' Transfer Speculation Thread '
Millwall apparently. I'll believe it when I see it.
Reply
We turned down a bid of £2m for Taylor from Blackburn 18 months ago. I’m sure we also turned down a higher bid from someone else in January.
Reply
Taylor is a funny one - plenty of managers here haven’t been convinced by him, but the club have stood by a firm valuation and handed him a long term deal. 

In the limited games I’ve seen him play, he’s been aerially dominant as you’d expect, but his passing poor and his movement very ponderous and laboured. It would be a big risk to put him into our side as a starting CB, but one which I think would pay off longer term. It seems however, that various managers have preferred a different approach, so if he’s not going to get serious game time this year it’s best we let him go, he turns 23 in Jan, we can’t loan him out to L1 again.
Reply
(08-27-2025, 06:18 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Taylor is a funny one - plenty of managers here haven’t been convinced by him, but the club have stood by a firm valuation and handed him a long term deal. 

In the limited games I’ve seen him play, he’s been aerially dominant as you’d expect, but his passing poor and his movement very ponderous and laboured. It would be a big risk to put him into our side as a starting CB, but one which I think would pay off longer term. It seems however, that various managers have preferred a different approach, so if he’s not going to get serious game time this year it’s best we let him go, he turns 23 in Jan, we can’t loan him out to L1 again.

He'd be decent in a Pulis type team that packs the defence, where he would have a more limited sphere of influence and his lack of pace would be less exposed. Milwall could be a good fit. Remember when agent Lescott was our PotS, in an 8 man defence, then looked like a babby giraffe in Villa's back 3? Oh how we loffed.  Big Grin
Reply
I'm not convinced by Taylor either and the Millwall links have been there a while. Makes sense from a PSR perspective as well.

Given he's 23 in January, he's no kid anymore. We can't sit around with him playing a bit here and there for the next 2-3 seasons to see whether he's good enough. We might as well move him on and give him a chance to play regularly somewhere. Maybe a deal with a buy-back clause or a hefty sell-on should he improve massively.
Reply
(08-27-2025, 07:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm not convinced by Taylor either and the Millwall links have been there a while. Makes sense from a PSR perspective as well.

Given he's 23 in January, he's no kid anymore. We can't sit around with him playing a bit here and there for the next 2-3 seasons to see whether he's good enough. We might as well move him on and give him a chance to play regularly somewhere. Maybe a deal with a buy-back clause or a hefty sell-on should he improve massively.

Yeah I’m of the view that Taylor probably isn’t going to improve much beyond his current level. If the price is right then sell.
Reply
(08-27-2025, 08:35 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-27-2025, 07:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm not convinced by Taylor either and the Millwall links have been there a while. Makes sense from a PSR perspective as well.

Given he's 23 in January, he's no kid anymore. We can't sit around with him playing a bit here and there for the next 2-3 seasons to see whether he's good enough. We might as well move him on and give him a chance to play regularly somewhere. Maybe a deal with a buy-back clause or a hefty sell-on should he improve massively.

Yeah I’m of the view that Taylor probably isn’t going to improve much beyond his current level. If the price is right then sell.
Always felt he was more a traditional centre half utilising his height but ponderous on the ground.

£2m would be a fair reflection of where he's at right now.
Reply
A couple million would be great business for Taylor. Is years off being ready.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Not a lot of love for Caleb Taylor on this board.

First choice player for a top 6 side in League 1, whilst in his very early 20s (still a young age for that position) suggests there is talent that should only improve with experience.

If we can get a fee for him and use the funds to improve the squad then fine, but writing him off as never going to be good enough seems extremely previous.
Reply
(08-27-2025, 09:04 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Not a lot of love for Caleb Taylor on this board.

First choice player for a top 6 side in League 1, whilst in his very early 20s (still a young age for that position) suggests there is talent that should only improve with experience.

If we can get a fee for him and use the funds to improve the squad then fine, but writing him off as never going to be good enough seems extremely previous.

I don't think anyone has said that? He might be good enough in the future, Sam Field would add to our squad now, should we have waited for four years to find out? Chances are he wouldn't be the player he is now, if he'd of spent all that time sat on our bench. Was let go at a similar point to where Taylor is now. 

If he was going to break into and hold down a spot in our team, he needed to have done it by now, he isn't a kid any more. Countless managers haven't fancied him, even Val who was so wedded to playing a back three - which would be ideal for blooding a young CB - didn't give him a sniff.

We're looking at replacing him with Beckmann, who is younger and has more experience in a better league already. The deals make perfect sense if we can make it happen.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)