Make Gaza Great Again
It's not conflation. Remove the cause, end the effect.

To answer your question, no, they would also require the unconditional surrender of all enemy combatants, and rightly so.
Reply
Ahhh yeah, then they’d be super nice and stop genocide and land grabs. Got ya.
Reply
Conflating the settlers, encouraged or not by the Israeli government, tos teal land in the west bank, to the the war in Gaza to remove Hamas from power and return hostages after the largest attack on Jews since WWII is never going to help.

The reality here is both Palestinian and Israeli moderates, which I imagine are the vast, vast majority are governed by nationalist, religious, idealist nutters. Both need to be removed from power. The problem is there will never be an election in Israel in war time. So the war needs to finish, with the temporary destruction of Hamas and it's proxy's to allow space for a political solution. Where hopefully the more moderate Arab states and the western world can mediate on both sides.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(08-03-2025, 11:21 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Conflating the settlers, encouraged or not by the Israeli government, tos teal land in the west bank, to the the war in Gaza to remove Hamas from power and return hostages after the largest attack on Jews since WWII is never going to help.

The reality here is both Palestinian and Israeli moderates, which I imagine are the vast, vast majority are governed by nationalist, religious, idealist nutters.  Both need to be removed from power. The problem is there will never be an election in Israel in war time. So the war needs to finish, with the temporary destruction of Hamas and it's proxy's to allow space for a political solution. Where hopefully the more moderate Arab states and the western world can mediate on both sides.

I probably shouldn't have quoted Squid's post, I was ignoring the whataboutery re the West Bank which they mention on virtually every post on this topic (so who is conflating?) and continuing the conversation about Gaza, apologies for the confusion.

(08-03-2025, 11:16 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Ahhh yeah, then they’d be super nice and stop genocide and land grabs. Got ya.

Only one way to find out...
Reply
There's a very obvious avenue for removing Hamas, it involves displacing them from the political structures in Gaza. The Israeli government have not even attempted to pursue that avenue so I cannot take any argument that they are trying to get rid of Hamas seriously.
Reply
(08-03-2025, 11:30 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: There's a very obvious avenue for removing Hamas, it involves displacing them from the political structures in Gaza. The Israeli government have not even attempted to pursue that avenue so I cannot take any argument that they are trying to get rid of Hamas seriously.

Hamas are not a real political party. The politicians are just the tip of a very large terrorist iceberg.

I am absolutely sickened at what Israel are doing. And war crimes have 100% been commited and those responsible should be held fully accountable. But Hamas by their very existence has given space for the Israelis to vote in and support a genocidal war.

It's horrible and messy and unfortunately it will continue to be so until Hamas and other proxy's are defeated as a military threat. Then and only then can the rest of world try and broker some sort of peace agreement and try and put more moderate leadership in place on both sides.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(08-03-2025, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-03-2025, 11:30 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: There's a very obvious avenue for removing Hamas, it involves displacing them from the political structures in Gaza. The Israeli government have not even attempted to pursue that avenue so I cannot take any argument that they are trying to get rid of Hamas seriously.

Hamas are not a real political party. The politicians are just the tip of a very large terrorist iceberg.

I am absolutely sickened at what Israel are doing. And war crimes have 100% been commited and those responsible should be held fully accountable. But Hamas by their very existence has given space for the Israelis to vote in and support a genocidal war.

It's horrible and messy and unfortunately it will continue to be so until Hamas and other proxy's are defeated as a military threat. Then and only then can the rest of world try and broker some sort of peace agreement and try and put more moderate leadership in place on both sides.

Hamas absolutely are a political party, the political party are the political wing of their military terrorist group. And that political party is in charge of the political structures of Gaza, you need to replace them with something else to have a functioning state.

I cannot take anything the Israeli government is doing seriously given they have not attempted to even pay lip service to displacing Hamas from those political structures. The only way to starve the military threat is to remove the political threat.
Reply
The so called “whataboutery” on the West Bank just demonstrates why Israel can’t be trusted to deal with any situation with integrity and within the law. It is absolutely a valid illustration of how they act with a mentality of being superior and treating others as second class (at best) human beings

To that end, it is entirely relevant. The only positive about the whole thing is Israel has exposed itself tot the whole world, whilst in reality is has behaved like this since its artificial inception, to one extent or another
Reply
(08-03-2025, 11:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The so called “whataboutery” on the West Bank just demonstrates why Israel can’t be trusted to deal with any situation with integrity and within the law. It is absolutely a valid illustration of how they act with a mentality of being superior and treating others as second class (at best) human beings

To that end, it is entirely relevant. The only positive about the whole thing is Israel has exposed itself tot the whole world, whilst in reality is has behaved like this since its artificial inception, to one extent or another

Including long before Hamas existed.
Reply
(08-03-2025, 12:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-03-2025, 11:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The so called “whataboutery” on the West Bank just demonstrates why Israel can’t be trusted to deal with any situation with integrity and within the law. It is absolutely a valid illustration of how they act with a mentality of being superior and treating others as second class (at best) human beings

To that end, it is entirely relevant. The only positive about the whole thing is Israel has exposed itself tot the whole world, whilst in reality is has behaved like this since its artificial inception, to one extent or another

Including long before Hamas existed.

Indeed.

It would be wonderful to see Palestine self governing free from its current administration but to pretend they are or always have been the main reason for Israel’s genocidal leanings has the horse and the cart the wrong way around.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)