Fellows
It's not been a good day.
Reply
How much did we pay for Mikey Johnston?

If Fellows was so undervalued at £8-10million - then there wouldn't other clubs show an interest?
Isn't it telling that Everton chose not to pursue, and (as far as I'm aware) no other Premier League clubs have put an offer in.

Fellows has been brilliant for us, and is a fantastic talent - but ... he isn't that fast, and his finishing/goal scoring doesn't (yet) look Premier League quality. I'd hope for much more than £8-10 million, but as a club, we've got to be better at balancing the books. Selling Fellows does this, so long as we have some exciting incoming transfers, in a month's time this won't matter!
Reply
(08-28-2025, 10:22 PM)ghanaian_baggie Wrote: How much did we pay for Mikey Johnston?

If Fellows was so undervalued at £8-10million - then there wouldn't other clubs show an interest?
Isn't it telling that Everton chose not to pursue, and (as far as I'm aware) no other Premier League clubs have put an offer in.

Fellows has been brilliant for us, and is a fantastic talent - but ... he isn't that fast, and his finishing/goal scoring doesn't (yet) look Premier League quality. I'd hope for much more than £8-10 million, but as a club, we've got to be better at balancing the books. Selling Fellows does this, so long as we have some exciting incoming transfers, in a month's time this won't matter!

It's about the contract Fellows is now, and buying that contract,  then trying to equate if Fellows stayed for the the length of the contract being offered, how much is that?







Personally I'd love Tom to stay, because other clubs are shit, and one day I'd hope a true proper Baggie wear the Capitan armband, and they are few and far between.
Reply
(08-28-2025, 10:04 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: The fastest way to inflate his value is by Fellows signing a new contract on a higher percentage per week , e.g. Fellows signs 4 year's @ 80k p/w. There is absolutely no way our
Banking infrastructure would allow that. Which means unfortunately, Fellows wages and values (5yr) top out over 10/11 M
Its pretty fucking shit. But I don't work in finance nor football player purchases, but I understand maths given to me, and unfortunately Tom is about 10M and the best we can hope for is Eng appearances to be bonus and add on 15% sell on.

Cheers mate - cleared that up. Thank fuck it’s Saturday tomorrow and we can focus on the footie
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(08-28-2025, 07:23 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 05:16 PM)richbaggie Wrote: No bids from the prem this summer.

He's just not as good as some of our fans think, unfortunately. I think this sentence says a lot. 

He'll be a top Champ side/bottom half of the Prem side player for most of his career, I expect, which is still great.

Barnes was/is a far better player than Fellows and even he was massively overrated (as a nailed on future England regular) by most during his spell here.
Reply
(08-28-2025, 09:43 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 09:03 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 08:06 PM)Sliced Wrote: He’s 25 in a week. Hitting his peak.

It’s mind boggling that anyone is trying to argue that 10m for Fellows is good business.

It’s like the Pereira situation all over again. The join worst decision in recent Albion history alongside appointing Steve Bruce

I know football is all about emotion but this is getting ridiculous. 

If he’s so good and coming into his prime why aren’t the likes of Bournemouth, West Ham, Wolves, Brentford etc all coming in for him? There’s no bidding war here. 

As I said earlier a champ club is buying a champ player with minimal outside interest.  £10m is a fair fee. The lad has no prem experience couldn’t get off the bench in the U21 Euros. We love him and he’s great for us. But £10m plus a sell on is a fair price. 

This summer clears the PSR issues for good. If we recruit well, the club will be able to move forward on and off the pitch. That has to be a good thing.

It’s smacks of bad planning. No one could convince me that we can’t get more than 10 million for Fellows, and he’s our most creative outlet. We’ve already brought in a decent amount in fees this summer which is awesome. If the offer is ten million, keep fellows and enjoy the fact that he’s contributing on the pitch knowing that we have him on a 3 year contract.

I don’t think it does.

The complexities of the financial mess left by Lai together with the extremely questionable FFP rules has left us in a very difficult position regards strengthening.

This summer was always going to be tough and we need to get real with the state of the club after those Chinese clowns left us in the crap.

Ultimately as good as Fellows is we can only sell if clubs want to buy.

As has been said, the Prem recruitment teams with all their analytics and data don’t think he’s worth the risk.

Being a home grown player selling will really help us be compliant FFP wise. 

Remember look at us not that long ago and for reference look at Sheffield Wednesday now. There but for the grace of God and all that.
Reply
My take is that we needed to sell this summer. Prem clubs seem to have reservations and this wasn’t helped by a fool underusing him from Christmas last year. No one has therefore come in until now and we need to take what we can.

The comparisons with the likes of Hutchinson, Doak etc were always unreasonable anyway. Doak plays for the Champions; Hutchinson has just had a wonderful Euros and a good Prem season. And neither of the selling clubs have PSR concerns.
Reply
(08-28-2025, 09:27 PM)Atomic Wrote: Some people really are not properly understanding the PSR issues. We have to sell. If Southampton are the only club interested we can't start a bidding war and we are in no position to hold on for higher offers.

It's a lower fee than ideally we would've liked but this summers dealings are freeing us of that PSR mess left behind by the Lai regime.

Sometimes you have to take a step back in order to move forwards.

The Heggem sale largely dealt with PSR for this season, then Furlong topped it up more, we did not have to sell right now.
Reply
Still, as far as fire sales go… it could have been worse.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(08-29-2025, 07:22 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Still, as far as fire sales go… it could have been worse.

it aint over yet! Shilen needs a few extra bob to pay off that loan remember.... Big Grin

But, yeah, could have been a lot worse, assuming it stays how it is and we get some replacements in.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: