Fellows
(08-29-2025, 07:22 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Still, as far as fire sales go… it could have been worse.

I've quite enjoyed it tbh - it's been long overdue, should have happened four summers ago.
Reply
If I remember correctly for PSR we lost a years profit for a year where we lost 30 mil. We have improved wage wise but we are still left with the loss over the rolling 3 year period. We have a couple more years to go before all the losses run through so we will still be selling players (unless we get promotion).
Reply
(08-29-2025, 07:15 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 09:27 PM)Atomic Wrote: Some people really are not properly understanding the PSR issues. We have to sell. If Southampton are the only club interested we can't start a bidding war and we are in no position to hold on for higher offers.

It's a lower fee than ideally we would've liked but this summers dealings are freeing us of that PSR mess left behind by the Lai regime.

Sometimes you have to take a step back in order to move forwards.

The Heggem sale largely dealt with PSR for this season, then Furlong topped it up more, we did not have to sell right now.

Can’t agree, with no interest from the premiership, after this transfer deadline his price will drop even more as his contract goes down. Come January only 18 months left on his contract. I don’t think Mason had the faith that Corberan had in Fellows and Mowbray didn’t have total  faith as he kept leaving him out. I think that a lot of managers will see if you double up on Fellows it really does nullify his threat. Hope I’m wrong and I would have stuck out for 15mill, but I see why he’s been sold for the price he has. I love Tom to bits and hopefully he proves me wrong did very well for us. To be honest he isn’t twice as good as Johnston who we nearly sold for 5 mill.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 07:42 AM)Jerry Wrote: If I remember correctly for PSR we lost a years profit for a year where we lost 30 mil. We have improved wage wise but we are still left with the loss over the rolling 3 year period. We have a couple more years to go before all the losses run through so we will still be selling players (unless we get promotion).

I had us down as close to the limit at the end of last season, hence the EFL taking an overview of things...

We've slashed the wage bill, no idea by how much, but i would think it's pretty substantial.

With Fellows, Heggem and Furlong we've bought in around £19m. (I'm using £7.5, £8 and £3.5)

We've spent around £13m... but spread over say 3 years (and I think some are on 4 year deals), that's £4m to come off this year, so £15m profit + wage savings... that should see us put a decent dent into the PSR for next year...

2022 - profit £5m
2023 - £11m loss
2024 - £34m loss
2025 - hopefully something like a £10m+ profit
next year starting at £34m loss over the previous 3 years, which is under the £41.5m allowed...
Reply
As I've mentioned before on this thread, there are a few folks ignoring some very important points which feed in to why we may be accepting a lower bid than we'd like.

There has been very little interest. (That in itself speaks volumes when i see the crazy valuations some of our fans seem to put on him) Saints know this and are taking advantage. People then argue that we shouldn't sell and keep him. However, how do we then pay for the players we are trying to bring in? As things stand now, because of the sales we've made and wages saved, we are fine on PSR but the squad is short and we need quality in.

I fully expect that the reported 8m plus add ons will be 8m up front now. To us, thats more valuable than some structured deal over 4 or 5 years worth 12m or so. It will allow us to finalise the summer rebuild and balance the PSR books.

I'm disappointed it's so low but understand the logic when looking at the bigger picture rather than the deal in isolation.

Question for those saying it's a ridiculous thing to do. How would you pay for the players that the club are planning to bring in before Monday without the Fellows money?
Reply
I wonder if Boro fans are having the same angst about the Azaz fee.

His goal involvement numbers are better than Fellows, and he has more experience.

So much of this transfer depends on what happens next. What we do with the money.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 07:12 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: My take is that we needed to sell this summer. Prem clubs seem to have reservations and this wasn’t helped by a fool underusing him from Christmas last year. No one has therefore come in until now and we need to take what we can.

The comparisons with the likes of Hutchinson, Doak etc were always unreasonable anyway. Doak plays for the Champions; Hutchinson has just had a wonderful Euros and a good Prem season. And neither of the selling clubs have PSR concerns.

This is a very valid point.

The last six months under Mowbray would have seriously impacted his value. Like a few of our players he wasn't quite the same after Corberan went and annoyingly the second half of last season would have been when the scouts were seriously paying attention.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:07 AM)richbaggie Wrote: As I've mentioned before on this thread, there are a few folks ignoring some very important points which feed in to why we may be accepting a lower bid than we'd like.

There has been very little interest. (That in itself speaks volumes when i see the crazy valuations some of our fans seem to put on him) Saints know this and are taking advantage. People then argue that we shouldn't sell and keep him. However, how do we then pay for the players we are trying to bring in? As things stand now, because of the sales we've made and wages saved, we are fine on PSR but the squad is short and we need quality in.

I fully expect that the reported 8m plus add ons will  be 8m up front now. To us, thats more valuable than some structured deal over 4 or 5 years worth 12m or so. It will allow us to finalise the summer rebuild and balance the PSR books.

I'm disappointed it's so low but understand the logic when looking at the bigger picture rather than the deal in isolation.

Question for those saying it's a ridiculous thing to do. How would you pay for the players that the club are planning to bring in before Monday without the Fellows money
Ah some sense…
Reply
A good few years ago (around Gera returning time), I knew people in the legal dept of WBA. The one thing that was clear was the figures quoted as fact were often way, way off. They usually come from one source and then get repeated so often, they become 'facts'. The balance sheet is always consolidated so you never know for sure.

Secondly, the owners talked to the league before they bought the club. I suspect there was some compromises made by the league otherwise Patel would have walked away and the league would have been left to explain how they contributed to the downfall of the club. The compromise offered was that the owners would stay in close consultation with the league. - they didn't 'step in' because of concerns. I may be wrong, but if I was going to buy a beleaguered, politically sensitive asset, I would negotiate when I was in a strong position - which is before I bought it, not after. And lets face it, that's more believable than the league being pro-active...

Thirdly, would Fellows be worth more at the end of next season? Would there be more clubs queuing up to buy him then than now? What's more important is what we do with the money. You either back the recruitment team to spend the wisely, or you don't. That's assuming they are given the money. We'll find out soon enough.

Personally, I think the owners are going to continue to hover around the edges of FFP. They'll do it deliberately because the impetus seems to be growing that the rules are going to have to change. At the very least, I reckon the championship will match up with the Premier league's FFP rules in the near future. So why leave cash unspent and uninvested if it becomes irrelevant in a few season's time? It's just not a profitable way to run the club.
Reply
(08-29-2025, 08:36 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: A good few years ago (around Gera returning time), I knew people in the legal dept of WBA. The one thing that was clear was the figures quoted as fact were often way, way off. They usually come from one source and then get repeated so often, they become 'facts'. The balance sheet is always consolidated so you never know for sure.

Secondly, the owners talked to the league before they bought it. I suspect there was some negotiations before they bought the club, some compromises were made by the league otherwise they would have walked away and the league would have been left to explain how they contributed to the downfall of the club. The compromise offered was that the owners would stay in close consultation with the league. - they didn't 'step in' because of concerns. I may be wrong, but if I was going to buy a beleaguered, politically sensitive asset, I would negotiate when I was in a strong position - which is before I bought it, not after. And lets face it, that's more believable than the league being pro-active...

Thirdly, would Fellows be worth more at the end of next season? Would there be more clubs queuing up to buy him than now? What's more important is what we do with the money. You either back the recruitment team to spend the wisely, or you don't. That's assuming they are given the money. We'll find out soon enough.

Good summary of where, I suppose, we are. I'm disappointed with the fee but as has been said it is how we use what we get that will count.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)