Villa FFP
#51
Total net losses of Championship clubs since Shaun Harvey was appointed CEO of @EFL are £1,177,278,000, (£4.5 million a week)

Shows that the current leader of that organisation hasn't a clue how to enforce ffp or make the leagues anywhere near sustainable. Notwithstanding of course owners who are spunking millions on average players
Reply
#52
(06-03-2019, 05:56 PM)billybassett Wrote: Total net losses of Championship clubs since Shaun Harvey was appointed CEO of @EFL are £1,177,278,000, (£4.5 million a week)

Shows that the current leader of that organisation hasn't a clue how to enforce ffp or make the leagues anywhere near sustainable. Notwithstanding of course owners who are spunking millions on average players

That's the reasoning behind my thoughts that on average owners are investing £20 million a year into clubs to keep them afloat.
Because our owner is insistent he will not invest a penny, After this seasons parachute payment has been used we will be struggling to stay afloat IMO never mind compete, It's not all bad we have several good youngsters coming through and a few quality player we can still cash in on. Short term we are secure. Time for Dowling / Pearce and Jenkins to earn their corn. I hope they don't do a runner when the money starts drying up, we have been used enough.
Reply
#53
(06-03-2019, 08:04 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(06-03-2019, 05:56 PM)billybassett Wrote: Total net losses of Championship clubs since Shaun Harvey was appointed CEO of @EFL are £1,177,278,000, (£4.5 million a week)

Shows that the current leader of that organisation hasn't a clue how to enforce ffp or make the leagues anywhere near sustainable. Notwithstanding of course owners who are spunking millions on average players

That's the reasoning behind my thoughts that on average owners are investing £20 million a year into clubs to keep them afloat.
Because our owner is insistent he will not invest a penny, After this seasons parachute payment has been used we will be struggling to stay afloat IMO never mind compete, It's not all bad we have several good youngsters coming through and a few quality player we can still cash in on. Short term we are secure. Time for Dowling / Pearce and Jenkins to earn their corn. I hope they don't do a runner when the money starts drying up, we have been used enough.
I've just said on another thread quite a few of my work mates(non with any particular axe to grind) seem to think we are close to being in financial meltdown where this rumour has come from I've no idea but interesting to hear how others see us at the moment.
Reply
#54
Thought something might had happened against Villa and Derby before the start of last season but they fudged it and ended up in the Wembley final so cannot reality take the FFP thing seriously any more.
Just a farce as was the Bolton scenario.
Reply
#55
Am I wrong in saying, that in essence the FFP rules are only relevant if you don't get promoted within 2 seasons?

What's to stop us (Tight arse owner aside!) from spending x amount on a Premiership quality squad, which clearly breaches FFP rules, if we get promoted at the end of the season? The EFL clearly can't or won't do anything after the season ends, and it'd be too early for FFP breaches to show up in our accounts.

The only risk in this, as far as I can tell, is if you fail to get promoted, then the EFL can hand out punishments mid season, as per Blues. 

Pragmatist?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#56
(06-04-2019, 05:24 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(06-03-2019, 08:04 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(06-03-2019, 05:56 PM)billybassett Wrote: Total net losses of Championship clubs since Shaun Harvey was appointed CEO of @EFL are £1,177,278,000, (£4.5 million a week)

Shows that the current leader of that organisation hasn't a clue how to enforce ffp or make the leagues anywhere near sustainable. Notwithstanding of course owners who are spunking millions on average players

That's the reasoning behind my thoughts that on average owners are investing £20 million a year into clubs to keep them afloat.
Because our owner is insistent he will not invest a penny, After this seasons parachute payment has been used we will be struggling to stay afloat IMO never mind compete, It's not all bad we have several good youngsters coming through and a few quality player we can still cash in on. Short term we are secure. Time for Dowling / Pearce and Jenkins to earn their corn. I hope they don't do a runner when the money starts drying up, we have been used enough.
I've just said on another thread quite a few of my work mates(non with any particular axe to grind) seem to think we are close to being in financial meltdown where this rumour has come from I've no idea but interesting to hear how others see us at the moment.

Anybody who can read a set of accounts will know that we are a long way from being in financial meltdown.  We were arguably in better financial shape than any team that has been relegated from the PL in recent years, with no debt, having made profits in 9 of the previous 10 seasons. 

