Fellows & Price - financial value..
#31
Given where we are i would prefer to keep both Fellows and Price for this season.

If we sold now we probably couldn't use the money wisely given the time left in the window....transfer prices are only going to increase {for good players} in what remains of the window.

Puts us in a stronger position regarding offers for these two, they would have to be very good.

What is a fair value for either player.

Fellows probably 15-20m.

Price who knows, not enough evidence . Put it this way i think he could become a player who could command a plus 30m transfer fee, but at this moment, if i was a buying club i wouldn't want to pay that . And most clubs who could afford that kind of fee probably don't need to take that kind of gamble.
Reply
#32
(08-18-2025, 08:35 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(08-18-2025, 04:35 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(08-18-2025, 04:32 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Hopefully Heggem’s sale is enough from the ffp pov for now to enable us to resist anything but ridiculous bids for either, but you have to be looking at £25m+ for Fellows and £40m+ for Price based on the eye watering sums being bandied about for other similar or lesser Championship players at the moment.

Correct. Anything below that is ludicrous talk.

It baffles me that people think that we should just practically give some of our players away. Transfer fees have really stepped up another level this season. You're looking at a £20-25m for a young Championship player who has had one good season. This is then £40-50m if they've a decent Premier League season.

Anyone suggesting £10-12m for Fellows shows that they're just completely out of touch with modern football.

Totally in-touch 

Realistic view. As much as we think he’s worth x y z it’s not the reality 

15m ish with sell on is a very good price for fellows 

25m ish now with a sell on is a very good price for Isaac. 

My point is…fellows’ value I can’t see increasing that much. £15m + £5m (add ons) with sell on….maybe, but that’s the ceiling or just above it imo. 

Price…..could be looking at £30m next summer

(08-19-2025, 05:36 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-18-2025, 08:58 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(08-18-2025, 08:35 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(08-18-2025, 04:35 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(08-18-2025, 04:32 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Hopefully Heggem’s sale is enough from the ffp pov for now to enable us to resist anything but ridiculous bids for either, but you have to be looking at £25m+ for Fellows and £40m+ for Price based on the eye watering sums being bandied about for other similar or lesser Championship players at the moment.

Correct. Anything below that is ludicrous talk.

It baffles me that people think that we should just practically give some of our players away. Transfer fees have really stepped up another level this season. You're looking at a £20-25m for a young Championship player who has had one good season. This is then £40-50m if they've a decent Premier League season.

Anyone suggesting £10-12m for Fellows shows that they're just completely out of touch with modern football.

Yep.

+2

Anything under £20M for Fellows would be a terrible sale. Philogene went for £18M to Villa, Watson has joined Brighton for £12M, and hell Wrexham have just paid £10M for 27yo Broadbent with 12 months on his deal and one decent Champ season under his belt. 

I’m glad some of you lot aren’t working in our recruitment department!

Anyone who knows football, player comparisons for selling players hold very little influence.

Position of selling club - both league and financial status.
Term of current contract.
Age
Medical
Caps
Stats

(08-19-2025, 06:32 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-19-2025, 06:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-19-2025, 05:57 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Do the club have a spreadsheet with the value that we value our players at, do we think?

If not, I can get one going.

Ultimately, a players value is only what the buying club is willing to pay.

And the selling club is willing to accept.

If the selling club hold out for £100mill, but no one is willing to pay that, then that doesn't mean the player's value is £100mill, does it? They're only worth what someone is actually willing to buy. 

If I put a value on my house of £1mill, no one would buy it. It's not worth that. If someone did buy it for £1mill then it would be worth the £1mill.
Correct - sensible post

(08-19-2025, 07:59 AM)moley63 Wrote: upgrade both contracts ...place a minimum 30m on price and 20 on fellows ...keep em happy with good wages

I guess the club may well have been discussing that. Needs player to agree though obviously.
Reply
#33
The key is not to go early. Look at Adam Wharton. Sold for £18 million. His next move will be at least treble that. I'd get both on improved terms ASAP with overly high release clauses, perhaps TF £30m/IP £50m.

RWs estimates are on the low side and I feel Albion would resist at those numbers with the Heggem profit tucked in the back pocket.
Reply
#34
(08-19-2025, 09:19 AM)Jacko Wrote: The key is not to go early. Look at Adam Wharton. Sold for £18 million. His next move will be at least treble that. I'd get both on improved terms ASAP with overly high release clauses, perhaps TF £30m/IP £50m.

RWs estimates are on the low side and I feel Albion would resist at those numbers with the Heggem profit tucked in the back pocket.

If a bournemouth or similar came in with £30m…. He’d go. Player would want to go as well!  And i wouldn’t blame him. 

It’s the football food chain.
Simple as that.

All irrelevant until offers land in agents inboxes anyway.
Reply
#35
Playing Devil's Advocate. If you're an Everton, Spurs, Villa, or other mid-tabled club that wants to try and break into the top 6, would you want to spend £20mill plus on Fellows, with no PL experience, and an unknown at that level? Especially when you will be likely limited by PSR? Would you not rather spend that kind of money on a proven talent at that level? With PSR clubs are less likely to take risks on players like Fellows, aren't they?

Price, on the other hand, is performing at international level, too. So he's a little different.

The above wasn't a criticism on Fellows qualities, btw. We all know what he can do, and how good he can be.
Reply
#36
In fairness RW you said we should “sell sell sell” Heggem for 6m and we got 10m so it’s probably worth considering your valuations may not be what Albion end up with
Raw Sausage
Reply
#37
I agree with Ronnie here, couple of data points:

1. James McAtee who has more prem experience, more England U21 experience and is seen as an exceptional talent has just left for c£27m from City.
2. Elliot Anderson, who was a Newc regular and only sold because of PSR, U21 regular went for £35m

At this stage, as a championship club, you can’t possibly believe Tom or Isaac are in that bracket. Hutchinson has just lived for what, £35m from Ipswich and he has a full prem season behind him.

I get they’re both gems but the market really does suggest they’re not in the bracket yet to be £20m+ players.
Reply
#38
Ok, so if these are the terms we're looking at for Fellows:

Position of selling club - both league and financial status - we're looking much better financially now and the Heggem sale will have made a big difference. When Tom goes it will be to a top flight club and they're all chucking huge amounts on players.
Term of current contract - 2 years left on his deal
Age - Early 20s, huge potential
Medical - Not had any fitness issues
Caps - England U-21 international
Stats - best assister in the Championship despite playing in a team that struggled for goals at times last season

Yeah, let's just give him away. Jesus wept....
Reply
#39
I do think this thing about caps is a misnomer. Mentioned for Price and Doak in the last couple of days.

If Fellows was a national of any other the other home countries he'd be capped. I dont think playing games for NI and Scotland adds any value tbh.
Reply
#40
(08-19-2025, 09:24 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: In fairness RW you said we should “sell sell sell” Heggem for 6m and we got 10m so it’s probably worth considering your valuations may not be what Albion end up with

We sold for £8m 

Great price

(08-19-2025, 09:26 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I agree with Ronnie here, couple of data points:

1. James McAtee who has more prem experience, more England U21 experience and is seen as an exceptional talent has just left for c£27m from City.
2. Elliot Anderson, who was a Newc regular and only sold because of PSR, U21 regular went for £35m

At this stage, as a championship club, you can’t possibly believe Tom or Isaac are in that bracket. Hutchinson has just lived for what, £35m from Ipswich and he has a full prem season behind him.

I get they’re both gems but the market really does suggest they’re not in the bracket yet to be £20m+ players.

Correct

(08-19-2025, 09:27 AM)Jacko Wrote: I do think this thing about caps is a misnomer. Mentioned for Price and Doak in the last couple of days.

If Fellows was a national of any other the other home countries he'd be capped. I dont think playing games for NI and Scotland adds any value tbh.

Scoring wonder goals does

(08-19-2025, 09:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Ok, so if these are the terms we're looking at for Fellows:

Position of selling club - both league and financial status - we're looking much better financially now and the Heggem sale will have made a big difference. When Tom goes it will be to a top flight club and they're all chucking huge amounts on players.
Term of current contract - 2 years left on his deal
Age - Early 20s, huge potential
Medical - Not had any fitness issues
Caps - England U-21 international
Stats - best assister in the Championship despite playing in a team that struggled for goals at times last season

Yeah, let's just give him away. Jesus wept....

£15m would not be giving him away
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: