How much is enough?
#71
(06-20-2025, 08:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-20-2025, 07:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: So, to be clear, you’re angry about people being disincentivised in some areas, but want us to lose our best trained medics to countries that will pay them the going rate?

If the tax cliff edges were removed then our best trained medics wouldn't need a 20% pay rise.

If medics choose to take their services overseas that's their right, but you're going to find over the course of this long 5 years with Labour that all kinds of state employees are going to hold hard-pressed average earners to ransom - who've got off pretty lightly in taxation terms in the last 20 years. The optics will be awful.

(06-20-2025, 07:30 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The average UK wage btw is £37.5k

Take home is £27,000 Dear

All part of cleaning up the mess. What are you gonna do
Reply
#72
(06-20-2025, 08:18 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: People are seeing and hearing on a daily basis about the state the NHS is in, they go to hospitals and see staff hanging around, talking about holidays whilst appointments are running three hours behind (all things I've seen in the past 12-months), junior doctors striking for pay, now consultants who earn more than these people ever will, asking for more money, all the while becoming seemingly more and more unreachable in terms of getting an appointment with one.

I've worked in the NHS, I think it's brilliant but I think you're ignoring the 'reality' of what a lot of people are seeing and feeling if you think that this wont piss people off and further entrench them behind anyone who arrives on the scene and says things like "we should sack those who strike" etc.

Optics. Precisely.

And let's not forget last year's huge pay rises came with no strings. We're still awaiting a 10-year NHS plan, so this year's will be without strings too.

(06-20-2025, 08:26 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: All part of cleaning up the mess. What are you gonna do

It's not though is it? If you were really serious about cleaning up the mess you'd be looking at fundamental reform / productivity and tying salary increases to outcomes. Streeting talked a really good game on this before the election and has pretty much Homer-reversed himself into the hedge since then.

I'd love a world class NHS, believe me. But stuffing gold into the mouths of the already wealthy on the back of lower and average earners is a sure fire way of alienating people whilst improving nothing.

(06-20-2025, 08:26 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You probably need to rework your figures on that one Proth. Removing the 100k - 125k removal of PA wouldn't result in an overall 20% pay increase.

And can you pick a number please instead of keep shifting the argument - do you want to talk about Salary, Pay including Overtime or Take Home Pay?

I'd rather you addressed the principle. You won't because you know I'm right.

There are cliff edges at 50K & 100K and in some cases people will earn NOTHING more between £100K - £125K
https://www.rsmuk.com/insights/weekly-ta...r-families
Reply
#73
The areas we always see eye-to-eye on:

People don’t want to hear the truth

People won’t vote for the policies that tackle the reality we are in

What wasn’t helpful:

Making us all worse off feeding people a pack of ideological lies and nonsense over Brexit

The very same people you and others helped convinced was a good idea are now the ones leading us even further down the path of lah lah land
Reply
#74
(06-20-2025, 08:18 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-20-2025, 07:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-20-2025, 07:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Proth might be talking Tufton St but this one is a classic case of the old 'optics'. How does it appear to your man down the pub when you've got people already earning 3x more than they do asking for a pay rise? And we continue to wonder why people purchased further towards Reform etc.

What do you think the average Reform voter would make of the stat that the wealth of the richest man in the world, is around one third of the total GDP of an economically successful country of about 9 million people (Switzerland).

You can label that anyway you want, but what is, is unsustainable without a massive lurch to more authoritarian govt.

And in truth it really doesn't matter what the average Reform voter thinks, it's the opinion of donors to Reform that actually matters.

A) They don't understand.
B) It has no direct (obvious) impact to their lives.

People are seeing and hearing on a daily basis about the state the NHS is in, they go to hospitals and see staff hanging around, talking about holidays whilst appointments are running three hours behind (all things I've seen in the past 12-months), junior doctors striking for pay, now consultants who earn more than these people ever will, asking for more money, all the while becoming seemingly more and more unreachable in terms of getting an appointment with one.

I've worked in the NHS, I think it's brilliant but I think you're ignoring the 'reality' of what a lot of people are seeing and feeling if you think that this wont piss people off and further entrench them behind anyone who arrives on the scene and says things like "we should sack those who strike" etc.

It certainly does affect their lives, huge wealth inequality on that scale makes us all poorer.

And I am sure you are talking about all voters, not Reform voters specifically, not being able to understand.

Don't want to go down that rabbit hole again of Reform/Brexit voters are stupid.
Reply
#75
In the same thread that Proth talks about 'stuffing gold into the mouths of the rich' he also complains about someone on £100k having to pay their own childcare costs. Game's gone Tom.

The principle is that only the terminally stupid or greedy will expect to earn over £100k and still get the government to pay for their kids - the juxtaposition of those that argue for a two child benefit cap and at the same time complain about the rich having to pay for child care must be a tricky maze to work.
Reply
#76
(06-20-2025, 08:41 AM)baggy1 Wrote: In the same thread that Proth talks about 'stuffing gold into the mouths of the rich' he also complains about someone on £100k having to pay their own childcare costs. Game's gone Tom.

You just don't get it do you? Fucking Hell.

If you're just sub £100K WHY WOULD YOU WORK FOR NOTHING?

If you did you'd need to be sectioned.

Christ, people who think like you are actually running the country - and one of them even claims to be an economist.
Reply
#77
Let’s not forget to let our hearts bleed for VAT on private schools while we are getting angry
Reply
#78
(06-20-2025, 08:37 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The very same people you and others helped convinced was a good idea are now the ones leading us even further down the path of lah lah land

Eh? Who?

(06-20-2025, 08:41 AM)baggy1 Wrote: In the same thread that Proth talks about 'stuffing gold into the mouths of the rich' he also complains about someone on £100k having to pay their own childcare costs. Game's gone Tom.

The principle is that only the terminally stupid or greedy will expect to earn over £100k and still get the government to pay for their kids - the juxtaposition of those that argue for a two child benefit cap and at the same time complain about the rich having to pay for child care must be a tricky maze to work.

I am flabbergasted by this. Seriously.

Earn £100K gross and keep your PA and Childcare

Earn £125K and lose both giving you a marginal tax rate of 100% (or more) for £25K worth of earnings.

And you can't see why someone might (should) say, nah I'll just do 4 days?

Growth? Howling.
Reply
#79
I'm afraid that it is you that doesn't get it due to your mindset. You are complaining that someone on over £100k would dare to ask for a pay rise after having their salary frozen for years whilst at the same time arguing that people wouldn't work at over £100k if it meant they lose their childcare - the latter is your mindset, not the average person who will see that they have received a benefit up to that point and can afford it themselves now. Not receiving a handout from the government is not an extra tax and we are talking about a minimal number of people in the country that this applies to, it's a theoretical point based on 4% of earners who have kids needing child care which will greatly reduce that 4%.
Reply
#80
(06-20-2025, 09:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm afraid that it is you that doesn't get it due to your mindset. You are complaining that someone on over £100k would dare to ask for a pay rise after having their salary frozen for years whilst at the same time arguing that people wouldn't work at over £100k if it meant they lose their childcare - the latter is your mindset, not the average person who will see that they have received a benefit up to that point and can afford it themselves now. Not receiving a handout from the government is not an extra tax and we are talking about a minimal number of people in the country that this applies to, it's a theoretical point based on 4% of earners who have kids needing child care which will greatly reduce that 4%.

I'm not complaining about anyone asking for a pay rise. I'm complaining about the fiscal context within which they're asking for it.

Personally I think Free Childcare is madness above a pretty low threshold, but it's the type of entitled welfare Britons have come to depend on. I don't care what your average Joe thinks about affordability for high earners - it doesn't change the fact that if they earned 25% more they'd take home NONE OF IT.

Here's another silent scandal:

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2025/06/19/the-...isnt-paid/

As someone whose paid Corporation Tax correctly and on time for 15 years or more it upsets me greatly that my companies are part of only 3 in 5 that file and pay correctly. 

There's up to £15bn available here annually. Now again, some of that will be disincentives, some will be the VAT threshold but most of it is going to be unpursued avoidance and evasion.

£15bn. And it's getting worse. 

What's Rach doing in a fiscal crisis? Nothing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)