Grant... pens
#1
One for the statos... if you include last night I have it that he's taken 10 pens for us. And missed 5. Is that correct?
Reply
#2
(08-13-2025, 05:28 AM)CIM Wrote: One for the statos... if you include last night I have it that he's taken 10 pens for us. And missed 5. Is that correct?

Probably, he shouldn’t have been anywhere near taking one. You would have thought Mason would have an idea of his abysmal record too
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#3
A forward player with a decent goals return. I simply cannot understand why Grant can't take a convincing penalty.
FWIW, and separately, I think every CF should be have Shearer's attitude at penalties. First, hit it hard at either top corner. They know where it's going but can't do anything about it. Second, it's my job to get 20+ goals and a penalties are about the easiest way to get there..
Reply
#4
I missed the end of the game so didn't see their goal. A few on here are criticising Wildsmith but what about levelling some criticism at the penalty takers? How come we only scored two out of five?
Reply
#5
(08-13-2025, 10:45 AM)baggienick68 Wrote: I missed the end of the game so didn't see their goal. A few on here are criticising Wildsmith but what about levelling some criticism at the penalty takers? How come we only scored two out of five?

Fair point...
Personally ive been critical of Wallace and Grant for ages..maybe not on here. Both a comllete waste of space. Never understood the love in with Wallace. Overrated bang average at best..get rid.
Grant..generally awful until he decided to put himself about a bit last season..but ultimately hes crap.
Yeh..its where we are and i expect too much..blah blah...but i wouldnt give you a bag of sprouts for either.
Reply
#6
Penalties are weird for players.

First of all, it's a dead ball, that changes how to hit it, all the power has to applied as it's kicked, and it has to aimed completely since there is no flight already being done. Shearer was capable of doing it and getting top corner, but when it went wrong, ball flies over the bar hilariously. Grant already struggles unless cutting in a moving ball, no chance he'll be a good penalty taker.

That's our problem, none of our players, maybe Dike excepted, are actual goal scorers, even Maja is more of a creator and is a bit erratic with finishing. This is also why sometimes defenders can be good penalty takers, Maguire for example is a fantastic penalty taker because he can get the angle and power right at the start, but lacks every other attribute for a striker.

I used to occasionally play up front, always in a number 10 role, finishing was my weakness, and I've never, ever scored a penalty that mattered, even in training most were saved or flew over the bar.

Practice rarely helps either, players can do them, or can't, and that seems to be it, and players can lose the confidence to do them too, see Berahino.
Reply
#7
Oh, interestingly, it's another skill, with goal poaching, that is fading out of the game at academy level, why when a player is good at pens now, they standout, while back in the 90's, most strikers were good at penalties
Reply
#8
I never have, and never will criticise penalty takers in that situation.. fair fucks for putting their hand up.
Reply
#9
You cannot easily say who will take a good penalty, Jed Wallace scored 8 in two seasons for Millwall….but missed, Mulumby scored and his passingand clean hitting of a ball is pretty weak. I think it is mainly psychological, confidence, visualisation and having a strategy
Reply
#10
(08-13-2025, 11:05 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Penalties are weird for players.

First of all, it's a dead ball, that changes how to hit it, all the power has to applied as it's kicked, and it has to aimed completely since there is no flight already being done. Shearer was capable of doing it and getting top corner, but when it went wrong, ball flies over the bar hilariously. Grant already struggles unless cutting in a moving ball, no chance he'll be a good penalty taker.

That's our problem, none of our players, maybe Dike excepted, are actual goal scorers, even Maja is more of a creator and is a bit erratic with finishing.  This is also why sometimes defenders can be good penalty takers, Maguire for example is a fantastic penalty taker because he can get the angle and power right at the start, but lacks every other attribute for a striker.

I used to occasionally play up front, always in a number 10 role, finishing was my weakness, and I've never, ever scored a penalty that mattered, even in training most were saved or flew over the bar.

Practice rarely helps either, players can do them, or can't, and that seems to be it, and players can lose the confidence to do them too, see Berahino.

They are professional footballers, not 8 year olds having a park kick around.

Your 30 years behind the times. There's no excuse for not being able to take a decent penalty nowadays. The majority of players for any League Two side will strike a better penalty 9 times out of 10 than Grant's and Wallace's half-arsed efforts yesterday. The latters in particular was very poor. Can't agree that practice doesn't help either, why wouldn't it? You probably don't expect a keeper to be able to control a ball with their feet either.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)