Elliot Bell Referee
#11
Easy to pile on after the fact but until the non-pen he was fine.

After that, he realised he'd got the big decision wrong and he absolutely shat the bed. Some nonsense for both sides topped off by not sending off their lad for the reach around on Heggebø and sending Mason off for his appraisal.

Win some, lose some I guess.
Reply
#12
First one smelt like a penalty but from the Brumie end could not see. The next I think that the ref tried to play advantage but we weren’t quite in the position to score so the chance went. I would have liked him to have pulled the game back and if that meant their player was sent off so be it but he bottled that.
Reply
#13
(08-23-2025, 05:19 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Easy to pile on after the fact but until the non-pen he was fine.

After that, he realised he'd got the big decision wrong and he absolutely shat the bed. Some nonsense for both sides topped off by not sending off their lad for the reach around on Heggebø and sending Mason off for his appraisal.

Win some, lose some I guess.

He booked Campbell for fuck all, Heggebø was already getting dragged by both their defenders and both centre halves should have been on yellows long before the penalty incident.

He may have seemed fine because there was no big decisions to be made up until then but he wasn't good. And then he completely shat the bed with a stonewall penalty, one of the most blatant red cards I've ever seen and booking our players and our manager for dissent.

He's clearly not ready to referee at this level of football.
Reply
#14
(08-23-2025, 05:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-23-2025, 05:19 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Easy to pile on after the fact but until the non-pen he was fine.

After that, he realised he'd got the big decision wrong and he absolutely shat the bed. Some nonsense for both sides topped off by not sending off their lad for the reach around on Heggebø and sending Mason off for his appraisal.

Win some, lose some I guess.

He booked Campbell for fuck all, Heggebø was already getting dragged by both their defenders and both centre halves should have been on yellows long before the penalty incident.

He may have seemed fine because there was no big decisions to be made up until then but he wasn't good. And then he completely shat the bed with a stonewall penalty, one of the most blatant red cards I've ever seen and booking our players and our manager for dissent.

He's clearly not ready to referee at this level of football.

Let me rephrase then, until the pen he was consistently bad for both sides I thought.
Reply
#15
Im not so sure he was fine befor that Penalty incident.Heggebo was being fouled many times before that and he did bugger all about it.
Reply
#16
I can accept him playing on when Heggebo is held back but not to go back after the play to send off the defender was unbelievable. As for the penalty, you only have to look at the face of the fullback when he realises that he’s got away with it.
Reply
#17
3 awful decisions by the ref.
1. The clear foul on Heggebo before their equaliser
2. The blatant pen not given
3. The lack of sending off
Reply
#18
I've just watched the highlights. There is one very good close up angle of the penalty claim and I've watched it 10 times and it's bloody close. The player slides but there is a secondary stretch out and he's millimetres from the ball. I still can't tell wether he got the slightest touch. Given the shit angle the ref saw it from you can see why he didn't give it. Not great reffing but absolutely shit luck.

I'm more angry about the pull back on Heggebø. That's just rank bad reffing and the linesman should also have flagged as he was right in line with it.

We've been unlucky today but at 1-0 you always run that risk. Should have done what Cov did and put the game to bed earlier.

Still an unbeaten start. We move on....
Reply
#19
(08-23-2025, 05:51 PM)Peachy Wrote: I've just watched the highlights. There is one very good close up angle of the penalty claim and I've watched it 10 times and it's bloody close. The player slides but there is a secondary stretch out and he's millimetres from the ball. I still can't tell wether he got the slightest touch. Given the shit angle the ref saw it from you can see why he didn't give it. Not great reffing but absolutely shit luck.

I'm more angry about the pull back on Heggebø. That's just rank bad reffing and the linesman should also have flagged as he was right in line with it.

We've been unlucky today but at 1-0 you always run that risk. Should have done what Cov did and put the game to bed earlier.

Still an unbeaten start. We move on....

Touching the ball does not make it not a foul, he's had to go through Heggebø to get to the ball and he's impeded Heggebø from retaining possession of the ball by doing so. You can get clean contact on the ball every time after that (which he didn't get) and it's still a foul. 

That's been the rule now for 30 years.

(08-23-2025, 05:28 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-23-2025, 05:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-23-2025, 05:19 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Easy to pile on after the fact but until the non-pen he was fine.

After that, he realised he'd got the big decision wrong and he absolutely shat the bed. Some nonsense for both sides topped off by not sending off their lad for the reach around on Heggebø and sending Mason off for his appraisal.

Win some, lose some I guess.

He booked Campbell for fuck all, Heggebø was already getting dragged by both their defenders and both centre halves should have been on yellows long before the penalty incident.

He may have seemed fine because there was no big decisions to be made up until then but he wasn't good. And then he completely shat the bed with a stonewall penalty, one of the most blatant red cards I've ever seen and booking our players and our manager for dissent.

He's clearly not ready to referee at this level of football.

Let me rephrase then, until the pen he was consistently bad for both sides I thought.

Can't agree, the only decisions he's had to make up to the penalty were to book their centre halves for pulling back Heggebø - which he didn't do - and he's booked Campbell for nothing. That clearly favoured Portsmouth.
Reply
#20
Just seen a replay of the pen incident. Even more blatant than I thought sat in East Stand
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)