his breakthrough season though. I wish Taylor all the best whilst also hoping that we haven’t dropped a bollock here.
Reply
#50
Won't be long before he's in the Millwall team. They got bullied by Kieffer Moore today.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: