Fellows
(08-28-2025, 01:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: We all get a bit bogged down with the money, but it's not really about that, it's about the squad. If we sell Tom for £10m and replace for £2m and the replacement is as good or better, good deal. If we sell him for £20m and replace for £10m, but the replacement is shite, bad deal, even though we made more money.

Tom is an incredibly valuable asset ON the pitch, so, whatever the price, we are weaker without him. That should be all that matters to a fan watching the team, surely.

But it's not just about bringing in one player as a replacement for the one outgoing though. A £20m fee for Fellows could bring in maybe 3 or 4 really good quality players across the squad in the same way that we used the £5m we got in for Hughes in 2001 to strengthen the squad as a whole. Players with such a high market value don't come around often for a club in Albion's position, particularly not through the youth system. When you do get them you need to make to maximise what you're bringing in.
Reply
Seriously, can we just wait for the sale to be confirmed and see what value the club announce, if any, before pant wetting. It's laughable reading some of the negativity flying around ATM, all over a fee that may not be accurate!
Reply
Is he worth 20 million? Yes the market is wild but he doesn't score goals - 4 goals in 96 games for us. He 100% has the potential to add that to his game but 20 million would be a lot for someone who has never played at the top level and doesn't score.
Reply
I still think there was something behind Fellows sale, I’m also begging in to believe that there was a 10 million release clause added to his contract extension. How else could he go for such a low fee in our eyes anyway.
We have done good deals for Heggem , Furlong and probably Taylor, so something has happened to sell him.
Reply
Very few people will know the actual fee agreed, let alone the intricacies of Fellows' contract, FFS. Guesswork and pant wetting AOTS.

Calm down, guys. Have a cup of tea, read some ceefax pages, go for an angry wank, just chill out a bit, eh! Big Grin
Reply
(08-28-2025, 01:59 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: We all get a bit bogged down with the money, but it's not really about that, it's about the squad. If we sell Tom for £10m and replace for £2m and the replacement is as good or better, good deal. If we sell him for £20m and replace for £10m, but the replacement is shite, bad deal, even though we made more money.

Tom is an incredibly valuable asset ON the pitch, so, whatever the price, we are weaker without him. That should be all that matters to a fan watching the team, surely.

But it's not just about bringing in one player as a replacement for the one outgoing though. A £20m fee for Fellows could bring in maybe 3 or 4 really good quality players across the squad in the same way that we used the £5m we got in for Hughes in 2001 to strengthen the squad as a whole. Players with such a high market value don't come around often for a club in Albion's position, particularly not through the youth system. When you do get them you need to make to maximise what you're bringing in.
You still need to play someone in the role Fellows occupied, so without him we are weaker in that area. Could have the best back 4 in the league but we will still be weaker on the right wing. Point still stands either way. Wherever the money goes, if it's well spent it will be a good deal, if it isn't, it won't.

I can remember similar conversations when Robson and Moses left, for record breaking money, and how it was for the greater good. Turned out it wasn't.

(Not comparing Fellows to Robson, before someone grinds their teeth to dust!)  Big Grin
Reply
I'd argue if we used £10 mill (if that is actually the figure) to buy a striker who will get circa 15 goals, and a RM who isn't as talented, but is consistently a solid 6.5 every week, and is a good team player (a Championship Milner, type of player, if that makes sense?) then that puts us in a stronger position than we are with Fellows.
Reply
(08-28-2025, 01:49 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: If it is a £10M its a joke and a criminal loss of value, what I really don't understand is that we have a young player with years left on his contract, happy here, whose value trajectory is steeply going  up with assists and involvement in the England U21s.  Whatever he is worth now will be double this time next year and we don't have to sell him (unless an accountant says something different)  The value and the timing of this is seriously fucked up, don't get it at all.

Absolutely this.

IF we ever get to know the deal, £10m (however it is put together) is us getting our pants pulled down.
Reply
BBC reporting could rise to £10m, so it's more likely the £8m mentioned before, they also reckon we only got £9m for Heggem (not £10m that everyone keeps saying, although some are reporting we only got £7.5m for Heggem+ add ons)

Seems very undervalued to me, 22 and an England u21 International... joint top assists in the Champ, less than £15m seems very bad...

So with 7.5 for Heggem, 8 for Tom, 3.5 for Furlong that's £19m in, and about £11m out (but they can be spread over the contract lengths, and not including Mepham), so call that £3m out, that's £16m profit, but leaving us with a team that looks strongish) in defence and weak everywhere else. No creativity and limited attacking threat... hmmm I knew the recent positivity was too good to be true...

Unless of course we've got some decent creatives lined up...
Reply
(08-28-2025, 02:11 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:59 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 01:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: We all get a bit bogged down with the money, but it's not really about that, it's about the squad. If we sell Tom for £10m and replace for £2m and the replacement is as good or better, good deal. If we sell him for £20m and replace for £10m, but the replacement is shite, bad deal, even though we made more money.

Tom is an incredibly valuable asset ON the pitch, so, whatever the price, we are weaker without him. That should be all that matters to a fan watching the team, surely.

But it's not just about bringing in one player as a replacement for the one outgoing though. A £20m fee for Fellows could bring in maybe 3 or 4 really good quality players across the squad in the same way that we used the £5m we got in for Hughes in 2001 to strengthen the squad as a whole. Players with such a high market value don't come around often for a club in Albion's position, particularly not through the youth system. When you do get them you need to make to maximise what you're bringing in.
You still need to play someone in the role Fellows occupied, so without him we are weaker in that area. Could have the best back 4 in the league but we will still be weaker on the right wing. Point still stands either way. Wherever the money goes, if it's well spent it will be a good deal, if it isn't, it won't.

I can remember similar conversations when Robson and Moses left, for record breaking money, and how it was for the greater good. Turned out it wasn't.

(Not comparing Fellows to Robson, before someone grinds their teeth to dust!)  Big Grin

What's wrong about that analogy is not the comparison of the individual players, it's the implication that the management of the club at the time was in some way similar to how it is now. Anyone old enough to have been there knows how shabbily the club was run right up until Paul Thompson got involved at the end of the 90s. Things are different now.

Although it can't beat the "FF" thread for comedy value, I must say I'm enjoying the way many long-term "naysayers" have latched onto the Fellows transfer so they can vent on this old bored. Big sigh of relief, "Normal service has been resumed!". Enjoy your moments of misery, boys. I'm hoping you'll be grandly disappointed when you have nothing much to complain about as the season unfolds.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: