Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
Quite right too - but the EFL should have dealt with this properly before the playoffs under their own regulations. There is no way that Villa have not breached the 3-year maximum loss limit of £39m including the 2018/9 season.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba...rules.html
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-30-2019, 10:36 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Quite right too - but the EFL should have dealt with this properly before the playoffs under their own regulations. There is no way that Villa have not breached the 3-year maximum loss limit of £39m including the 2018/9 season.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba...rules.html
Guilty along with Derby - Sheff Wed - Dingles
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(05-30-2019, 10:48 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (05-30-2019, 10:36 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Quite right too - but the EFL should have dealt with this properly before the playoffs under their own regulations. There is no way that Villa have not breached the 3-year maximum loss limit of £39m including the 2018/9 season.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba...rules.html
Guilty along with Derby - Sheff Wed - Dingles
I’m not convinced re Dingles being guilty. They brought in several players from Portugal who weren’t on big wages (a third of what McCormick and Richards were on at Villa) and paid them big promotion bonuses which are excluded from FFP as they are only payable conditional upon promotion. Was very clever, but can only be done by convincing players to come and be paid modest wages with no guarantees re a bonus if they don’t go up.
Derby and Wednesday I have serious doubts about - but they didn’t end up getting promoted.
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League.
Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table.
Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?
Posts: 698
Threads: 42
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)ExactlyDreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League.
Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table.
Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?
Exactly!
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League.
Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table.
Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?
Spot on. Stopping promotion won't happen though.
Also cant see them getting a points deduction. The reason being the premier top brass are only interested in how their "brand is viewed. Having a team start the season on -12 Just wouldn't look good in their eyes.
It'll be a fine if they get anything. Dint QPR get £42m?
Possibly a transfer embargo too. That could actually could fuck them up big time if they aren't allowed to bring anyone in. That squad, without it's loan players, wouldn't survive at all.
Surely something has to be done to stop teams blatantly cheating their way to promotion. If not everyone will do it.
Posts: 341
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(05-31-2019, 06:49 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League.
Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table.
Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?
Spot on. Stopping promotion won't happen though.
Also cant see them getting a points deduction. The reason being the premier top brass are only interested in how their "brand is viewed. Having a team start the season on -12 Just wouldn't look good in their eyes.
It'll be a fine if they get anything. Dint QPR get £42m?
Possibly a transfer embargo too. That could actually could fuck them up big time if they aren't allowed to bring anyone in. That squad, without it's loan players, wouldn't survive at all.
Surely something has to be done to stop teams blatantly cheating their way to promotion. If not everyone will do it. The problem with a transfer ban though is that they’ll still end up massively better off financially. Without the ability to sign any players they’ll probably go down, but with the benefit of £100 million plus of PL tv money and years of parachute payments.
The EFL needed to deal with this weeks ago. If I were Blues I’d be kicking up a huge fuss over this, as they are still the only side to be properly punished over the new regulations.
Clearly it’s too late to deny them promotion, but you could deny them the riches that promotion offers. They should be docked their PL tv money so it drops to EFL levels and their parachute payments revoked.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
The jammy fuggers will get away with it, again.
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(05-31-2019, 06:55 AM)ABBaggie Wrote: (05-31-2019, 06:49 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-31-2019, 12:33 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Surely if Villa face a points deduction next season, that’s an acknowledgement that they broke the rules to get promotion. I know I’m kind of preaching to the converted here, but surely the punishment for that should be that they’re denied access to the Premier League.
Even if you deducted them 50 points next season to make sure they go back down again, you’re still not addressing the point that another team has been denied their rightful place at the top table.
Does any fucker give a shit about what’s right and what’s wrong these days?
Spot on. Stopping promotion won't happen though.
Also cant see them getting a points deduction. The reason being the premier top brass are only interested in how their "brand is viewed. Having a team start the season on -12 Just wouldn't look good in their eyes.
It'll be a fine if they get anything. Dint QPR get £42m?
Possibly a transfer embargo too. That could actually could fuck them up big time if they aren't allowed to bring anyone in. That squad, without it's loan players, wouldn't survive at all.
Surely something has to be done to stop teams blatantly cheating their way to promotion. If not everyone will do it. The problem with a transfer ban though is that they’ll still end up massively better off financially. Without the ability to sign any players they’ll probably go down, but with the benefit of £100 million plus of PL tv money and years of parachute payments.
The EFL needed to deal with this weeks ago. If I were Blues I’d be kicking up a huge fuss over this, as they are still the only side to be properly punished over the new regulations.
Clearly it’s too late to deny them promotion, but you could deny them the riches that promotion offers. They should be docked their PL tv money so it drops to EFL levels and their parachute payments revoked.
That's actually a very good idea and simple idea. It would require a rule change though so again they will get away with it this year as they could mount a legal challenge saying it's unfair etc etc.
They are going to get a slap on the wrists. We all know it.
If I were Blues I'd be absolutely fuming.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
|