HS2
#21
(06-18-2025, 04:22 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 03:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 03:25 PM)Morley Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

Would a standard railway on the HS2 route be cheaper than the HS2?

Probably the same cost, the effect of the wider loading guage is going to be minimal to none. The biggest issues with HS2 have been abysmal project governance and planning and constantly changing the plan (like a new tunnel under the Chiltern). You might get some benefit from being more flexible with the route not needing to be as straight but that's it.

Don't know anything about HS2 but the issue on these big public sector projects tends to be weak, poor, leadership and governance.  I worked for a while on the aircraft carrier alliance a project that went from a budget of £3.9 Billion, included about £500M contingency, to a final bill of £6.2 Billion and both carriers are still plagued by technical problems.  It was basically run by a committee of people from BAe, Thales and Babcock who couldn't agree on anything, absolute disaster, doesn't seem much better on HS2.

My experience working on HS2 was brief and early on but it was clear that the DfT and HS2 Ltd had no idea what they were doing or actually wanted, from what I've heard from friends working on it or adjacent to it things got worse as basic scopes changed long after works had started (like Euston). You don't massively change fundamental aspects of the scope after the designs have been signed off let alone when works have bloody started when there's no material problems with the scope.

Meanwhile, the people with experience in building high speed rail in the UK having delivered HS1 on time and on budget were blocked from running HS2 for some reason.
Reply
#22
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

And any time saved will be taken up by walking over to Curzon station.

I work in the planning sector. Anyone employed in the Transport Planning sector knows what a joke it is (same with the planned rollout of EV charging stations). I know some very experienced Planning Officers who have left local authorities to work on HS2 stuff as it just easy money to sit in endless meetings for years whilst this bullshit goes through the motions.

The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.
Reply
#23
Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.

If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.

Is it really rocket science?
Reply
#24
I watched six HS2 workers in hi-viz clothing trying to self-scan sandwiches crisps and a meal deal drink in Sainsburys today.  Their engineering prowess was not evident based on the abuse they were shouting at each other.
Reply
#25
(06-18-2025, 06:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.

If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.

Is it really rocket science?

One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.

We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.

(06-18-2025, 06:31 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.

Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.
Reply
#26
(06-18-2025, 07:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 06:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.

If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.

Is it really rocket science?

One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.

We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.

(06-18-2025, 06:31 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.

Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.

It's embarrassing. I lived in Singapore in 2000. They had 2 tube lines with about 50 stations. There are now 6 lines with 160 stations. In London we built one line in the same time frame. I know it's different but come on.
Reply
#27
Birmingham only qualifies as having Mass Rapid Transit because of a disused railway line to connect it to West Brom that the Victorians built could be used by the tram. For a city of 1.1 million people that is embarrassing, Copenhagen is roughly the same population and metro area yet that has built 4 fully autonomous metro lines since 2002 and they're currently building a 5th one. The bloody Greeks built a fully autonomous metro line in their second city that has a smaller metro area than just Birmingham, Greece! It's ridiculous Morley.

I don't think there's a worse country at building anything, loads of useless jobs and idiotic strategic decisions. What sane country builds a high speed rail line on time and on budget and then blocks the people who did that from building the second high speed line? What country gives a licence for a new nuclear power station in 2015 but only signs off funding in 2025?
Reply
#28
(06-18-2025, 07:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 06:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.

If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.

Is it really rocket science?

One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.

We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.

(06-18-2025, 06:31 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.

Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.

With all due respect literally no-one I know or work with would agree with that view and that includes people who work on or have worked in the HS2 project. We have a relatively cheap and numerous options to get between Birmingham and London already.
Reply
#29
Capacity is currently full though to New St. HS2 will offer lots of options and flexibility to London and locally
Reply
#30
(06-18-2025, 08:07 PM)KRO Wrote: Capacity is currently full though to New St. HS2 will offer lots of options and flexibility to London and locally

That’s true actually. Loads of people coming up from London to watch Birmingham City. Said no-one ever.

You get a train from Brum to London or return. None of them are ever full. If you book well in advance it’s between £6.40 on Chiltern or £14 on Avanti. The latter takes less than 80 mins. HS2 promises under an hour. By the time you’ve walked from New St to Curzon St you’ve lost time. It is a nonsense.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)