Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(08-08-2025, 08:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-07-2025, 09:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All of that is made up Dekka. I voted for Corbyn and subsequently realised afterwards that he would not be accepted so made the pragmatic decision in voting for Starmer. The PIP system needs reform and there is abuse of the system - most have seen it but you have been sheltered from it apparently. You opposed the changes without understanding them from what you showed. I’m all for a wealth tax but they simply don’t work in the way you want. Adding pensions into inheritance tax is a wealth tax (taxable wealth at a measureablr and definite point) - that will cost my kids dependent on how long I live. If you are reading my posts as not upsetting the rich then you are daft - I’m simply saying a wealth tax has been tried many times and failed many times. It’s simple really - how would you measure wealth.
You’d like it sound Tory because it’s not telling you you’re right. You simply don’t have any realistic proposals that will work in the real world. We all need to face up to the long haul ahead of us instead of wanting unicorns today
I voted for Corbyn knowing that he would lose. If Andy Burnham for example was proposing those policies he would have had a far better chance of winning. It was bloody obvious that Corbyn and Momentum were a hinderance not a vote winner.
Starmer has shown he has no convictions, he’s u-turned and contradicted himself on most of the policies he’s voted on, developed and delivered. His lack of convictions mean know one trusts him, no one has a clue what Labour stand for and the principles it once stood for have been thrown out the window to appease voters who will never go back to voting for him or Labour. Labour for elected because the Tories were abysmal nothing more.
You continually ignore what I write, I have said the welfare system around disability needs reform. However you slavishly follow the party line that £5bn cuts were reform. The reforms were written on a vape packet after Reeves and the treasury realised they’d ran out of wriggle room. You cite fraud and yet cannot produce any proper research, I’m sure there is fraud as there is in any system but you want it to be significant because it justifies picking on the most vulnerable in society to shoulder the financial burden for a lack of growth in the economy. The fact the government would have lost the vote if they hadn’t rowed back on its ‘reforms’ shows how badly thought out, disingenuous and communicated it was.
You sound like a Tory because the party you still defend are following broadly Tory led policies that have failed miserably for over a decade.
You don’t get politics it’s about the story, and personality you tell as much as the policies. Labours story is one of five years of more of the same drudgery as the last 15yrs, very little hope, divisive language around working people and non working people, how about just people, no real vision, condescension and hypocrisy and some vague our hearts not in it, Reform style rhetoric around immigration.
Meanwhile Reform hold the narrative around immigration, crime, and hope for change. It’ll be awful I’m sure if they win power, but with a vacuum of personality and hope at the heart of this Labour government that’s what you get.
Things can only get perhaps slightly better but probably worse! Is not what people want to hear. But those last 2 lines are the truth. Unpalatable as it sounds. When Boris was slinging (taxpayers) money around in Covid, when they decided they would protect us from rising energy bills, did no one stop and think who is going to pay for this? Whoever won that last election was on a hiding to nothing. I was hoping to see Labour go after the super rich, sort out the housing supply, aim for growth, I still think they were the best bet at the last election but find them currently, underwhelming. The hope is that they find their teeth along the way because the alternative parties are still unconvincing. Maybe a new leader, someone like Burnham, would help in policy and popularity terms. . Fact is, you stop anyone in the High St. the pub, the football or the bloke that comes to mend your drains and they'll likely tell you they will vote for whoever promises to sort out immigration. So select your party carefully next time, if Labour fall apart, what is the alternative?
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
08-08-2025, 09:17 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-08-2025, 09:23 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(08-08-2025, 08:50 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-08-2025, 08:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You don’t get politics it’s about the story, and personality you tell as much as the policies.
Considering you've spent the last few years bemoaning populist governments this statement really does raise an eyebrow.
It always has been it’s not a new thing. Labour had charismatic (whatever people think of him) Blair up against a decent but grey Major or for that matter Thatcher versus Kinnock.
Also what story is Labour telling people? Things aren’t going to get better for another five years but trust us in a decade it’ll be much better. Oh and even then, it’ll only be for working people who fit into our neat little boxes of PAYE, usually within the public sector. Small business owners, freelancers, unpaid carers, the disabled, the sick, elderly… we don’t care about you.
