Growth
I think that this is what happens when you can't lose an election, because the other lot are simply unelectable, and swan into office with a false sense of superiority.

My concern about Labour was that they never were specific on what their growth strategy was, despite throwing the word about pre-election as if it were confetti. One hoped that it was simply to obfuscate the finer points of their manifesto (and risk the last lot plagiarising it), but it is becoming increasingly clear that no meaningful, workable strategy existed. They have been thwarted by a combination of their own electorate and backbench at every turn to make the savings an increased spending budget necessitated, and - whilst it's more than clear that they have inherited an abundance of cans kicked well-and-truly down the road - everyone knew that this was more than likely the case, and it should have been anticipated (certainly they have done the blaming part of this observation often enough).

So, it all hinged on the magic 'G' word, and beyond a miraculous trade deal with the US being formalised beyond conjecture I simply cannot see what that is going to consist of.

More borrowing was obviously out, because Truss (as we all know all too well) unsuccessfully tried that one. Spending cuts aren't achievable without pissing everyone off. Promises have been made, yet strikes are either ongoing or about to start again, and I can even see the QE question raising its head again. In fact it's exactly why I voted for Davey, because he at least suggested one or two things that were different to the norm. Instead, all we have are Tories in different ties, which even more regrettably is adding greater appeal to the extremist lunatics who think voting for Reform or what Corbyn can muster will somehow represent a better option.

What a horrible, horrible mess.
Reply
ThassitR
Reply
Despite coming things from different angles I think most not all on this thread are all disappointed with Labour which is no mean feat to achieve given our different experience, points of view and circumstances. Starmer himself seems to lack both imagination and conviction and would rather listen to advisers who are patently failing to deliver on any meaningful level be they practical or political. If you fail to give people hope and change and continue to follow Sunak orthodox, management then you simply roll out the red carpet to Reform.

For all the piss taking and condescension I have taken on here since I dared to be critical of Starmer, his cabinet and his advisers, I feel that my opinion hasn’t been far off what is and has transpired so far.
Reply
(07-16-2025, 01:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Despite coming things from different angles I think most not all on this thread are all disappointed with Labour which is no mean feat to achieve given our different experience, points of view and circumstances. Starmer himself seems to lack both imagination and conviction and would rather listen to advisers who are patently failing to deliver on any meaningful level be they practical or political. If you fail to give people hope and change and continue to follow Sunak orthodox, management then you simply roll out the red carpet to Reform.

For all the piss taking and condescension I have taken on here since I dared to be critical of Starmer, his cabinet and his advisers, I feel that my opinion hasn’t been far off what is and has transpired so far.

Smithers!! Release the hounds Baggy1.  Big Grin
Reply
As has been commented on in a couple of places today, we are now in a world where people object to something without knowing what they object to. Dekka's feed gives him reasons to be angry, the Hillsborough thread is a prime example. He's not certain what has happened but he's unhappy with it anyway and will have a go at the government. He doesn't believe that the benefits system needs reforming and will fight any reduction in benefits for anyone whether they need them or not, and he definitely doesn't believe there is fraud in the system.

A quick example - I've had a bloke register for PIP and receive his payment backdated and also register with NHS England whilst living at my address. I'm pretty certain he's pulling a fast one because his PIP scores indicate he can't get out of bed and can't feed himself. I've checked all the bedrooms in all of the wings and he's not there. But the system doesn't need reform because it is robust enough obviously.
Reply
(07-16-2025, 04:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: As has been commented on in a couple of places today, we are now in a world where people object to something without knowing what they object to. Dekka's feed gives him reasons to be angry, the Hillsborough thread is a prime example. He's not certain what has happened but he's unhappy with it anyway and will have a go at the government. He doesn't believe that the benefits system needs reforming and will fight any reduction in benefits for anyone whether they need them or not, and he definitely doesn't believe there is fraud in the system.

A quick example - I've had a bloke register for PIP and receive his payment backdated and also register with NHS England whilst living at my address. I'm pretty certain he's pulling a fast one because his PIP scores indicate he can't get out of bed and can't feed himself. I've checked all the bedrooms in all of the wings and he's not there. But the system doesn't need reform because it is robust enough obviously.

Have you considered that he may be your latest footman or gallery host? Sure you didn't check the orangery, snooker room and larder?
Reply
(07-16-2025, 04:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: As has been commented on in a couple of places today, we are now in a world where people object to something without knowing what they object to. Dekka's feed gives him reasons to be angry, the Hillsborough thread is a prime example. He's not certain what has happened but he's unhappy with it anyway and will have a go at the government. He doesn't believe that the benefits system needs reforming and will fight any reduction in benefits for anyone whether they need them or not, and he definitely doesn't believe there is fraud in the system.

A quick example - I've had a bloke register for PIP and receive his payment backdated and also register with NHS England whilst living at my address. I'm pretty certain he's pulling a fast one because his PIP scores indicate he can't get out of bed and can't feed himself. I've checked all the bedrooms in all of the wings and he's not there. But the system doesn't need reform because it is robust enough obviously.

I’ve never said the system doesn’t need reform, it’s a lie to suggest otherwise. However you cannot reform anything without doing your homework first. They didn’t consult properly with the disabled community, they haven’t come up with any credible plan to get more people into work other than some vague plans around work coaches, they haven’t said how they are going to incentivise companies to take on people with disability and they didn’t bother to listen to their own backbenchers.

With regards to SM feeds the fact is you cherry pick as does everyone the bits you like/support your argument and dismiss the stuff you don’t. You’ve had to change your argument more than once declaring something was or wasn’t a fact then backtracked afterwards.

You say there’s fraud of PIP (never wanting to commit to how much) and ignore reports that if there is, it’s not significant or anywhere near what the Government wanted to cut from the budget. 

I appreciate that you are reluctant to concede that Labour handled the disability cuts badly, you’re still arguing they were reforms. Not one  element was well thought out including communication, planning or intended implementation. The reason for this seems more about cuts than reform of the welfare budget. At least a third of Labour MPs knew this and that’s a major reason the arrogant cabinet and advisers had to back down.
Reply
A lot of bullshit in that post Dekka, you’re making things up now I’m afraid.
Reply
(07-16-2025, 10:04 PM)TV baggy1 Wrote: A lot of bullshit in that post Dekka, you’re making things up now I’m afraid.

I’m simply disputing what you accused me of. Which bits are bullshit?
Reply
Today's fresh hell for Rachel
Unemployment up
These Tories need to be gone. Inept, charmless, soulless, spineless and delivering fuck all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)