The line between insulting speech and criminal speech
#11
(07-02-2025, 09:50 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:48 AM)MrBater Wrote: speaking of causing offence, how is anyone is offended by this??

https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/35651358/...kit-video/

I'm offended by The Sun

are you of Scouse descent?? Big Grin
Reply
#12
As Alan Partridge once said "It's now our national pastime to get offended by things we previously didn't care about at all."
Reply
#13
(07-02-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:13 AM)MrBater Wrote: Imagine if she'd said Jewish cunt....

She'd be headlining the Pyramid Stage in 2027 am I right?

Big Grin

Calling someone a this or that cunt really shouldn't be needing courts... Where would we all be with the seal cunts in that case?

Calling for the death of people on the other hand, that needs sorting.

You could argue he was calling for the "death" of IDF as an entity.
Reply
#14
(07-02-2025, 09:56 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 08:33 AM)Squid Wrote: While browsing the Manchester Evening News, via the link posted in the JSO thread, I came across this story:

Woman, 20, in court for racial abuse after calling hospital worker 'Welsh c***'

https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/...e-31965608

I have the following thoughts:

1) Are the Welsh actually a race?

2) Is this really worth a court case as opposed to the women being removed from the hospital?

I suspect she was being 'disruptive' so they used anything to punish her. IF that's the case then tough, why should people at work put up with arseholes without protection? If it isn't the case, in what context is it okay to call someone you don't know a 'cunt' anyway? I'm guessing the person wasn't offended by the use of Welsh, more the attitude displayed. 

You could remove her and she probably was, but then what do you do when she comes back in? It's tricky for a hospital to ban people because it's, well... a hospital! You can't really refuse entry, imagine the furore if the person was refused treatment.

Perhaps the bigger issue is that there is no law severe enough to protect people from aggressive arseholes so they have to look at other laws instead.

As a recent recipient of a speed ticket, maybe they should fast track the video/written evidence, issue a ticket, maybe an equivalent of a speed awareness course if its your first offence for £90, points on your record if not. However, if you choose to contest it, up to a £1000 fine.

There you go - solved it. Next.

Hospitals can and do ban people:

https://www.itv.com/news/2024-02-26/aggr...curb-abuse

City Hospital used to have a permanent police presence to deal with miscreants and I imagine the Midland Met has similar. 

I have no issue with hospitals barring abusive people, it's just whether verbal abuse should be considered a criminal offense.
Reply
#15
(07-02-2025, 09:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote: As Alan Partridge once said "It's now our national pastime to get offended by things we previously didn't care about at all."
Partridge is a buffoon, not a sage.  Just sayin.
Reply
#16
(07-02-2025, 10:00 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:13 AM)MrBater Wrote: Imagine if she'd said Jewish cunt....

She'd be headlining the Pyramid Stage in 2027 am I right?

Big Grin

Calling someone a this or that cunt really shouldn't be needing courts... Where would we all be with the seal cunts in that case?

Calling for the death of people on the other hand, that needs sorting.

You could argue he was calling for the "death" of IDF as an entity.

I think that is what is being claimed. And any lawyer worth their salt would argue that on their client's behalf.

And there is a danger in taking thinks too literally, Kneecap got their crowd to chant fuck Kier Starmer nobody took that literally.

On the wider subject i have some sympathy for the point Fuzzbox made, and context is everything. Someone being abusive and saying offensive things to someone directly is in more danger of commiting a criminal offence than someone saying exactly the same thing online.
Reply
#17
(07-02-2025, 11:05 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 10:00 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:13 AM)MrBater Wrote: Imagine if she'd said Jewish cunt....

She'd be headlining the Pyramid Stage in 2027 am I right?

Big Grin

Calling someone a this or that cunt really shouldn't be needing courts... Where would we all be with the seal cunts in that case?

Calling for the death of people on the other hand, that needs sorting.

You could argue he was calling for the "death" of IDF as an entity.

I think that is what is being claimed. And any lawyer worth their salt would argue that on their client's behalf.

And there is a danger in taking thinks too literally, Kneecap got their crowd to chant fuck Kier Starmer nobody took that literally.

On the wider subject i have some sympathy for the point Fuzzbox made, and context is everything. Someone being abusive and saying offensive things to someone directly is in more danger of commiting a criminal offence than someone saying exactly the same thing online.

Very good point. In the big scheme it's nothing. It's not like she said Olivia Rodrigo shouldn't be headlining Glastonbury!
Reply
#18
The only reason why Sophie Ellis Bextor didn't get charged is because she's middle class and white.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#19
(07-02-2025, 12:23 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: The only reason why Sophie Ellis Bextor didn't get charged is because she's middle class and white.

The lyrics to Murder In The Dancefloor grind my gears in ways you cannot imagine. It’s like some fuggin random word generator was used. I don’t know what the crime is here but if there isn’t one then there needs to be.
Reply
#20
(07-02-2025, 10:57 AM)Squid Wrote: Hospitals can and do ban people:

https://www.itv.com/news/2024-02-26/aggr...curb-abuse

City Hospital used to have a permanent police presence to deal with miscreants and I imagine the Midland Met has similar. 

I have no issue with hospitals barring abusive people, it's just whether verbal abuse should be considered a criminal offense.

Fair enough, I stand corrected. I can only imagine the man-hours that went in to banning someone. 

Staff need protected - if it's not a criminal offense then there has to be some deterrence, otherwise you're just diverting the problem. FWIW, I do think there should be an overhaul of what is meant by a 'criminal record'. 

If giving someone a criminal record is used too freely it actually makes things like getting a job harder which is counter-productive to the aim of 'fixing' bad behaviour. I would imagine it also works the other way where police and prosecution are unwilling to prosecute minor infractions. Either way, at present it makes for an unfair and inconsistent approach which inevitably attracts criticism.

p.s I read the article - I wonder how many people have actually been banned. "go back to the jungle"? I've not heard that one for years. Don't they realise with Global warning and soil erosion, it's mostly desert now? I personally would be happy to go back to the jungle. Do I get to choose which one? Costa Rica would be excellent. Obviously, as a new immigrant they can't expect me to jump the housing queue, that would be hypocritical, so I will need a nice house too. I'll pay up front and take a percentage of their social security benefits for the next twenty years if it helps....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: