Fellows
Rich with the logic as always.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:07 AM)richbaggie Wrote: As I've mentioned before on this thread, there are a few folks ignoring some very important points which feed in to why we may be accepting a lower bid than we'd like.

There has been very little interest. (That in itself speaks volumes when i see the crazy valuations some of our fans seem to put on him) Saints know this and are taking advantage. People then argue that we shouldn't sell and keep him. However, how do we then pay for the players we are trying to bring in? As things stand now, because of the sales we've made and wages saved, we are fine on PSR but the squad is short and we need quality in.

I fully expect that the reported 8m plus add ons will  be 8m up front now. To us, thats more valuable than some structured deal over 4 or 5 years worth 12m or so. It will allow us to finalise the summer rebuild and balance the PSR books.

I'm disappointed it's so low but understand the logic when looking at the bigger picture rather than the deal in isolation.

Question for those saying it's a ridiculous thing to do. How would you pay for the players that the club are planning to bring in before Monday without the Fellows money?

I understand the logic you're trying to present here Rich, but we now have to replace Fellows' contribution for 8M, which will be bloody difficult, considering we've got so many other positions to fix with that money already. Say we need 3-4M to bring in the fullbacks, central midfielder and forward we need, and we now also need to replace close to 20 goal involvements from last season with what remains.

Still, I guess we can go to other clubs struggling with PSR and buy their players for well below market value......

For me the question is, would I rather we kept Fellows and added maybe one or 2 loans between now and the close of the window, or will the business we complete in the next 72 hours compensate for the loss of our most creative player last year for a knock down price.

Let's wait and see.
Reply
My guess

We’ll get near as damn it £15mill once add-ons kick in over the term of TFs Saints contract. No issue there. 

Realistically 18-20 months left on deal.  Value drops as every month passes. 

Mason may want to play a 3-5-1-1 or 3-5-2 model as well, so sale not that detrimental to team and can fund players he wants. 

Maybe just maybe, TF has been upfront with club and gave no indication that he wants to extend deal.  Yes he may well have been happy to play at WBA for this season, but at some point the club needs to make money on him if that’s the case. 

No premier league clubs after him… £10-15m on table spread over 4-5 yrs…

You have to sell……
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:55 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: My guess

We’ll get near as damn it £15mill once add-ons kick in over the term of TFs Saints contract. No issue there. 

Realistically 18-20 months left on deal.  Value drops as every month passes. 

Mason may want to play a 3-5-1-1 or 3-5-2 model as well, so sale not that detrimental to team and can fund players he wants. 

Maybe just maybe, TF has been upfront with club and gave no indication that he wants to extend deal.  Yes he may well have been happy to play at WBA for this season, but at some point the club needs to make money on him if that’s the case. 

No premier league clubs after him… £10-15m on table spread over 4-5 yrs…

You have to sell……

If it is 8-10M upfront rising to 15M over time, then that's about right given the circumstances. We probably should have pushed harder, given we know the window is closing and Saints are flush with cash, but provided we see a return closer to his true value, 15M would be easier to stomach.

Provided of course we get the calibre of replacements we need.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 09:00 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 08:55 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: My guess

We’ll get near as damn it £15mill once add-ons kick in over the term of TFs Saints contract. No issue there. 

Realistically 18-20 months left on deal.  Value drops as every month passes. 

Mason may want to play a 3-5-1-1 or 3-5-2 model as well, so sale not that detrimental to team and can fund players he wants. 

Maybe just maybe, TF has been upfront with club and gave no indication that he wants to extend deal.  Yes he may well have been happy to play at WBA for this season, but at some point the club needs to make money on him if that’s the case. 

No premier league clubs after him… £10-15m on table spread over 4-5 yrs…

You have to sell……

If it is 8-10M upfront rising to 15M over time, then that's about right given the circumstances. We probably should have pushed harder, given we know the window is closing and Saints are flush with cash, but provided we see a return closer to his true value, 15M would be easier to stomach.

Provided of course we get the calibre of replacements we need.

Every remotely reliable source says it is £8m rising to £10m with a hefty sell-on.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 08:07 AM)richbaggie Wrote: As I've mentioned before on this thread, there are a few folks ignoring some very important points which feed in to why we may be accepting a lower bid than we'd like.

There has been very little interest. (That in itself speaks volumes when i see the crazy valuations some of our fans seem to put on him) Saints know this and are taking advantage. People then argue that we shouldn't sell and keep him. However, how do we then pay for the players we are trying to bring in? As things stand now, because of the sales we've made and wages saved, we are fine on PSR but the squad is short and we need quality in.

I fully expect that the reported 8m plus add ons will  be 8m up front now. To us, thats more valuable than some structured deal over 4 or 5 years worth 12m or so. It will allow us to finalise the summer rebuild and balance the PSR books.

I'm disappointed it's so low but understand the logic when looking at the bigger picture rather than the deal in isolation.

Question for those saying it's a ridiculous thing to do. How would you pay for the players that the club are planning to bring in before Monday without the Fellows money?

I understand the logic you're trying to present here Rich, but we now have to replace Fellows' contribution for 8M, which will be bloody difficult, considering we've got so many other positions to fix with that money already. Say we need 3-4M to bring in the fullbacks, central midfielder and forward we need, and we now also need to replace close to 20 goal involvements from last season with what remains.