What do Labour stand for? If you can’t answer that without some vague weasel words around ‘working people’ and ‘change’ then you’ve answered the question why everything they do seems like middle management accountancy with PR team borrowed from Sunak’s broom cupboard.
(08-08-2025, 08:51 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (08-08-2025, 08:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-07-2025, 09:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All of that is made up Dekka. I voted for Corbyn and subsequently realised afterwards that he would not be accepted so made the pragmatic decision in voting for Starmer. The PIP system needs reform and there is abuse of the system - most have seen it but you have been sheltered from it apparently. You opposed the changes without understanding them from what you showed. I’m all for a wealth tax but they simply don’t work in the way you want. Adding pensions into inheritance tax is a wealth tax (taxable wealth at a measureablr and definite point) - that will cost my kids dependent on how long I live. If you are reading my posts as not upsetting the rich then you are daft - I’m simply saying a wealth tax has been tried many times and failed many times. It’s simple really - how would you measure wealth.
You’d like it sound Tory because it’s not telling you you’re right. You simply don’t have any realistic proposals that will work in the real world. We all need to face up to the long haul ahead of us instead of wanting unicorns today
I voted for Corbyn knowing that he would lose. If Andy Burnham for example was proposing those policies he would have had a far better chance of winning. It was bloody obvious that Corbyn and Momentum were a hinderance not a vote winner.
Starmer has shown he has no convictions, he’s u-turned and contradicted himself on most of the policies he’s voted on, developed and delivered. His lack of convictions mean know one trusts him, no one has a clue what Labour stand for and the principles it once stood for have been thrown out the window to appease voters who will never go back to voting for him or Labour. Labour for elected because the Tories were abysmal nothing more.
You continually ignore what I write, I have said the welfare system around disability needs reform. However you slavishly follow the party line that £5bn cuts were reform. The reforms were written on a vape packet after Reeves and the treasury realised they’d ran out of wriggle room. You cite fraud and yet cannot produce any proper research, I’m sure there is fraud as there is in any system but you want it to be significant because it justifies picking on the most vulnerable in society to shoulder the financial burden for a lack of growth in the economy. The fact the government would have lost the vote if they hadn’t rowed back on its ‘reforms’ shows how badly thought out, disingenuous and communicated it was.
You sound like a Tory because the party you still defend are following broadly Tory led policies that have failed miserably for over a decade.
You don’t get politics it’s about the story, and personality you tell as much as the policies. Labours story is one of five years of more of the same drudgery as the last 15yrs, very little hope, divisive language around working people and non working people, how about just people, no real vision, condescension and hypocrisy and some vague our hearts not in it, Reform style rhetoric around immigration.
Meanwhile Reform hold the narrative around immigration, crime, and hope for change. It’ll be awful I’m sure if they win power, but with a vacuum of personality and hope at the heart of this Labour government that’s what you get.
Things can only get perhaps slightly better but probably worse! Is not what people want to hear. But those last 2 lines are the truth. Unpalatable as it sounds. When Boris was slinging (taxpayers) money around in Covid, when they decided they would protect us from rising energy bills, did no one stop and think who is going to pay for this? Whoever won that last election was on a hiding to nothing. I was hoping to see Labour go after the super rich, sort out the housing supply, aim for growth, I still think they were the best bet at the last election but find them currently, underwhelming. The hope is that they find their teeth along the way because the alternative parties are still unconvincing. Maybe a new leader, someone like Burnham, would help in policy and popularity terms. . Fact is, you stop anyone in the High St. the pub, the football or the bloke that comes to mend your drains and they'll likely tell you they will vote for whoever promises to sort out immigration. So select your party carefully next time, if Labour fall apart, what is the alternative?
The fact is Labour won’t stop immigration and they are tin eared when it comes to dumping people within communities that are already struggling.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
08-08-2025, 09:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-08-2025, 09:57 AM by baggy1.)
(08-08-2025, 09:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The fact is Labour won’t stop immigration and they are tin eared when it comes to dumping people within communities that are already struggling.
