Seven Tribes
#21
(07-14-2025, 08:30 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Over the last couple of days we've had claims that tge current problems this country faces starts with Brown's bailout and had a 'sliding doors' moment during the Miliband vs Miliband (which led to Corbyn) contest. 

I'm not even saying it's wrong but more aping the folk on here who still blame CORBYN.

David Miliband is ans was not the messiah and wouldn't have made a jot of difference imo. Though he can probably scoff a burger rather daintily.
Reply
#22
(07-15-2025, 12:05 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:30 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Over the last couple of days we've had claims that tge current problems this country faces starts with Brown's bailout and had a 'sliding doors' moment during the Miliband vs Miliband (which led to Corbyn) contest. 

I'm not even saying it's wrong but more aping the folk on here who still blame CORBYN.

David Miliband is ans was not the messiah and wouldn't have made a jot of difference imo. Though he can probably scoff a burger rather daintily.

https://medium.com/@craig_walmsley/this-...21341eb108
Reply
#23
(07-14-2025, 09:32 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: An interesting video that I have to say resonates - in a nutshell, huge amounts of the UK population are disillusioned with the current state of things and are looking for something that gives them hope. Where those people are looking for hope, and to what extent they want to scrutinise their selected source of hope is what differentiates them.

Labour had a massive, massive opportunity to introduce genuine, generational change and they have blown it to appease people they feared would vote reform in 5 years' time. The size of their mandate, plus the their lead over Reform and Tory MPs meant/means they could genuinely push through almost any legislative agenda they wanted (land taxes, wealth taxes, nationalisation, PR voting, even bloody redebating EU membership) but instead they've decided to continue with the same failed austerity bullshit that we've lived through for the last 15 years.

Yet another government we'll look back on with a sense of "what it, and how"

That's not the ticket they ran on. They went with the were adults and at least we aren't Rishi Sunak. The last time Labour genuinely offered something different the country returned Boris Johnson in record numbers. We don't want, not deserve change.
Reply
#24
(07-15-2025, 06:12 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(07-15-2025, 12:05 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:30 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Over the last couple of days we've had claims that tge current problems this country faces starts with Brown's bailout and had a 'sliding doors' moment during the Miliband vs Miliband (which led to Corbyn) contest. 

I'm not even saying it's wrong but more aping the folk on here who still blame CORBYN.

David Miliband is ans was not the messiah and wouldn't have made a jot of difference imo. Though he can probably scoff a burger rather daintily.

https://medium.com/@craig_walmsley/this-...21341eb108

Walmsley's analysis is laughable.

Given the talents that David had over his unworthy brother, you would have to wonder how he lost the leadership contest....possibly because Walmsley's assessment of the two brothers' capabilities are comfortably wide of the mark.

And the Ed Miliband is responsible for the election of Corbyn is risible. Corbyn came to power because all the other candidates could not read the room that was the Labour membership.Burnham should have won that contest but he followed Harman's disastrous leadership decisions and torpedoed his campaign.
Reply
#25
(07-15-2025, 08:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: And the Ed Miliband is responsible for the election of Corbyn is risible. 

Corbyn would never have won the leadership had the rules not changed.
Reply
#26
(07-15-2025, 07:25 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:32 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: An interesting video that I have to say resonates - in a nutshell, huge amounts of the UK population are disillusioned with the current state of things and are looking for something that gives them hope. Where those people are looking for hope, and to what extent they want to scrutinise their selected source of hope is what differentiates them.

Labour had a massive, massive opportunity to introduce genuine, generational change and they have blown it to appease people they feared would vote reform in 5 years' time. The size of their mandate, plus the their lead over Reform and Tory MPs meant/means they could genuinely push through almost any legislative agenda they wanted (land taxes, wealth taxes, nationalisation, PR voting, even bloody redebating EU membership) but instead they've decided to continue with the same failed austerity bullshit that we've lived through for the last 15 years.

Yet another government we'll look back on with a sense of "what it, and how"

That's not the ticket they ran on. They went with the were adults and at least we aren't Rishi Sunak. The last time Labour genuinely offered something different the country returned Boris Johnson in record numbers. We don't want, not deserve change.

By the time Sunak had called an election it was inevitable that Labour would win, such was the absolute shitshow that the Tories had presided over. Labour won not because of their policies because frankly they were dull (what were they, without Googling?). I know the Labour Party sycophants think his advisers did a brilliant job, but that’s a load of bollocks, it was an election harder to lose than win by virtue of Starmer and co’s opponents. 

As for the electorate rejecting a manifesto  that would have seen genuine change in policy from the Tories, those who still hold a torch for Corbyn can’t separate what by all accounts were popular policies according to most polls at the time from an unelectable salesperson in Corbyn. You also had to factor in Johnson’s appeal (yes I know inexplicable for some including me) and te backdrop of Brexit as reasons.

If those proposals had been set out by Starmer at the last election I’ve no doubt he would have won because that’s where the country was at the time looking for change… all it got was more of the same shite that Sunak was offering and they are still carrying on with this tactic whilst Reform show no sign of budging in the polls.
Reply
#27
(07-15-2025, 08:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-15-2025, 07:25 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:32 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: An interesting video that I have to say resonates - in a nutshell, huge amounts of the UK population are disillusioned with the current state of things and are looking for something that gives them hope. Where those people are looking for hope, and to what extent they want to scrutinise their selected source of hope is what differentiates them.

Labour had a massive, massive opportunity to introduce genuine, generational change and they have blown it to appease people they feared would vote reform in 5 years' time. The size of their mandate, plus the their lead over Reform and Tory MPs meant/means they could genuinely push through almost any legislative agenda they wanted (land taxes, wealth taxes, nationalisation, PR voting, even bloody redebating EU membership) but instead they've decided to continue with the same failed austerity bullshit that we've lived through for the last 15 years.

Yet another government we'll look back on with a sense of "what it, and how"

That's not the ticket they ran on. They went with the were adults and at least we aren't Rishi Sunak. The last time Labour genuinely offered something different the country returned Boris Johnson in record numbers. We don't want, not deserve change.

By the time Sunak had called an election it was inevitable that Labour would win, such was the absolute shitshow that the Tories had presided over. Labour won not because of their policies because frankly they were dull (what were they, without Googling?). I know the Labour Party sycophants think his advisers did a brilliant job, but that’s a load of bollocks, it was an election harder to lose than win by virtue of Starmer and co’s opponents. 

As for the electorate rejecting a manifesto  that would have seen genuine change in policy from the Tories, those who still hold a torch for Corbyn can’t separate what by all accounts were popular policies according to most polls at the time from an unelectable salesperson in Corbyn. You also had to factor in Johnson’s appeal (yes I know inexplicable for some including me) and te backdrop of Brexit as reasons.

If those proposals had been set out by Starmer at the last election I’ve no doubt he would have won because that’s where the country was at the time looking for change… all it got was more of the same shite that Sunak was offering and they are still carrying on with this tactic whilst Reform show no sign of budging in the polls.

Yep, proving once again that Proth's point about #Optics is bang on the money. Someone like Andy Burnham with Corbyn's policies would have probably won in 2017, 2019 and 2024.
Reply
#28
(07-14-2025, 09:32 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: in a nutshell, huge amounts of the UK population are disillusioned with the current state of things and are looking for something that gives them hope.

The great divide in our country these days is between those who want to protect what they have at all costs and those who cannot ever hope to attain wealth, even with what most of us would consider a high salary.

The economic power associated with rising property wealth is an unstoppable political force. All over the Black Country and Worcestershire this influence is being used ruthlessly to stop green belt release building in our back yards, choking new housing supply in a nation crying out for more homes for 50 years, and pushing asset prices yet higher. The government kept interest rates low and engaged in waves of quantitative easing for many dubious reasons, a central motive was that bidding up house prices is an electoral winner, not least because homeowners tend to vote in large numbers.

40% of 18-35 year olds live with their parents. Home ownership amongst the under 35s is just 6%. These stats are horrifying - virtually all my childhood friends from my sink comp owned their own home by the time they were 30. The idea of returning to to your folks' house permanently after University was unconscionable.

This squirreling away of free money into property and BTL has had a chilling effect on investment and productivity - 80% of the growth in per capita wealth over the last 30 years is because of property. Because young talented people cannot easily move home our economic dynamism is being strangled. All this wholly unearned housing wealth is the definition of hoarding. I'm part of the problem and I guess most of you are too.

There is an urgent moral case to address planning, taxes and tax incentives. Take your pick from the following, though a combination will be necessary:

Land Value Tax - with punitive rates for undeveloped residential sites with planning consent
Abolition of private residence relief (worth £30 billion pa) coupled with a lifetime CGT exemption on UK-based non-property investments 
Massive expansion of development into the Green Belt and White Land - new towns and cities, not just infill and extensions
Abolition of Stamp Duty to encourage labour mobility and downsizing
Outlaw RTB unless 2 social homes are built for every one sold
Address under occupation in the social rented sector
Specific tax incentives and CGT reliefs for non-property investment - abolish stamp duty on UK share transactions (FFS!)
Abandon the Triple Lock and increase the State Pension in line with wage growth only
Abolish Higher Rate relief on pension contributions in favour of a flat rate of 30% 
Abolish Lifetime Limits on pensions
Increase the age for access to 25% tax free lump sum from 55 to 65 (particularly in the public sector)

If you implement some or all of that then you might get under 40s interested in voting. If you don't, we are all fucked.

Those over 50 with huge unearned housing wealth need to take a long look in the mirror, and have a think about their less affluent neighbours of the same age, their kids and grandkids. If they don't we are fiscally screwed in any event.
Reply
#29
(07-15-2025, 08:42 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-15-2025, 08:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: And the Ed Miliband is responsible for the election of Corbyn is risible. 

Corbyn would never have won the leadership had the rules not changed.

Fucking hell, it's a broken clock!  Big Grin
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#30
(07-15-2025, 09:13 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:32 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: in a nutshell, huge amounts of the UK population are disillusioned with the current state of things and are looking for something that gives them hope.

The great divide in our country these days is between those who want to protect what they have at all costs and those who cannot ever hope to attain wealth, even with what most of us would consider a high salary.

The economic power associated with rising property wealth is an unstoppable political force. All over the Black Country and Worcestershire this influence is being used ruthlessly to stop green belt release building in our back yards, choking new housing supply in a nation crying out for more homes for 50 years, and pushing asset prices yet higher. The government kept interest rates low and engaged in waves of quantitative easing for many dubious reasons, a central motive was that bidding up house prices is an electoral winner, not least because homeowners tend to vote in large numbers.

40% of 18-35 year olds live with their parents. Home ownership amongst the under 35s is just 6%. These stats are horrifying - virtually all my childhood friends from my sink comp owned their own home by the time they were 30. The idea of returning to to your folks' house permanently after University was unconscionable.

This squirreling away of free money into property and BTL has had a chilling effect on investment and productivity - 80% of the growth in per capita wealth over the last 30 years is because of property. Because young talented people cannot easily move home our economic dynamism is being strangled. All this wholly unearned housing wealth is the definition of hoarding. I'm part of the problem and I guess most of you are too.

There is an urgent moral case to address planning, taxes and tax incentives. Take your pick from the following, though a combination will be necessary:

Land Value Tax - with punitive rates for undeveloped residential sites with planning consent
Abolition of private residence relief (worth £30 billion pa) coupled with a lifetime CGT exemption on UK-based non-property investments 
Massive expansion of development into the Green Belt and White Land - new towns and cities, not just infill and extensions
Abolition of Stamp Duty to encourage labour mobility and downsizing
Outlaw RTB unless 2 social homes are built for every one sold
Address under occupation in the social rented sector
Specific tax incentives and CGT reliefs for non-property investment - abolish stamp duty on UK share transactions (FFS!)
Abandon the Triple Lock and increase the State Pension in line with wage growth only
Abolish Higher Rate relief on pension contributions in favour of a flat rate of 30% 
Abolish Lifetime Limits on pensions
Increase the age for access to 25% tax free lump sum from 55 to 65 (particularly in the public sector)

If you implement some or all of that then you might get under 40s interested in voting. If you don't, we are all fucked.

Those over 50 with huge unearned housing wealth need to take a long look in the mirror, and have a think about their less affluent neighbours of the same age, their kids and grandkids. If they don't we are fiscally screwed in any event.

I agree with you in terms of the scale of the problem in terms of housing. It needs to be prioritised as an urgent issue. However, I think there is a massive amount that could be done with brownfield sites. Hagley Road is a prime example. So many former office blocks which could be redeveloped into housing.

I would also add that mortgage accessibility is a big issue. I bought my first house with a 100% graduate mortgage, those sorts of financial products are sadly non-existent now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)