Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(07-05-2025, 08:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:27 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:15 PM)WWHO Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:55 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:50 PM)Dumbo Wrote: How did Nestors data lead us to Mowbray? He’s not the second coming of Steven Hawkins super computer.
I’ll say again. Mikey is the only member of our team that can run at a player.
We have Bany and a very raw Whitwell that do but granted we need to sign a proper creative spark/maverick.
I'm guessing Mikey Moore on loan might do this but I haven't seen enough of him to know....
My main concern about Bany is his injury record and ability to play a full 90 mins, let alone a 46 game season.
His former boss at Randers said this in a recent interview with the Brum Mail:
"Of course the Championship is a faster and more physical game with more athletic players. I think he has the skills but it'll be a question of how they manage his body and his fitness - he'll never be a guy who plays 90 minutes three times in a week. If you manage him well, then for sure he can make an impact."
Hardly fills me with confidence re his fitness and proneness to injuries.
So why did someone at Albion sanction a £3M transfer for him, sounds ludicrous.
Because he could still be a very good player, but just not one that plays every minute of every game.
Much like Yokuslu then. We missed him so much last season.
Posts: 7,715
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Johnston 3 goals and 5 assists; Grant 7 goals and 2 assists. I know who I'd rather have with the mooted 3 strikers we've got.
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
45 high quality minutes three times a week is fine by me.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(07-05-2025, 07:27 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:15 PM)WWHO Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:55 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:50 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:43 PM)WWHO Wrote: Considering how data driven Nestor is, he must have been aware of his 'creative stats', yet still sanctioned the deal.
He must feel he can find better for £5m?!
How did Nestors data lead us to Mowbray? He’s not the second coming of Steven Hawkins super computer.
I’ll say again. Mikey is the only member of our team that can run at a player.
We have Bany and a very raw Whitwell that do but granted we need to sign a proper creative spark/maverick.
I'm guessing Mikey Moore on loan might do this but I haven't seen enough of him to know....
My main concern about Bany is his injury record and ability to play a full 90 mins, let alone a 46 game season.
His former boss at Randers said this in a recent interview with the Brum Mail:
"Of course the Championship is a faster and more physical game with more athletic players. I think he has the skills but it'll be a question of how they manage his body and his fitness - he'll never be a guy who plays 90 minutes three times in a week. If you manage him well, then for sure he can make an impact."
Hardly fills me with confidence re his fitness and proneness to injuries.
So why did someone at Albion sanction a £3M transfer for him, sounds ludicrous.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...d-31931955
Might be worth reading the full interview. His ex coach spent most of his time saying how special he was and how well we had done picking him up. The above quote was the only caveat.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,961
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
07-06-2025, 09:21 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-06-2025, 09:24 AM by richbaggie.)
(07-05-2025, 03:48 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 03:24 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Poor man's Tony Morley. Great on his day but far too inconsistent. I think it's a good deal all round.
God , a poor mans Tony Morley would struggle to get a game for Kiddy Harriers, Morley was rubbish, ( although with an ego the size of The Isle Of Wight ), typical of the cheap, past it players we signed in the 80`s, like Gerry Armstrong, George Reilly, Tony`10 Ton` Kelly, Paul Dyson, Martin Dickinson, Mickey Thomas etc.
It was tongue in cheek but the comparison is true regarding their careers with both being devastating on their day but too often ineffective.
(07-06-2025, 08:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:27 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:15 PM)WWHO Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:55 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:50 PM)Dumbo Wrote: How did Nestors data lead us to Mowbray? He’s not the second coming of Steven Hawkins super computer.
I’ll say again. Mikey is the only member of our team that can run at a player.
We have Bany and a very raw Whitwell that do but granted we need to sign a proper creative spark/maverick.
I'm guessing Mikey Moore on loan might do this but I haven't seen enough of him to know....
My main concern about Bany is his injury record and ability to play a full 90 mins, let alone a 46 game season.
His former boss at Randers said this in a recent interview with the Brum Mail:
"Of course the Championship is a faster and more physical game with more athletic players. I think he has the skills but it'll be a question of how they manage his body and his fitness - he'll never be a guy who plays 90 minutes three times in a week. If you manage him well, then for sure he can make an impact."
Hardly fills me with confidence re his fitness and proneness to injuries.
So why did someone at Albion sanction a £3M transfer for him, sounds ludicrous.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...d-31931955
Might be worth reading the full interview. His ex coach spent most of his time saying how special he was and how well we had done picking him up. The above quote was the only caveat.
Agree Lurker. Interesting the takes people get from articles. I remember reading that feeling excited about him.
I saw a player in the minutes he managed with us. An all action player who makes things happen.
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Poor mans Sherjill Macdonald
Posts: 1,154
Threads: 59
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
8
(07-06-2025, 09:21 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (07-05-2025, 03:48 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 03:24 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Poor man's Tony Morley. Great on his day but far too inconsistent. I think it's a good deal all round.
God , a poor mans Tony Morley would struggle to get a game for Kiddy Harriers, Morley was rubbish, ( although with an ego the size of The Isle Of Wight ), typical of the cheap, past it players we signed in the 80`s, like Gerry Armstrong, George Reilly, Tony`10 Ton` Kelly, Paul Dyson, Martin Dickinson, Mickey Thomas etc.
