Keeper scenario!?
#51
(02-14-2025, 11:59 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: The biggest things to my mind are his lack of height, and he seems to have zero presence. I sit right at the front, behind the goals, and Palmer was constantly shouting and directing the defence. Wildsmith did non of this. The second goal against Blackburn, Palmer would have taken that cross easily. Griffiths has the stature of Palmer, and hopefully will be much more vocal. Hopefully Mowbray puts him in tomorrow. Another slip by Wildsmith and the boo boys will be all over him.

You can't really buy presence as a keeper, can you? 

They either have it or don't. Palmer had it in. abundance. Nothing instils reassurance and confidence more in centrebacks than a vocal keeper bellowing out instructions and that yell of "keepers ball"

As for Wildsmith, there will be no hiding place. Either he's up to it, or not.
Reply
#52
(02-14-2025, 11:19 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: Josh Griffiths isn't 21, he's 23.

Ah apologies, still not a massive difference.
Reply
#53
(02-14-2025, 10:00 AM)Sliced Wrote: Last game Wildsmith was poor, and I hope Griffiths gets in next game, but lets be honest there's a lot of our fans that were desperate for his first mistake so they could jump on it.

Oh yes, I for one was delighted at, after driving a 5 hour round trip up and down rhe M6 on a wet Wednesday night, that he chucked one in and then played hokey cokey for another to cost us the game. All so I could come on here and say he was shit. That's exactly what happened.
Reply
#54
(02-14-2025, 06:40 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 10:00 AM)Sliced Wrote: Last game Wildsmith was poor, and I hope Griffiths gets in next game, but lets be honest there's a lot of our fans that were desperate for his first mistake so they could jump on it.

Oh yes, I for one was delighted at, after driving a 5 hour round trip up and down rhe M6 on a wet Wednesday night, that he chucked one in and then played hokey cokey for another to cost us the game. All so I could come on here and say he was shit. That's exactly what happened.

I probably wasn't talking about you then.
Reply
#55
(02-14-2025, 11:59 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: The biggest things to my mind are his lack of height, and he seems to have zero presence. I sit right at the front, behind the goals, and Palmer was constantly shouting and directing the defence. Wildsmith did non of this. The second goal against Blackburn, Palmer would have taken that cross easily. Griffiths has the stature of Palmer, and hopefully will be much more vocal. Hopefully Mowbray puts him in tomorrow. Another slip by Wildsmith and the boo boys will be all over him.

He's the same size as Peter Shilton, but simply Shilton played in an era when the big centre forward was 6ft and the big centre halve similar. Guys like Joe Jordan and Ally Rob would be small now, and 6ft as a keeper is like being 5ft 10 30 odd years ago.

I think Pickford is 6 1, again on the smaller side by today's standard, but what he brings is incredible presence where he scares the shit of those in front of him to do the right thing- he also has astonishing passing skills and awareness, that makes up for being on the smaller side of modern day keepers.

Simply though at corners a 6ft keeper, who is the same size as half of the players on the field now doesn't have the same level of command, in an era when every team has 3-4 very tall 6 3 or 6 4 guys in there.

Wildsmith is better than Button I believe, but I think even Griffiths of 2 years ago was better than Wildsmith is now. 

Here in 2025, Griffiths was idolised at Bristol Rovers and, in my opinion, not far behind Palmer 2 years ago. He's a huge keeper, with over 100 games behind him- it's now his time.
Reply
#56
Wildsmith is probably a good keeper. He can't be a liability, played 40 games for Derby last season, who were promoted and had the best defensive record in the league. Not sure that happens with a goalkeeper who is a liability.

For what it's worth I would have played Griffiths, but it was a tough decision. I find it hard to understand why he came to us this season, Palmer was always going to be difficult to dislodge as the first choice. Not picking him when Palmer moved on would have been a massive blow, one that would be hard to come back from.

Who plays tomorrow will be another big and difficult choice. Glad I'm not making it.
Reply
#57
I wouldn't mind making the decision the money our Tony,s on .
Reply
#58
(02-12-2025, 10:50 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's fine, he's the "senior pro" who's been in the squad as the first team number 2. He's had his go, and in both games he's been vulnerable and made errors.

Josh should be in on Saturday. But don't think he will.

Arf
Reply
#59
Reading posts from February (rightfully) saying that Wildsmith should be dropped is depressing.
Reply
#60
(02-13-2025, 07:18 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: We'd have lost last night with Palmer in goal. The GK position is not the issue.

Are we seriously writing off Wildsmith after two games, one of which he made two excellent saves to keep us in the game, which we went on to win!

Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: