Beilik
#61
(08-14-2025, 08:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-14-2025, 08:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Bielik and Phillips should as good as Bartley, loads better than Holgate.

Campbell's brief appearances look promising too, semi's pace was always an asset, so we will see how we can get up the pitch with out it.

Know my thoughts on centre backs and pace. I'd rather they read the game well and never had to run. Semis pace may have been an asset, his diabolical defending was a hindrance too often.

Absolutely agree by and large. 

But it's the mindset and belief that it brings to players knowing you've got a gazelle in the back line capable of recovering if a ball is played in behind that gives them the confidence to press and get up the pitch. 

Even with CCs obsession with shape and structure, when we played a higher block, we sometimes needed that pace to dig us out.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#62
Very pleased with this. Overall we have upgraded the centre back department.
Reply
#63
(08-15-2025, 07:03 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Very pleased with this. Overall we have upgraded the centre back department.
Do you think so? Obviously I hope you're right.. but losing Heggem and Bartley plus Ajayi, gaining Beilik, Campbell, Phillips.
Jury's out.
Reply
#64
I’d say Phillips is better than any CB here last season, it’s whether the others are an upgrade on the others. Wait and see.

I think Campbell will be prone to a clanger, Ajayiesque. Hopefully Phillips can talk him through games and keep him calm.

I’d still crave a proper LB that strengthens defence and by default midfield depth too.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#65
(08-15-2025, 07:42 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’d say Phillips is better than any CB here last season, it’s whether the others are an upgrade on the others.  Wait and see.

I think Campbell will be prone to a clanger, Ajayiesque.  Hopefully Phillips can talk him through games and keep him calm.

I’d still crave a proper LB that strengthens defence and by default midfield depth too.

Yeah, but why do you think that? Is it so you can be proven right IF it happens?
Reply
#66
(08-15-2025, 07:19 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(08-15-2025, 07:03 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Very pleased with this. Overall we have upgraded the centre back department.
Do you think so? Obviously I hope you're right.. but losing Heggem and Bartley plus Ajayi, gaining Beilik, Campbell, Phillips.
Jury's out.

Well I get castigated much on here as I never rated either Ajayi nor Bartley. I thought they were protected by Corberan's rigid formation and exposed without it. Heggem is a loss but Phillips and Bielik are very good additions. I'm happy to take a punt on Campbell and Taylor. Obviously just my opinion but I'm happy so far. Assuming we have cover at right back in the Academy then left back is the next position to reinforce.
Reply
#67
It's early days, but I think we've upgraded. Ajayi was error and injury prone, Phillips is the better player.
I think we've played a blinder selling Heggem for roughly 7m plus add ons and getting as good a player as Bielik for 2m.
Campbell is an unknown quantity bar what we saw Tuesday but would anyone swap him for Bartley right now?
Reply
#68
Average age down from 31 to 26, so that's a plus.
Personally, I think Phillips will be an improvement on Bartley and Bielik will be as reliable as Heggem, if not as flexible.
Campbell vs Ajayi is hard to call as we've seen so little of him, but early signs are positive.

If, however, we are getting £10m bids for Campbell in a year's time, then he will definitely have been successful!
Reply
#69
Welcome Christian. Who was the last player we bought from Brum, Darren Carter?
Reply
#70
Looks like Phillips is a proper leader. Him and Campbell could turn out to be perfect for us. Campbell is good at both passing and dribbling through the press. I reckon Phillios could be our most important signing this window
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)