Rejoice Rejoice 31 March 1990
#31
With the taxes applied to individual landlords it'll just shift more wealth into corporates rather than people's pockets.

Maggie might be dead but she'd have been chuffed.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#32
(08-04-2025, 03:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The councils lost a significant proportion of value on assets they owned for those 3 million houses which meant they didn't have the capital to replace the stock they lost. There simply wasn't enough money to ring-fence to address the need to build social housing. You're not only looking at the 3 million assets lost at below value but the opportunity to realise the value of those assets by raising capital which could have been used to build new social housing schemes. The sums referenced in the report represent such a huge loss in opportunity value that should have been directed to building more houses.

That's the effect of the subsidy. And any subsidy that does not expand supply is a poor use of a subsidy. The whole premise of right to buy was to increase the owner occupier ratio but here we are now in 2025 with it being lower now than it was in the 1980s and trending downwards towards levels not seen since the late 1960s, so it's completely failed in that respect.

They will only have lost max 10% (if they gave them away free which they didn’t) and you’re not taking into account the outsourcing of the social housing stock to associations. The housing stock is at 90% of what it would have been if they’d have kept the 3m houses. 

Again I take you back to the ‘do nothing’ scenario. If they hadn’t sold these they still wouldn’t have had the money to spend on building social housing. I realise this is an easy one to look at as being the bogey man and I agree that it was badly planned and delivered but it isn’t the all evil that is being painted.
Reply
#33
(08-04-2025, 12:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Right to buy was a terrible initiative that strangled local government funding while acting as one of the biggest state housing subsidies ever given out with the long-term effect of reversing the trend of home ownership rates going up.

Bang on, BB. We had the RTB with my dad eventually being the only one left in the family home. We talked him into  doing a swap with another social housing provider which gave him a flat in a location that became convenient as he aged. It freed up a good sized house for a family. Exactly how it should be and no regrets about losing a few bob on a "property deal". I can tell a dozen other stories from that estate though. Most end up with private landlords not doing repairs or turning homes into HMOs. In one case a woman I knew bought her house under RTB, due to her instant equity she was bombarded with offers of loans she couldn't resist, sold it quickly and cheaply to cover her debts and now rents the same house privately at a lot more money. There is, I'm sure, the odd exception but I don't see any utopian ideal, just a desperate shortage of homes.
Reply
#34
(08-04-2025, 04:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 03:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The councils lost a significant proportion of value on assets they owned for those 3 million houses which meant they didn't have the capital to replace the stock they lost. There simply wasn't enough money to ring-fence to address the need to build social housing. You're not only looking at the 3 million assets lost at below value but the opportunity to realise the value of those assets by raising capital which could have been used to build new social housing schemes. The sums referenced in the report represent such a huge loss in opportunity value that should have been directed to building more houses.

That's the effect of the subsidy. And any subsidy that does not expand supply is a poor use of a subsidy. The whole premise of right to buy was to increase the owner occupier ratio but here we are now in 2025 with it being lower now than it was in the 1980s and trending downwards towards levels not seen since the late 1960s, so it's completely failed in that respect.

They will only have lost max 10% (if they gave them away free which they didn’t) and you’re not taking into account the outsourcing of the social housing stock to associations. The housing stock is at 90% of what it would have been if they’d have kept the 3m houses. 

Again I take you back to the ‘do nothing’ scenario. If they hadn’t sold these they still wouldn’t have had the money to spend on building social housing. I realise this is an easy one to look at as being the bogey man and I agree that it was badly planned and delivered but it isn’t the all evil that is being painted.

The discount averaged out to 44% by 1988. With the number of houses that were sold and the distribution of those houses, like the London commuter belt which was adversely affected and where there's a huge shortage, that is a huge subsidy and it's a subsidy which did the opposite of moving the supply-demand curve to the right. 

The "do nothing" scenario is that the previous trend up until the 1980 act would have continued where tenants had the right to purchase at market value and older stock was sold to the private sector to help fund newer stock, it's one of many idiotic short term decisions made in the 1980s that has bitten us in the arse. It has undoubtedly contributed to the problem, particularly in the social housing space where aside from an aberration been 2010 and 2015 has continually been shrinking. And we've ended up with the absurd position of 52% of those houses being used for rent with 16% being rented out privately and 36% being rented out socially, and I repeat this was via a state subsidy that did not shift the supply-demand curve to the right. And that has ballooned the benefit bill by virtue of increasing the cost of housing benefit than if that had otherwise stayed as it was - another positive for the "do nothing" scenario.

If you remove the capacity for someone to realise the value of their assets then they cannot replenish those assets like-for-like.
Reply
#35
I don’t disagree with the overarching sentiment BB, I’m saying the figures don’t make sense. You’re saying that just over 4% of the total value of the portfolio has caused that problem. It doesn’t make sense if those figures are correct.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)