The only issue is that being self-financing is not realistic after next season when the second parachute payment will have been used. Cutting our cloth accordingly will then be necessary and all other teams in the Championship are reliant on financing from their shareholder.  Tying in high-earning players on long contracts right now is unwise - hence the Gayle wages stance.
Reply
#57
(06-04-2019, 05:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-04-2019, 05:24 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(06-03-2019, 08:04 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(06-03-2019, 05:56 PM)billybassett Wrote: Total net losses of Championship clubs since Shaun Harvey was appointed CEO of @EFL are £1,177,278,000, (£4.5 million a week)

Shows that the current leader of that organisation hasn't a clue how to enforce ffp or make the leagues anywhere near sustainable. Notwithstanding of course owners who are spunking millions on average players

That's the reasoning behind my thoughts that on average owners are investing £20 million a year into clubs to keep them afloat.
Because our owner is insistent he will not invest a penny, After this seasons parachute payment has been used we will be struggling to stay afloat IMO never mind compete, It's not all bad we have several good youngsters coming through and a few quality player we can still cash in on. Short term we are secure. Time for Dowling / Pearce and Jenkins to earn their corn. I hope they don't do a runner when the money starts drying up, we have been used enough.
I've just said on another thread quite a few of my work mates(non with any particular axe to grind) seem to think we are close to being in financial meltdown where this rumour has come from I've no idea but interesting to hear how others see us at the moment.

Anybody who can read a set of accounts will know that we are a long way from being in financial meltdown.  We were arguably in better financial shape than any team that has been relegated from the PL in recent years, with no debt, having made profits in 9 of the previous 10 seasons. 

The only issue is that being self-financing is not realistic after next season when the second parachute payment will have been used. Cutting our cloth accordingly will then be necessary and all other teams in the Championship are reliant on financing from their shareholder.  Tying in high-earning players on long contracts right now is unwise - hence the Gayle wages stance.

Am I the only fan who thinks this is sensible?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#58
(06-04-2019, 05:47 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Am I wrong in saying, that in essence the FFP rules are only relevant if you don't get promoted within 2 seasons?

What's to stop us (Tight arse owner aside!) from spending x amount on a Premiership quality squad, which clearly breaches FFP rules, if we get promoted at the end of the season? The EFL clearly can't or won't do anything after the season ends, and it'd be too early for FFP breaches to show up in our accounts.

The only risk in this, as far as I can tell, is if you fail to get promoted, then the EFL can hand out punishments mid season, as per Blues. 

Pragmatist?

That’s incorrect - but only if the EFL actually apply their own new rules.

They changed the rules from 16/17 to prevent Championship teams escaping sanctions by being promoted. The PL agreed to apply Championship sanctions (and vice versa) after Bournemouth and Leicester got away with it.  QPR would have got away with it had they not been relegated.  

In the 3rd year of a 3-year cycle where a club looks like breaking the Championship P&S limits, that club has to provide accounting forecasts for the 3rd season on a monthly basis.  If they aren’t going to satisfy the limits then the EFL can deny them promotion, deny them a playoff place, impose transfer embargos etc 

Seems like Villa and Derby both satisfied the EFL by (lawfully) selling and leasing back their grounds, thereby booking a large enough profit to cover their P&S shortfall.  Seemingly valid, if based on independent valuations.

If on the other hand either club is found, after publishing their audited accounts next March/April, to have misled the EFL then you can expect litigation from other Championship clubs, no doubt led by Steve Gibson.   However those clubs can’t try that groundselling trick again until they’ve bought their grounds back - again at arms length valuation prices.
Reply
#59
(06-04-2019, 06:09 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-04-2019, 05:47 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Am I wrong in saying, that in essence the FFP rules are only relevant if you don't get promoted within 2 seasons?

What's to stop us (Tight arse owner aside!) from spending x amount on a Premiership quality squad, which clearly breaches FFP rules, if we get promoted at the end of the season? The EFL clearly can't or won't do anything after the season ends, and it'd be too early for FFP breaches to show up in our accounts.

The only risk in this, as far as I can tell, is if you fail to get promoted, then the EFL can hand out punishments mid season, as per Blues. 