What does this mean? I don't think Labour are trying to stop immigration - they are making an effort to reduce asylum seekers coming across the channel. But when they do arrive, which they do, where should they go?
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(08-08-2025, 09:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-08-2025, 09:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The fact is Labour won’t stop immigration and they are tin eared when it comes to dumping people within communities that are already struggling.
What does this mean? I don't think Labour are trying to stop immigration - they are making an effort to reduce asylum seekers coming across the channel. But when they do arrive, which they do, where should they go?
Replying to Tom Joad. Whatever the rights and wrongs of this particular challenge, it’s clear that if Labour continue to place asylum seekers in hotels and HMOs in towns creaking from underinvestment it’ll see them lose the next election. They’ve just lost yet another council seat in South Staffs, to Reform with a big swing. I appreciate it’s a difficult challenge for any party particularly Labour but it’s not going away and I very much doubt the debate will calm down before the next election.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
They place them in all authorities, there is a protest in Solihull this weekend.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(08-08-2025, 02:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-08-2025, 09:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-08-2025, 09:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The fact is Labour won’t stop immigration and they are tin eared when it comes to dumping people within communities that are already struggling.
What does this mean? I don't think Labour are trying to stop immigration - they are making an effort to reduce asylum seekers coming across the channel. But when they do arrive, which they do, where should they go?
Replying to Tom Joad. Whatever the rights and wrongs of this particular challenge, it’s clear that if Labour continue to place asylum seekers in hotels and HMOs in towns creaking from underinvestment it’ll see them lose the next election. They’ve just lost yet another council seat in South Staffs, to Reform with a big swing. I appreciate it’s a difficult challenge for any party particularly Labour but it’s not going away and I very much doubt the debate will calm down before the next election.
Agree Derek. My point is that immigration, mainly from the channel, is the hot topic whether we like that or not. Any party making promises to "sort it out" will gain ground at Labour's expense. Thus meaning a swing to the right. Like I said, I'm hoping Labour find an economic plan meanwhile to avert a Reform win next time around. The N.I.rise was/is a very poor move, they need to find a wealth tax of some kind as their own populist policy.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
I see Proth Minor has missed the challenge laid out around my ‘where to look’ response. So I did a bit more looking at Wealth Taxation, given that it’s a slow Friday at the desk.
Wealth taxes absolutely exist and they do bring in money, despite what B1, Proth and Hayek would have you believe. Spain’s got one that kicks in for people with over €700k in assets (after debts) and still raised over €600 million last year, even though Madrid basically refunds the whole thing to residents. Switzerland’s version is local – each area sets its own rate – but it brings in around 3.6% of the country’s total tax revenue, which is huge. Norway’s got a 1.1% rate on net wealth over about £120k, and that raised 1.1% of all taxes in 2019. France used to hit all assets over €1.3m and pulled in €5 billion a year before switching to a property-only version that’s still in place.
In all cases, it’s done through the normal tax system. People just declare their assets once a year, deduct any debts, and pay the tax if they’re over the threshold. It’s not rocket science — real estate, shares, savings, and valuables get counted, minus mortgages and loans. A lot of the asset values are standardised or discounted (e.g. Norway only taxes 25% of the value of your main home), and enforcement is just part of normal tax compliance. FAFO, I think the term is.
If the UK wanted to copy something like this, it wouldn’t be that hard with a bit of political will, competence, guile and skill (as I said in my response). You could set a threshold at £2 million net wealth per person, apply a 1% rate on anything above that, and run it through self-assessment with the rest of the tax system. Property, ISAs, second homes, stocks, all count — but mortgages and other debts would knock a chunk off most people’s totals. You could even exclude pensions if you wanted to soften the blow. A commission already looked into it and reckoned a one-off tax of 1% a year for 5 years on the richest households would raise £260 billion. That’s not pocket change.
So yeah, wealth taxes aren’t some unworkable fantasy. They already function in places with similar economies, and they’re just another tool in the box. Not saying they’re perfect or painless, but pretending they don’t work is just nonsense.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
What people mean when they say they wouldn’t work is that they don’t want another hurdle to have to jump to avoid their reasonable contributions to society
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
The wealth tax in Norway hasn't really worked out though as it's resulted in a net reduction in tax receipts due to people changing their registered address, France had similar issues.
The only country that has a functional wealth tax (countries with a LVT like Denmark aside) is Switzerland and that only works due to how broad the applicability is and the effective net result with regards to the rate it's applied (up to 0.5%) coupled with low income tax rates. Switzerland also has a generous capital gains to compensate. In order for this to work you'd need to cut income tax, completely redo how capital gains tax functions and levy a wealth tax to a rate that is close to revenue neutral than revenue generating but if that doesn't actually work you've screwed yourself by cutting tax receipts.
There is fundamental scope for taxation reform but it involves wrapping up stamp duties, council tax and business rates into a revenue-neutral land value tax and simplifying the tax structure on VAT and income tax (rolling in the rates of effective income taxes like employee NICs into income tax and removing the withdrawal of the personal allowance with a cut to the allowance limit) but that isn't going to be popular enough to enact because entrenched interest groups that will lose out (pensioners, low-paid workers, very wealthy people) and there will be an inflationary effect from VAT simplification.
The real issue with the UK is that productivity and growth has stalled, that is the easiest way to boost tax receipts. A productive economy means real growth, real growth means more tax. Labour's big problem is they were so vague on what they promised to do on productivity that they either don't know or are too scared, and have kneecapped themselves on the few things they did talk about because they are too scared. Where is the grand infrastructure planning? Where is the land rescoping for planning? They've actively made it harder to fill key labour shortages so they aren't doing that. They've kicked the can down the road on social care reform so that's not going to get fixed meaning beds will be blocked and waiting times won't go down fast enough. They could start legalising aspects of the black and grey markets and tax revenues from that but they won't because they don't care to legalise the things that requires to happen.
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
08-08-2025, 08:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-08-2025, 08:32 PM by man in the corner shop.)
(08-08-2025, 05:30 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I see Proth Minor has missed the challenge laid out around my ‘where to look’ response. So I did a bit more looking at Wealth Taxation, given that it’s a slow Friday at the desk.
Wealth taxes absolutely exist and they do bring in money, despite what B1, Proth and Hayek would have you believe. Spain’s got one that kicks in for people with over €700k in assets (after debts) and still raised over €600 million last year, even though Madrid basically refunds the whole thing to residents. Switzerland’s version is local – each area sets its own rate – but it brings in around 3.6% of the country’s total tax revenue, which is huge. Norway’s got a 1.1% rate on net wealth over about £120k, and that raised 1.1% of all taxes in 2019. France used to hit all assets over €1.3m and pulled in €5 billion a year before switching to a property-only version that’s still in place.
In all cases, it’s done through the normal tax system. People just declare their assets once a year, deduct any debts, and pay the tax if they’re over the threshold. It’s not rocket science — real estate, shares, savings, and valuables get counted, minus mortgages and loans. A lot of the asset values are standardised or discounted (e.g. Norway only taxes 25% of the value of your main home), and enforcement is just part of normal tax compliance. FAFO, I think the term is.
If the UK wanted to copy something like this, it wouldn’t be that hard with a bit of political will, competence, guile and skill (as I said in my response). You could set a threshold at £2 million net wealth per person, apply a 1% rate on anything above that, and run it through self-assessment with the rest of the tax system. Property, ISAs, second homes, stocks, all count — but mortgages and other debts would knock a chunk off most people’s totals. You could even exclude pensions if you wanted to soften the blow. A commission already looked into it and reckoned a one-off tax of 1% a year for 5 years on the richest households would raise £260 billion. That’s not pocket change.
So yeah, wealth taxes aren’t some unworkable fantasy. They already function in places with similar economies, and they’re just another tool in the box. Not saying they’re perfect or painless, but pretending they don’t work is just nonsense.
And
https://54degrees.com/project/robinhoodtax/
But let's just hear the Proth/Baggy1/Daily mail narrative as an accepted truth.
|