It was tongue in cheek but the comparison is true regarding their careers with both being devastating on their day but too often ineffective.
(07-06-2025, 08:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:27 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:15 PM)WWHO Wrote: (07-05-2025, 06:55 PM)Peachy Wrote: We have Bany and a very raw Whitwell that do but granted we need to sign a proper creative spark/maverick.
I'm guessing Mikey Moore on loan might do this but I haven't seen enough of him to know....
My main concern about Bany is his injury record and ability to play a full 90 mins, let alone a 46 game season.
His former boss at Randers said this in a recent interview with the Brum Mail:
"Of course the Championship is a faster and more physical game with more athletic players. I think he has the skills but it'll be a question of how they manage his body and his fitness - he'll never be a guy who plays 90 minutes three times in a week. If you manage him well, then for sure he can make an impact."
Hardly fills me with confidence re his fitness and proneness to injuries.
So why did someone at Albion sanction a £3M transfer for him, sounds ludicrous.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...d-31931955
Might be worth reading the full interview. His ex coach spent most of his time saying how special he was and how well we had done picking him up. The above quote was the only caveat.
Agree Lurker. Interesting the takes people get from articles. I remember reading that feeling excited about him.
I saw a player in the minutes he managed with us. An all action player who makes things happen.
To be fair, I was talking about a concern I have regarding his ability to be relied upon over a full season.
This was in direct response to Peachy identifying him and Whitwell as potential sources of creativity.
From what I've seen of Bany, I'm very excited about his potential.
This comes with a caveat concerning his fitness levels and injury proneness (based on him getting injured early on in his Albion career and the aforementioned comments from his ex boss).
Posts: 1,961
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
That's a fair assessment. Hopefully a full pre season etc etc.
Given the demands of the champ and squad rotation, I doubt any midfielder will play much more than 2 out of 3 so need to get him to that level.
Posts: 1,154
Threads: 59
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
8
(07-06-2025, 09:43 AM)richbaggie Wrote: That's a fair assessment. Hopefully a full pre season etc etc.
Given the demands of the champ and squad rotation, I doubt any midfielder will play much more than 2 out of 3 so need to get him to that level.
Yeah, he was definitely not helped by joining what is a totally alien (and more intense) league right at the end of the January window.
I also need to accept that, due to the intensity of modern football, players can't be expected to play a 46 game season - particularly under a high press strategy.
I want all Albion players to do well - and Bany's no exception.
In fact, speaking personally, i'd love to see him succeed in order to raise the profile of players of Palestinian descent.
*as for me not linking the entire article - i wouldn't want to put anyone through that clusterfuck of a Brum Mail website ...
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-06-2025, 09:32 AM)WWHO Wrote: (07-06-2025, 09:21 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (07-05-2025, 03:48 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 03:24 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Poor man's Tony Morley. Great on his day but far too inconsistent. I think it's a good deal all round.
God , a poor mans Tony Morley would struggle to get a game for Kiddy Harriers, Morley was rubbish, ( although with an ego the size of The Isle Of Wight ), typical of the cheap, past it players we signed in the 80`s, like Gerry Armstrong, George Reilly, Tony`10 Ton` Kelly, Paul Dyson, Martin Dickinson, Mickey Thomas etc.
It was tongue in cheek but the comparison is true regarding their careers with both being devastating on their day but too often ineffective.
(07-06-2025, 08:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:27 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (07-05-2025, 07:15 PM)WWHO Wrote: My main concern about Bany is his injury record and ability to play a full 90 mins, let alone a 46 game season.
His former boss at Randers said this in a recent interview with the Brum Mail:
"Of course the Championship is a faster and more physical game with more athletic players. I think he has the skills but it'll be a question of how they manage his body and his fitness - he'll never be a guy who plays 90 minutes three times in a week. If you manage him well, then for sure he can make an impact."
Hardly fills me with confidence re his fitness and proneness to injuries.
So why did someone at Albion sanction a £3M transfer for him, sounds ludicrous.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...d-31931955
Might be worth reading the full interview. His ex coach spent most of his time saying how special he was and how well we had done picking him up. The above quote was the only caveat.
Agree Lurker. Interesting the takes people get from articles. I remember reading that feeling excited about him.
I saw a player in the minutes he managed with us. An all action player who makes things happen.
To be fair, I was talking about a concern I have regarding his ability to be relied upon over a full season.
This was in direct response to Peachy identifying him and Whitwell as potential sources of creativity.
From what I've seen of Bany, I'm very excited about his potential.
This comes with a caveat concerning his fitness levels and injury proneness (based on him getting injured early on in his Albion career and the aforementioned comments from his ex boss).
In fairness too, in the article his former coach also says he can’t do 90 minutes 3x a week because of his high aggression and high intensity, and said playing at that level in the Champ for 3 games a week would be very hard, he doesn’t say he can’t play 3 games in a week.
There are plenty of players that need to be managed through games, if we have to rotate him a little, that’s fine, provided we have some other options too.
|