Villa FFP
#31
(05-31-2019, 06:55 AM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 06:49 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules  to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League. 

Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table. 

Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?

Spot on. Stopping promotion won't happen though. 

Also cant see them getting a points deduction. The reason being the premier top brass are only interested in how their "brand is viewed. Having a team start the season on -12 Just wouldn't look good in their eyes.

It'll be a fine if they get anything. Dint QPR get £42m?

Possibly a transfer embargo too. That could actually could fuck them up big time if they aren't allowed to bring anyone in. That squad, without it's loan players, wouldn't survive at all.

Surely something has to be done to stop teams blatantly cheating their way to promotion. If not everyone will do it.
The problem with a transfer ban though is that they’ll still end up massively better off financially. Without the ability to sign any players they’ll probably go down, but with the benefit of £100 million plus of PL tv money and years of parachute payments. 

The EFL needed to deal with this weeks ago. If I were Blues I’d be kicking up a huge fuss over this, as they are still the only side to be properly punished over the new regulations.

Clearly it’s too late to deny them promotion, but you could deny them the riches that promotion offers. They should be docked their PL tv money so it drops to EFL levels and their parachute payments revoked.

Why is it 'too late' to deny them promotion.  

That's like saying oh you've stolen a million pounds and spent it so it's too late to prosecute you. 

They should be denied promotion and Derby (unless they're also disqualified) & WBA should play to decide who goes up or if not Derby, Leeds and WBA.
Reply
#32
(05-31-2019, 10:29 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 06:55 AM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 06:49 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules  to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League. 

Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table. 

Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?

Spot on. Stopping promotion won't happen though. 

Also cant see them getting a points deduction. The reason being the premier top brass are only interested in how their "brand is viewed. Having a team start the season on -12 Just wouldn't look good in their eyes.

It'll be a fine if they get anything. Dint QPR get £42m?

Possibly a transfer embargo too. That could actually could fuck them up big time if they aren't allowed to bring anyone in. That squad, without it's loan players, wouldn't survive at all.

Surely something has to be done to stop teams blatantly cheating their way to promotion. If not everyone will do it.
The problem with a transfer ban though is that they’ll still end up massively better off financially. Without the ability to sign any players they’ll probably go down, but with the benefit of £100 million plus of PL tv money and years of parachute payments. 

The EFL needed to deal with this weeks ago. If I were Blues I’d be kicking up a huge fuss over this, as they are still the only side to be properly punished over the new regulations.

Clearly it’s too late to deny them promotion, but you could deny them the riches that promotion offers. They should be docked their PL tv money so it drops to EFL levels and their parachute payments revoked.

Why is it 'too late' to deny them promotion.  

That's like saying oh you've stolen a million pounds and spent it so it's too late to prosecute you. 

They should be denied promotion and Derby (unless they're also disqualified) & WBA should play to decide who goes up or if not Derby, Leeds and WBA.

Rightly or wrongly, that is never going to happen. 

They'll get a slap on the wrist, at best.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#33
(05-31-2019, 10:29 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 06:55 AM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 06:49 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules  to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League. 

Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table. 

Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?

Spot on. Stopping promotion won't happen though. 

Also cant see them getting a points deduction. The reason being the premier top brass are only interested in how their "brand is viewed. Having a team start the season on -12 Just wouldn't look good in their eyes.

It'll be a fine if they get anything. Dint QPR get £42m?

Possibly a transfer embargo too. That could actually could fuck them up big time if they aren't allowed to bring anyone in. That squad, without it's loan players, wouldn't survive at all.

Surely something has to be done to stop teams blatantly cheating their way to promotion. If not everyone will do it.
The problem with a transfer ban though is that they’ll still end up massively better off financially. Without the ability to sign any players they’ll probably go down, but with the benefit of £100 million plus of PL tv money and years of parachute payments. 

The EFL needed to deal with this weeks ago. If I were Blues I’d be kicking up a huge fuss over this, as they are still the only side to be properly punished over the new regulations.

Clearly it’s too late to deny them promotion, but you could deny them the riches that promotion offers. They should be docked their PL tv money so it drops to EFL levels and their parachute payments revoked.

Why is it 'too late' to deny them promotion.  

That's like saying oh you've stolen a million pounds and spent it so it's too late to prosecute you. 

They should be denied promotion and Derby (unless they're also disqualified) & WBA should play to decide who goes up or if not Derby, Leeds and WBA.

It’s too late because there is no precedent for a punishment of that magnitude and would lead to a legal challenge from Villa (followed by inevitable appeals to the Court of Arbitration in sport, etc) that would take months and cause chaos elsewhere as the season wouldn’t be able to start until it was all resolved.

They’ve cheated and got away with it. Any token punishment they’re handed will be peanuts compared to the rewards they’re getting.
Reply
#34
A question for Pragmatist. 

If Villa were to get a heavy fine, would that fine have to be included in any FFP calculations, or is it exempt. I.e a hefty fine would mean a lower wage budget to stay within the regulations. 

Otherwise their owner can just absorb the fine, and ultimately it serves no real punishment, does it?
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#35
Fines alone are not enough, they're multi-billionaires. 

12 point deduction at the very least.
Reply
#36
Nothing will happen. It should have been dealt with during last season. It wasn't and wont be now. The game is a s corrupt as any other multi million pound money spinner. Run by gutless wankers.
Reply
#37
If they are found to have breached the rules and benefited from it there should be a points deduction and transfer embargo for two seasons. Both hefty enough to mean that they get relegated from the prem and find it difficult to get anywhere in the chump. They will then have a warchest to spend at the end of it but there's no avoiding that.
Reply
#38
(05-31-2019, 10:34 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: A question for Pragmatist. 

If Villa were to get a heavy fine, would that fine have to be included in any FFP calculations, or is it exempt. I.e a hefty fine would mean a lower wage budget to stay within the regulations. 

Otherwise their owner can just absorb the fine, and ultimately it serves no real punishment, does it?

In QPR's case, I believe the fine is included in their FFP calculations.

In Villa's case the fine would need to be astronomical in order to have any real impact. They've guaranteed themselves £270m minimum by winning promotion, so merely replicating the £40m fine handed to QPR is barely going to register.
Reply
#39
(05-31-2019, 10:34 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: A question for Pragmatist. 

If Villa were to get a heavy fine, would that fine have to be included in any FFP calculations, or is it exempt. I.e a hefty fine would mean a lower wage budget to stay within the regulations. 

Otherwise their owner can just absorb the fine, and ultimately it serves no real punishment, does it?

I’m not sure - but I don’t think it would be counted be counted as an operating cost.

As others have said, with wealthy owners a fine is irrelevant. The penalty must have more impact.
Reply
#40
Id suggest that the governing bodies are more than happy to empty pockets of billionaires and top up their own pension funds, why impose less profitable sanctions?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)