Fellows
If we receive £8m up front that all goes into the books for this year. We then pay £1m for a loanee from a big club - you're £7m+ for the year.

Following that if he hits the performance goals - we'll book another whatever whenever that happens.

If we had a sell on fee that's some more profit down the line too.

Price is in the books as whatever we paid (6m?) divided over the length of his contract (4 years?) so 1.5m cost per season. However if we sold him at the moment we'd only book profit from whatever is left in the book - so say anything other £5.25m as he's been here half a season.

If we are getting £8m for Fellows upfront - we'd have to get £13.25m up front for Price to make it worth while.

Selling Fellows now to keep Price and improve his value will probably be better overall for us and allow us to bring in more young players etc...
Reply
Thought it was April Fools when I heard 10m initial fee now it’s seems it lower at 8m!

Really don’t understand this one unless it a fire sale and we aren’t being told now all season tickets have been sold?
Who’s next and will we pay out done real cash for a quality replacement when we still need a right and, arguably, a first team left back.
Shopping up to be a great window just deflated.
Also leaves us highly vulnerable at Stoke as doubt we’d get anyone in before then.
Reply
(08-28-2025, 02:58 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 02:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 02:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A lot of people are overstating the value teams are giving to assists from wide areas in modern football. If he had last seasons record from RB - similar to Davis at Ipswich (but from LB) in their promotion season then maybe you'd be asking for £15-20m. Tom would also be worth more if he had 8 goals and 8 assists from last season. Lots of the players he's being compared with e.g. Philogene, Hutchinson both made double-figures for goals scored in their last Championship season. It's more valuable.

It's a touch low, but my God can't we wait until we see what his replacement looks like first?!

This is a very good post TBF, Ted. 

I also wonder if we have targets, they are going to cost us 'x' amount, we need to raise 'x' amount and this sale allows us to conclude our business.

It is a good post, but the players are handpicked, what about Kasey McAteer, Romain Esse? Don't get me started on Lewis Dobbin (yes I know the circumstances of that).

If you look at both of those players stats and skills;

Kasey McAteer - Goals, shots and defensive output in attacking areas. 

Romaine Esse - Ball carrying, take ons, shot creating actions from take ons and shots rather than crosses. 

All of those things are valued higher than assists from crosses. Because largely if you set up to consistently get somebody crossing, even if you score 1 goal every 2 games. Across the season you create fewer high quality chances. 

As I say though, still feel 5 million light.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(08-28-2025, 02:58 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 02:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 02:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A lot of people are overstating the value teams are giving to assists from wide areas in modern football. If he had last seasons record from RB - similar to Davis at Ipswich (but from LB) in their promotion season then maybe you'd be asking for £15-20m. Tom would also be worth more if he had 8 goals and 8 assists from last season. Lots of the players he's being compared with e.g. Philogene, Hutchinson both made double-figures for goals scored in their last Championship season. It's more valuable.

It's a touch low, but my God can't we wait until we see what his replacement looks like first?!

This is a very good post TBF, Ted. 

I also wonder if we have targets, they are going to cost us 'x' amount, we need to raise 'x' amount and this sale allows us to conclude our business.

It is a good post, but the players are handpicked, what about Kasey McAteer, Romain Esse? Don't get me started on Lewis Dobbin (yes I know the circumstances of that).

Esse is younger but has a similar goals return to Tom. He also went to the PL, they always pay more, and the reported fee was £12.5m rising to £15m - which I don't think would have been unreasonable for Tom.

McAteer has a better goal scoring record than Tom and has played a bit in the PL. Again he went for a reported £12m. 

I'll ignore Dobbin and I've tried to erase him entirely from my memory. 

I've only picked those players as they're being used by people both on here and on Twitter to point out we should have got more money for Tom, when in reality all they do is show that we perhaps got slightly under.
Reply
No one knows the financial wheeling and dealing, payment structures, accounting ramifications etc etc- sell on blah, blah, blah.

Patel took over a club in a mess and isn’t going to open the cheque book. He’s making calculations to stabilise us and then move us up.

I’m relaxed on all this. Let’s see how it all pans out by the end of the window.
Reply
Transfer values are more complicated than 'x went to them so y is worth £z'

Fellows is very good for us, but very limited as a player, lots of assists, but all very similar in style, and his out wide, step over and cross isn't going to work at every club, on fact, he's not looked good this season as we now play narrower so we can use Price more.

He couldn't get off the bench at the youth world cup, and younger wingers than him are far ahead of him, so it's safe to say, top champ, lower Prem is his absolute peak as a player. No one wants him who can pay more, Mason clearly wants more players on, we therefore need to sell assets, his value is what teams will pay. Everton had interest but after a lot of scouting and analysing decided against it, since I'd say that as best for for him, it shows we value him higher than others.

If we can get better full back options, another attacking option, maybe two, that improve us as a team the window as a whole is a success.
Reply
On the emotional side of course we are all sad for us to lose Tom and as the weeks go by we’ll move on.

What is being missed here on fees, is that we have a player who has only ever played in the champ, signing for another champ club. We can say what we think about whether £10m is enough, but on reflection unless you’ve multiple prem parties involved then that’s the going rate.

We might have great hopes, which is why he’ll have a sell on clause, but this champ player is being sold to a champ club with little or no prem interest. That in reality makes £10m a decent fee if you look at it cold.
Reply
Exactly, Champ to Champ sales aren't going to be as high as a prem club sale.
Reply
Southampton are losing Dibling and Fernandes and believe me they are losing two top players and are getting weaker not stronger even if they sign Fellow’s and Finn Azzaz.Southampton fans are in meltdown but we might not like it but both Ipswich and Southampton are the two biggest pulls in the Championship,if only for the reason that they have just come down with the biggest budgets with parachute payments.
Reply
With the massive profit on Heggem along with the Taylor and Fellows fees we must be looking at upwards of £20m worth of PSR benefits depending on the final fees.

Might sting now but that’ll drag us out of the financial shit a lot sooner.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)