Pragmatist?

That’s incorrect - but only if the EFL actually apply their own new rules.

They changed the rules from 16/17 to prevent Championship teams escaping sanctions by being promoted. The PL agreed to apply Championship sanctions (and vice versa) after Bournemouth and Leicester got away with it.  QPR would have got away with it had they not been relegated.  

In the 3rd year of a 3-year cycle where a club looks like breaking the Championship P&S limits, that club has to provide accounting forecasts for the 3rd season on a monthly basis.  If they aren’t going to satisfy the limits then the EFL can deny them promotion, deny them a playoff place, impose transfer embargos etc 

Seems like Villa and Derby both satisfied the EFL by (lawfully) selling and leasing back their grounds, thereby booking a large enough profit to cover their P&S shortfall.  Seemingly valid, if based on independent valuations.

If on the other hand either club is found, after publishing their audited accounts next March/April, to have misled the EFL then you can expect litigation from other Championship clubs, no doubt led by Steve Gibson.   However those clubs can’t try that groundselling trick again until they’ve bought their grounds back - again at arms length valuation prices.

Correct on all fronts, Prag. Sale/Leaseback is a "one off" fix. Presumably a market rent will have to be paid as well, to support the valuation, which could be £4M p.a. if a 5% yield is used on £80M valuation. This won't bother Villa, but it will be a consideration if they are ever relegated.

Concerning our accounts, they look tidy enough, and don't seem to be holding the horrors of Villa's from last year. Being self financing is unsustainable though, and the FFP rules create problems with the wage bills.

What we don't how is how Lai financed the acquisition of the share capital from Peace, and whether anyone in China is pressing him to make repayments. In terms of the club though, there are no apparent visible issues.
Reply
#60
(06-04-2019, 07:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(06-04-2019, 06:09 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-04-2019, 05:47 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Am I wrong in saying, that in essence the FFP rules are only relevant if you don't get promoted within 2 seasons?

What's to stop us (Tight arse owner aside!) from spending x amount on a Premiership quality squad, which clearly breaches FFP rules, if we get promoted at the end of the season? The EFL clearly can't or won't do anything after the season ends, and it'd be too early for FFP breaches to show up in our accounts.

The only risk in this, as far as I can tell, is if you fail to get promoted, then the EFL can hand out punishments mid season, as per Blues. 

Pragmatist?

That’s incorrect - but only if the EFL actually apply their own new rules.

They changed the rules from 16/17 to prevent Championship teams escaping sanctions by being promoted. The PL agreed to apply Championship sanctions (and vice versa) after Bournemouth and Leicester got away with it.  QPR would have got away with it had they not been relegated.  

In the 3rd year of a 3-year cycle where a club looks like breaking the Championship P&S limits, that club has to provide accounting forecasts for the 3rd season on a monthly basis.  If they aren’t going to satisfy the limits then the EFL can deny them promotion, deny them a playoff place, impose transfer embargos etc 

Seems like Villa and Derby both satisfied the EFL by (lawfully) selling and leasing back their grounds, thereby booking a large enough profit to cover their P&S shortfall.  Seemingly valid, if based on independent valuations.

If on the other hand either club is found, after publishing their audited accounts next March/April, to have misled the EFL then you can expect litigation from other Championship clubs, no doubt led by Steve Gibson.   However those clubs can’t try that groundselling trick again until they’ve bought their grounds back - again at arms length valuation prices.

Correct on all fronts, Prag. Sale/Leaseback is a "one off" fix. Presumably a market rent will have to be paid as well, to support the valuation, which could be £4M p.a. if a 5% yield is used on £80M valuation. This won't bother Villa, but it will be a consideration if they are ever relegated.

Concerning our accounts, they look tidy enough, and don't seem to be holding the horrors of Villa's from last year. Being self financing is unsustainable though, and the FFP rules create problems with the wage bills.

What we don't how is how Lai financed the acquisition of the share capital from Peace, and whether anyone in China is pressing him to make repayments. In terms of the club though, there are no apparent visible issues.

Fortunately the one thing we do know is that Lai hasn’t mortgaged the club to buy the shares. Any debt involved is his/his consortium’s, not the club’s. 

Will be very interesting to see what he does going forward.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)