Flag shaggers
(08-28-2025, 01:56 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:48 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: I'm still waiting for an explanation on how immigration doesn't affect the housing crisis today rather than who or what caused it.

Immigration or asylum seekers that are housed in hotels BJ?

Yes, the celebrated reducing of hotels being used is as the vast majority are processed from them are being moved to houses. There aren't any special places reserved for them. They move into the few places that people are waiting years to get a chance of moving in to
Reply
(08-28-2025, 01:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:14 PM)Jacko Wrote: If we are going to leave the ECHR, as now looks inevitable, surely B1 you'd prefer this Labour government to oversee it, than an incoming Reform regime?

If we leave the ECHR then we are lost - the fact that this has been pushed to anywhere near the top of the agenda is criminal whoever oversees it. The narrative that it is inevitable is also one that is being pushed by those that want it. The 'well, it doesn't apply to me' approach is equally stupid if you only take a glance over the pond to see how the courts are being driven politically, the ECHR, an independent body above any one government is the safety net, not the obstacle.

So you believe the courts should have the whip hand over the democratic will of the people? And that anachronistic legislation and international treaties should not be changed? And that lawyers are any more independent than the rest of us?

OK. I can see why you voted for Starmer. You are everything he is.

If we leave the ECHR then we are lost. Melodramatic bobbins. If this government doesn't do something it will replaced by something far worse. And you are sleepwalking into it.
Reply
It's all about numbers in a lot of areas. More people in the country affects housing waiting times, doctors appointments availability, dentists appointments availability, hospital beds availability and school places among others. Until a solution is implemented the tide of population growth needs to be reversed.
Reply
(08-28-2025, 02:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:14 PM)Jacko Wrote: If we are going to leave the ECHR, as now looks inevitable, surely B1 you'd prefer this Labour government to oversee it, than an incoming Reform regime?

If we leave the ECHR then we are lost - the fact that this has been pushed to anywhere near the top of the agenda is criminal whoever oversees it. The narrative that it is inevitable is also one that is being pushed by those that want it. The 'well, it doesn't apply to me' approach is equally stupid if you only take a glance over the pond to see how the courts are being driven politically, the ECHR, an independent body above any one government is the safety net, not the obstacle.

So you believe the courts should have the whip hand over the democratic will of the people? And that anachronistic legislation and international treaties should not be changed? And that lawyers are any more independent than the rest of us?

OK. I can see why you voted for Starmer. You are everything he is.

If we leave the ECHR then we are lost. Melodramatic bobbins. If this government doesn't do something it will replaced by something far worse. And you are sleepwalking into it.

I love the 'melodramatic bobbins' comment straight after 'the courts should have the democratic will of the people'. And what have lawyers got to do with anything, the laws are set by the government of the day and preceded over by judges who interpret those laws based on the text and caselaw. Lawyers simply represent one side or another, they are not the decision makers.

The democratic will of the people decided on a yes / no vote for Brexit and had instant buyers regret. The democratic will of the people is based on them getting all of the information that is pertinent to any decision, if you want to leave the ECHR and decide to leave the new oversight to any of the governments of the last 50 years that have been found guilty of mistreatment of individuals by the police and armed forces, including torture and abuse of homosexuals, covert surveillance of individuals, amongst others. And then you actually realise that less than 600 cases have been heard by the ECHR since of which 150 of them found no issue, it does make you wonder how big an issue it actually is and why would we want to get rid of it.

(08-28-2025, 02:23 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: It's all about numbers in a lot of areas. More people in the country affects housing waiting times, doctors appointments availability, dentists appointments availability, hospital beds availability and school places among others. Until a solution is implemented the tide of population growth needs to be reversed.

We're talking about 30,000 people nationally BJ, the fact that all of those things aren't available is not down to asylum seekers, it is down to not being funded properly in the first place.
Reply
Absolutely nonsense and head in sand denial. That or a basic lack of understanding of mathematics. Certainly a lack of common sense

28k have come this year so far on small boats alone. Add on the forgotten illegal routes via trucks and legal migration that goes on and on and on.
Reply
Legal migration is needed and shouldn't be an issue to anyone, without asylum status an 'illegal' cannot register with doctors, dentists, or local authorities for housing and would be identified should they be admitted to hospital.
Reply
Even if we could build the 1.5 million houses in the next 5 years in the pie in the sky promises of this government it wouldn't be enough to swallow up the current waiting backlog

It surely is trying to educate pork. Look that up
Reply
(08-28-2025, 02:40 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 02:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:14 PM)Jacko Wrote: If we are going to leave the ECHR, as now looks inevitable, surely B1 you'd prefer this Labour government to oversee it, than an incoming Reform regime?

If we leave the ECHR then we are lost - the fact that this has been pushed to anywhere near the top of the agenda is criminal whoever oversees it. The narrative that it is inevitable is also one that is being pushed by those that want it. The 'well, it doesn't apply to me' approach is equally stupid if you only take a glance over the pond to see how the courts are being driven politically, the ECHR, an independent body above any one government is the safety net, not the obstacle.

So you believe the courts should have the whip hand over the democratic will of the people? And that anachronistic legislation and international treaties should not be changed? And that lawyers are any more independent than the rest of us?

OK. I can see why you voted for Starmer. You are everything he is.

If we leave the ECHR then we are lost. Melodramatic bobbins. If this government doesn't do something it will replaced by something far worse. And you are sleepwalking into it.

I love the 'melodramatic bobbins' comment straight after 'the courts should have the democratic will of the people'. And what have lawyers got to do with anything, the laws are set by the government of the day and preceded over by judges who interpret those laws based on the text and caselaw. Lawyers simply represent one side or another, they are not the decision makers.

The democratic will of the people decided on a yes / no vote for Brexit and had instant buyers regret. The democratic will of the people is based on them getting all of the information that is pertinent to any decision, if you want to leave the ECHR and decide to leave the new oversight to any of the governments of the last 50 years that have been found guilty of mistreatment of individuals by the police and armed forces, including torture and abuse of homosexuals, covert surveillance of individuals, amongst others. And then you actually realise that less than 600 cases have been heard by the ECHR since of which 150 of them found no issue, it does make you wonder how big an issue it actually is and why would we want to get rid of it.

(08-28-2025, 02:23 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: It's all about numbers in a lot of areas. More people in the country affects housing waiting times, doctors appointments availability, dentists appointments availability, hospital beds availability and school places among others. Until a solution is implemented the tide of population growth needs to be reversed.

We're talking about 30,000 people nationally BJ, the fact that all of those things aren't available is not down to asylum seekers, it is down to not being funded properly in the first place.

The ECHR in question is the convention, removing the court's jurisdiction is merely a result of withdrawing from the convention.
Reply
450 cases upheld against the UK in 50 years Jacko (averaging 9 a year) - it doesn't appear to be the problem that it is being made out to be
Reply
See reply in the new thread mate.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)