Rejoice Rejoice 31 March 1990
#21
Not certain it's even as simple as that CC. Restricting people in doing what they want with their own property is probably fraught with legal issues, there could have been something in there whereby selling the property within a period of time would impact on the discount. I'm not certain it would have been the people purchasing that were the issue either - landlords could see an opportunity whereby they get the tenant to buy the property at a heavily discounted price, and at the same guaranteeing them that they would purchase it off them at a higher, but lower than market value, price. They then continue their rental and everyone is a winner, apart from society that is.
Reply
#22
Right to buy was a terrible initiative that strangled local government funding while acting as one of the biggest state housing subsidies ever given out with the long-term effect of reversing the trend of home ownership rates going up.
Reply
#23
(08-04-2025, 12:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not certain it's even as simple as that CC. Restricting people in doing what they want with their own property is probably fraught with legal issues, there could have been something in there whereby selling the property within a period of time would impact on the discount. I'm not certain it would have been the people purchasing that were the issue either - landlords could see an opportunity whereby they get the tenant to buy the property at a heavily discounted price, and at the same guaranteeing them that they would purchase it off them at a higher, but lower than market value, price. They then continue their rental and everyone is a winner, apart from society that is.

I believe there has always been a 5 year restriction rule on re-selling which meant some of  the discount had to be repaid. Whether it was actually enforced or not is debatable
Reply
#24
(08-04-2025, 12:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Right to buy was a terrible initiative that strangled local government funding while acting as one of the biggest state housing subsidies ever given out with the long-term effect of reversing the trend of home ownership rates going up.

I'd argue that it was more complex than that BB, council tenants having the right to buy their home after living there, and therefore maintaining the property and the value of that home, is a good thing. The way it was delivered and the lack of replacement was the problem. Then there are the wider issues, population growth of 11m since 2000 which is approx 20% of the 2000 population is massive under any circumstances - house building has not kept up at that pace and would struggle to have done. 

There have been approximately 3m RTB properties removed from council ownership since 1979 and the vast majority of them went directly to the former tenant which increase home ownership; subsequently 40% of those are now in private landlords hands - there are still 27m council properties available, without RTB that number would still only be 30M. I'm not certain that solves the problem - it's not as if they are empty.

(08-04-2025, 12:56 PM)strawman Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 12:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not certain it's even as simple as that CC. Restricting people in doing what they want with their own property is probably fraught with legal issues, there could have been something in there whereby selling the property within a period of time would impact on the discount. I'm not certain it would have been the people purchasing that were the issue either - landlords could see an opportunity whereby they get the tenant to buy the property at a heavily discounted price, and at the same guaranteeing them that they would purchase it off them at a higher, but lower than market value, price. They then continue their rental and everyone is a winner, apart from society that is.

I believe there has always been a 5 year restriction rule on re-selling which meant some of  the discount had to be repaid. Whether it was actually enforced or not is debatable

Didn't know that SM and that would make sense. Further reading shows 40% of those sold (3m) are now in private landlord ownership, so probably not as bad as the situation I stated above. Like you say, whether it was enforced is another matter.
Reply
#25
Gifting 10% of your social housing stock to private landlords was a disaster, alongside - as you mentioned - the lack of ringfenced rebuilding funds.

Now that I've thought about it more, the transfer of state owned assets to private individuals (not even landlords) was morally bankrupt. People had their housing subsidised by the taxpayer, the government then disposed of that national asset below market value (Gold anyone?) and failed to secure protection for the improper use of those assets, contributing to the shortage of affordable housing we have today. Morally, why should someone, who has had their asset part funded by me, a taxpayer, then be allowed to obtain that asset for a discounted rate? I've already funded their heating upgrade, double glazing etc - why do I need to pay more than they did? Those 'homeowners' then ripped off successive generations - indirectly at least.

To be clear, I don't have ANY issue with social housing - but I do have an issue with subsidised asset transfer.

PS: Covenants on buildings are a piece of piss to do - even moreso if you're the body that controls the development and approval of legislation!
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#26
It wasn't 10% CC - It was 40% of the 10% so 4%.

And those private individuals had maintained their homes for decades with this being their only opportunity to get onto the property ladder. They paid rent at a rate that was relative to the mortgage prices of the day in the earlier groups.
Reply
#27
(08-04-2025, 02:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It wasn't 10% CC - It was 40% of the 10% so 4%.

And those private individuals had maintained their homes for decades with this being their only opportunity to get onto the property ladder. They paid rent at a rate that was relative to the mortgage prices of the day in the earlier groups.

Apologies, misread re 10%.

However, my understanding was works were covered by council repairs, not homeowners - I certainly know that my Nan's double glazing, heating system and bathroom redo was all paid for with council monies not her own.

She declined RTB, the daft Socialist bint! Big Grin
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#28
(08-04-2025, 01:21 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 12:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Right to buy was a terrible initiative that strangled local government funding while acting as one of the biggest state housing subsidies ever given out with the long-term effect of reversing the trend of home ownership rates going up.

I'd argue that it was more complex than that BB, council tenants having the right to buy their home after living there, and therefore maintaining the property and the value of that home, is a good thing. The way it was delivered and the lack of replacement was the problem. Then there are the wider issues, population growth of 11m since 2000 which is approx 20% of the 2000 population is massive under any circumstances - house building has not kept up at that pace and would struggle to have done. 

There have been approximately 3m RTB properties removed from council ownership since 1979 and the vast majority of them went directly to the former tenant which increase home ownership; subsequently 40% of those are now in private landlords hands - there are still 27m council properties available, without RTB that number would still only be 30M. I'm not certain that solves the problem - it's not as if they are empty.

Wholeheartedly disagree, fundamentally this was a massive subsidy that did not even attempt to address supply constraints and actively made it difficult to replace social housing stock.

It's also had the knock-on effect of inadvertently increasing the benefit bill because supply of social housing went down while demand has gone up over the medium term meaning we're paying more in housing benefit than we otherwise would have done if the social housing stock was local authority owned. 

This was a poorly thought out policy designed solely to grab votes, subsidy to not expand supply is fiscally reckless and it's cost the state a lot of money that would have been better spent on building bloody houses.
Reply
#29
(08-04-2025, 02:25 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 02:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It wasn't 10% CC - It was 40% of the 10% so 4%.

And those private individuals had maintained their homes for decades with this being their only opportunity to get onto the property ladder. They paid rent at a rate that was relative to the mortgage prices of the day in the earlier groups.

Apologies, misread re 10%.

However, my understanding was works were covered by council repairs, not homeowners - I certainly know that my Nan's double glazing, heating system and bathroom redo was all paid for with council monies not her own.

She declined RTB, the daft Socialist bint! Big Grin

They were CC I should have added. My MIL took advantage of it and sold up latterly to move to a better area and have some cash (something she'd never had before) so it put her onto the property ladder. It gave her options that she wouldn't have had otherwise.

(08-04-2025, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 01:21 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 12:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Right to buy was a terrible initiative that strangled local government funding while acting as one of the biggest state housing subsidies ever given out with the long-term effect of reversing the trend of home ownership rates going up.

I'd argue that it was more complex than that BB, council tenants having the right to buy their home after living there, and therefore maintaining the property and the value of that home, is a good thing. The way it was delivered and the lack of replacement was the problem. Then there are the wider issues, population growth of 11m since 2000 which is approx 20% of the 2000 population is massive under any circumstances - house building has not kept up at that pace and would struggle to have done. 

There have been approximately 3m RTB properties removed from council ownership since 1979 and the vast majority of them went directly to the former tenant which increase home ownership; subsequently 40% of those are now in private landlords hands - there are still 27m council properties available, without RTB that number would still only be 30M. I'm not certain that solves the problem - it's not as if they are empty.

Wholeheartedly disagree, fundamentally this was a massive subsidy that did not even attempt to address supply constraints and actively made it difficult to replace social housing stock.

It's also had the knock-on effect of inadvertently increasing the benefit bill because supply of social housing went down while demand has gone up over the medium term meaning we're paying more in housing benefit than we otherwise would have done if the social housing stock was local authority owned. 

This was a poorly thought out policy designed solely to grab votes, subsidy to not expand supply is fiscally reckless and it's cost the state a lot of money that would have been better spent on building bloody houses.

The numbers don't add up BB - look at the 'do nothing' scenario here. If RTB didn't occur then those 3m would still be in those homes until they would have died, so you haven't made any more houses available to reduce the need for social housing - without the sale they would all of those that bought would still need social housing. Even if all 3M of them had passed on then that would have only increased the housing stock by that 3m and the need is much greater. Population growth of 11m over that period (20%) would not be solved by 3m extra houses (10% of housing stock). By selling you gave them the opportunity to improve their lives and leave money to their kids for deposits eventually - wthout that there is a liklihood that the kids would need social care hosuing.

The problem lies in your last paragraph whereby the money should have been ringfenced to build more, that didn't happen because LAs had their funding cut and the RTB money filled gaps.
Reply
#30
The councils lost a significant proportion of value on assets they owned for those 3 million houses which meant they didn't have the capital to replace the stock they lost. There simply wasn't enough money to ring-fence to address the need to build social housing. You're not only looking at the 3 million assets lost at below value but the opportunity to realise the value of those assets by raising capital which could have been used to build new social housing schemes. The sums referenced in the report represent such a huge loss in opportunity value that should have been directed to building more houses.

That's the effect of the subsidy. And any subsidy that does not expand supply is a poor use of a subsidy. The whole premise of right to buy was to increase the owner occupier ratio but here we are now in 2025 with it being lower now than it was in the 1980s and trending downwards towards levels not seen since the late 1960s, so it's completely failed in that respect.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)