Ahmedabad Plane Crash
#21
Seat 11A

Truly a miracle.
Reply
#22
(06-12-2025, 06:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: It's a hard watch. Awful. The guy that survived was apparently sitting next to his brother, what with grief and PTSD I pity the poor guy.

Poor sod. I actually wonder if being the sole survivor is actually crueller than dying.
Reply
#23
Survivor's guilt PTSD is absolutely awful, I've known a few suffer from it and honestly, it never resolves.
Reply
#24
An awful sight - looks like human or power failure error from the way it just glided down, but rare double engine failure could be a reason. The dream liner has so many fail safe warning alarms that would have alerted the very experienced pilots of what dangers the aircraft was in. Hard to imagine no emergency action appeared to take place
What ever the reasons we pray for all the lost souls.
Reply
#25
I read somewhere yesterday that on the video it appears that the flaps are retracted, meaning the plane never had a chance to climb. As said previously a bit early to speculate but that strongly suggests pilot error. Simply a terrible tragedy whatever the cause and it is heartbreaking to see the impact this is having on the families involved.
Reply
#26
If it was pilot error, then surely the co-pilot would have picked up on the error? It seems very unlikely to me that two extremely experienced and qualified people would make that kinda of error.

Am I right in thinking there is always two pilots in the cockpit to negate this kind of issue?

Although, I think any cause would seem very unlikely, as that's kind of the point in air travel. It's so safe that whatever issue caused this crash would seem improbable and ridiculously unlikely.
Reply
#27
(06-13-2025, 07:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: If it was pilot error, then surely the co-pilot would have picked up on the error? It seems very unlikely to me that two extremely experienced and qualified people would make that kinda of error.

Am I right in thinking there is always two pilots in the cockpit to negate this kind of issue?

Although, I think any cause would seem very unlikely, as that's kind of the point in air travel. It's so safe that whatever issue caused this crash would seem improbable and ridiculously unlikely.

Perhaps, but at 35,000 ft you have time to appraise the situation and act. At a mere 600 or so it's a matter of seconds. Even if they weren't at fault for whatever went wrong, they simply had no time to react. 

Could easily be any number of factors. Just ever so odd given that it's a pretty safe plane with no fatalities in almost 15 years.
Reply
#28
(06-13-2025, 07:25 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I read somewhere yesterday that on the video it appears that the flaps are retracted, meaning the plane never had a chance to climb. As said previously a bit early to speculate but that strongly suggests pilot error. Simply a terrible tragedy whatever the cause and it is heartbreaking to see the impact this is having on the families involved.

I dont think thats possible on take-off. The flap settings are set before push-back, based on weight, runway length, weather etc, and are triple-checked by both pilots and ground crew. This info is fed into the aircrafts flight computer, and the aircraft will sound warnings if these settings aren't applied or aren't set at take-off. I believe its almost impossible to override that.
Reply
#29
There is a video doing the rounds of someone who was on the same plane on the flight into the airport a few hours before this crash showing some electrical issues throughout the cabin. It's not been varified I don't think but if true that's another possibility.

They have recovered the black box so hopefully some answers.

If at all possible (I know they can't give details) but I think it would be best if they could quickly rule out issues with the plane itself as that would reassure people a little, however the longer it does go on the more likely it is an issue with the plane itself IMO.
Reply
#30
How many pilots would there have been in the cockpit at take off?

2, 3 or 4?

The pilot was very experienced, so I would look more at technical failures over human error, at a guess.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: