How much is enough?
Rubbish. Without endless fiscal drag and ludicrous tax cliff edges this wouldn't even be a conversation.

Anyway. The government doesn't have the money.
Reply
Figures today suggesting that if you earned £125,000 in 2020 you'd now have to earn £210,000 to take home the same amount after allowing for tax changes and inflation.
Reply
Love to see the calculations for that Proth.
Reply
(07-07-2025, 09:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Figures today suggesting that if you earned £125,000 in 2020 you'd now have to earn £210,000 to take home the same amount after allowing for tax changes and inflation.

I believe that. If you were a youngish NHS consultant you would also lose child benefits. Is it any wonder they want a considerable pay rise? The tax system is truly fucked up, it is clearly a disincentive to work and productivity. I think Labour recognise the reallities, but changing things is very hard.
Reply
A very simple check shows me take home pay in 19/20, on gross of £125,000, is £76k. In 25/26 £210,000 will give you a take home of £123k

According to BoE inflation calculator £76k in 2020 equates to £97k today.
Reply
(07-07-2025, 10:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: A very simple check shows me take home pay in 19/20, on gross of £125,000, is £76k. In 25/26 £210,000 will give you a take home of £123k

According to BoE inflation calculator £76k in 2020 equates to £97k today.

Peoples tax affairs are far from simple though:

https://www.cityam.com/how-much-tax-do-y...n-numbers/
Reply
That will be a very specific, and worse case scenario then. It's saying if you earned £125k in 2020 and were a graduate that had maxed out their borrowing and hadn't paid it down more than the minimum in the decade since graduating then you could end up in that position (although it omits any calculations). It is also a massive leap to get from £123k before any pensions and student debt is taken out to get to £63k. That would involve a big chunk going into their pensions based on their wording, which strangely doesn't include inflation, "When taken together, all this means a 31-year old graduate earning £125,000 can expect a take-home pay of as little as £63,134 or just half their salary. To achieve the same take-home pay of someone earning £125,000 four years ago, they’d have to increase their salary to around £210,000 today."

I've looked at this a few different ways - I can't see where the figures add up - £210k with max student loan repayment equates to approx £95k net which will increase to £125k when they have paid off the debt in approx 4 years.

Is this the same publication you linked the other week that appears to be slightly biased into getting to a figure they want?
Reply
(07-07-2025, 11:08 AM)baggy1 Wrote: That will be a very specific, and worse case scenario then. It's saying if you earned £125k in 2020 and were a graduate that had maxed out their borrowing and hadn't paid it down more than the minimum in the decade since graduating then you could end up in that position (although it omits any calculations). It is also a massive leap to get from £123k before any pensions and student debt is taken out to get to £63k. That would involve a big chunk going into their pensions based on their wording, which strangely doesn't include inflation, "When taken together, all this means a 31-year old graduate earning £125,000 can expect a take-home pay of as little as £63,134 or just half their salary. To achieve the same take-home pay of someone earning £125,000 four years ago, they’d have to increase their salary to around £210,000 today."

I've looked at this a few different ways - I can't see where the figures add up - £210k with max student loan repayment equates to approx £95k net which will increase to £125k when they have paid off the debt in approx 4 years.

Is this the same publication you linked the other week that appears to be slightly biased into getting to a figure they want?

Every case is a specific case. I've given you several.

This case could be very specific to those in the medical profession, for instance. 

I appreciate that you're convinced there's nothing to see here, and nothing will convince you that there is.
Reply
I'm using the reported case in the opinion piece, I would say article but it is that badly written it has to be an opinion. I'm also highlighting the worst case scenario from an accounting point of view as well. The article is either badly written or simply wrong, and you haven't given me any examples.

Stating a made up article as proof of your cliff edge problems, in which the reference dates are 2020 and 2025 and the cliff edge you talk of being introduced in 2010, makes no sense whatsoever.
Reply
(07-07-2025, 03:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Stating a made up article as proof of your cliff edge problems, in which the reference dates are 2020 and 2025 and the cliff edge you talk of being introduced in 2010, makes no sense whatsoever.

You simply don't understand what I'm saying, or indeed that article. Let me spell it out:

Successive governments have distorted the taxation system to a massive extent. As wages rise generally and as individuals rise up the income scale those distortions become acute, creating crazy disincetives to earn any more beyond certain thresholds. Add in the corrosive effects of inflation and it demonstrates just how appalling those distortions are.

Quality people are refusing promotions just when we need growth. In professional services (from which the UK derives 10% of GDP) there is a crisis in succession. The lack of younger people willing to take on equity partnership when the after-tax reward does not merit the risk and responsibility is driving huge consolidation, often destroying value. I've already waxed lyrical about quiet quitting.

Rachel Reeves is not responsible for the development of this phenomenon, but she's certainly not making it worse by inaction and endless Fiscal Drag - believe me when I say you can put your house on her extending that beyond 2028 in the next Budget.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)