Still, I guess we can go to other clubs struggling with PSR and buy their players for well below market value......

For me the question is, would I rather we kept Fellows and added maybe one or 2 loans between now and the close of the window, or will the business we complete in the next 72 hours compensate for the loss of our most creative player last year for a knock down price.

Let's wait and see.

Fully agree with this. I really don't think the benefit of the signings we'll make from the pittance that we receive from the Fellows sale will make up for what we're losing from him. I'd be delighted to be wrong though.
Reply
Worth noting, on various 'scoring' platforms, Fellows has been our worst attacking player in the opening three games so far.

He's a very one dimensional player who needs to add more to his game, I don't think Southampton will suit him and he'll struggle there, I also don't think he'll do as well under Mason who wants us to play narrower and through the middle more it seems.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 08:07 AM)richbaggie Wrote: As I've mentioned before on this thread, there are a few folks ignoring some very important points which feed in to why we may be accepting a lower bid than we'd like.

There has been very little interest. (That in itself speaks volumes when i see the crazy valuations some of our fans seem to put on him) Saints know this and are taking advantage. People then argue that we shouldn't sell and keep him. However, how do we then pay for the players we are trying to bring in? As things stand now, because of the sales we've made and wages saved, we are fine on PSR but the squad is short and we need quality in.

I fully expect that the reported 8m plus add ons will  be 8m up front now. To us, thats more valuable than some structured deal over 4 or 5 years worth 12m or so. It will allow us to finalise the summer rebuild and balance the PSR books.

I'm disappointed it's so low but understand the logic when looking at the bigger picture rather than the deal in isolation.

Question for those saying it's a ridiculous thing to do. How would you pay for the players that the club are planning to bring in before Monday without the Fellows money?

I understand the logic you're trying to present here Rich, but we now have to replace Fellows' contribution for 8M, which will be bloody difficult, considering we've got so many other positions to fix with that money already. Say we need 3-4M to bring in the fullbacks, central midfielder and forward we need, and we now also need to replace close to 20 goal involvements from last season with what remains.

Still, I guess we can go to other clubs struggling with PSR and buy their players for well below market value......

For me the question is, would I rather we kept Fellows and added maybe one or 2 loans between now and the close of the window, or will the business we complete in the next 72 hours compensate for the loss of our most creative player last year for a knock down price.

Let's wait and see.

We've added one full back. Time will tell whether Mason thinks he's got enough left back cover. I expect we'll go for a forward before the deadline, because no-one can rely on Maja and Dike until they prove their fitness. But do we need a central midfielder? Mowatt, Molumby, Diakite, Price, Collyer and Bielik is a pretty good start. 

As for "replacing Fellows' contribution", if Mason doesn't think he fits into our style of play that becomes irrelevant. Tom hasn't really sparked this season. As with Furlong, maybe he's known all along that he's going.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 08:07 AM)richbaggie Wrote: As I've mentioned before on this thread, there are a few folks ignoring some very important points which feed in to why we may be accepting a lower bid than we'd like.

There has been very little interest. (That in itself speaks volumes when i see the crazy valuations some of our fans seem to put on him) Saints know this and are taking advantage. People then argue that we shouldn't sell and keep him. However, how do we then pay for the players we are trying to bring in? As things stand now, because of the sales we've made and wages saved, we are fine on PSR but the squad is short and we need quality in.

I fully expect that the reported 8m plus add ons will  be 8m up front now. To us, thats more valuable than some structured deal over 4 or 5 years worth 12m or so. It will allow us to finalise the summer rebuild and balance the PSR books.

I'm disappointed it's so low but understand the logic when looking at the bigger picture rather than the deal in isolation.

Question for those saying it's a ridiculous thing to do. How would you pay for the players that the club are planning to bring in before Monday without the Fellows money?

I understand the logic you're trying to present here Rich, but we now have to replace Fellows' contribution for 8M, which will be bloody difficult, considering we've got so many other positions to fix with that money already. Say we need 3-4M to bring in the fullbacks, central midfielder and forward we need, and we now also need to replace close to 20 goal involvements from last season with what remains.

Still, I guess we can go to other clubs struggling with PSR and buy their players for well below market value......

For me the question is, would I rather we kept Fellows and added maybe one or 2 loans between now and the close of the window, or will the business we complete in the next 72 hours compensate for the loss of our most creative player last year for a knock down price.

Let's wait and see.

I’m with rich, to be honest I think as of yet we have had an excellent window, let’s wait till 7pm on Monday before getting the knives out over Fellows.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 10:03 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Worth noting, on various 'scoring' platforms, Fellows has been our worst attacking player in the opening three games so far.

He's a very one dimensional player who needs to add more to his game, I don't think Southampton will suit him and he'll struggle there, I also don't think he'll do as well under Mason who wants us to play narrower and through the middle more it seems.
 
There lies the reason why we haven't much interest. He's  fantastic when goes outside and puts the crosses in but that is one dimensional. I think he became less effective last season when coaches nullified that and made him cut inside. We've seen that this season too. I think he would struggle in the prem with better defenders which is why there's not been a sniff.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: